Chapter summaries I Think We've Been Here Before Suzy Krause

Chapter 7 (6) Summary and Analysis: The Burden of Prophecy

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

When Marlen was nine, his friend explained that anyone could be a prophet—just speak a prediction about someone else and see if it comes true. Marlen reluctantly prophesied that his friend would be hit in the head with a baseball. Two days later, a football struck the boy, convincing Marlen he might have genuine foresight. He forgot about the incident for decades.

About a year before his cancer diagnosis, Marlen woke with a sudden, urgent feeling: I need to write my book. The underlying impression was that he didn't have much time left. He had always dreamed of writing a novel, and this time he acted. Secretly, during school breaks and lunch hours, he wrote a story about a gamma ray burst that destroys Earth. The idea had first come to him as a teenager. He completed 70,000 words in nine months and arranged to publish through a small local subsidy press, intending to surprise his wife, Hilda, with a printed copy.

Now that his terminal cancer has been confirmed, Marlen sees himself as a prophet: he foresaw his own death. But the arrival of the book feels awkward. He fears that giving people a story about dying—especially one in which Hilda dies—will seem irreverent, like offering a tale of death from a man who is himself dying. He struggles to find the right moment to share it, when now is too soon and there is no later.

Key Events

  • At age nine, Marlen's friend tells him anyone can be a prophet; Marlen prophesies the friend will be hit in the head.
  • Two days later, the friend is struck by a football, seemingly fulfilling the prophecy.
  • Decades later, Marlen awakens with an urgent compulsion to write the novel he has always dreamed of.
  • He secretly writes the novel—about a gamma ray burst ending the world—during work spares and lunch breaks.
  • He arranges publication with a small subsidy press, planning the printed copies as a surprise for his wife.
  • After his terminal cancer diagnosis, Marlen reflects on his prophetic ability and worries the book's timing is inappropriate.
  • He questions when to give the book to others, as now feels too soon and there will be no later.

Character Development

  • Marlen: The chapter deepens his complexity. As a child he was curious and impulsive, willing to risk damnation for a glimpse of prophecy. As an adult, he is secretive and driven by a sense of impending doom. His decision to write the book reveals a man trying to leave a legacy and process his own mortality, yet he remains uncertain about how to navigate the social awkwardness of his gift turned burden.
  • Hilda: Although she does not appear directly, Marlen's thoughts reveal his deep affection for her. The novel was intended as a love letter, and he is sensitive to how she might interpret Hilda's death in the story.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Prophecy and Inevitability: Marlen's childhood prediction and his later conviction about his death suggest a recurring motif of foresight. The chapter questions whether prophecy is a supernatural gift or a heightened awareness of one's own trajectory.
  • Creative Urgency in the Face of Death: The compulsion to write the book becomes a way for Marlen to process his mortality. The novel, which ends the world, mirrors his personal ending.
  • Irreverence and Timing: Marlen’s worry that the book will seem tasteless taps into the motif of social propriety clashing with raw emotional truth. He faces an impossible choice: give the book now (too soon) or never (too late).
  • The Book as Memento Mori: The printed novel represents both a lifelong achievement and a tangible reminder of death. It is a physical object that will outlast him, carrying the weight of his prophecy.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is crucial because it reveals the origin and true purpose of the novel Marlen has been secretly writing. It connects his childhood experience of prophecy to his adult life, solidifying his belief that he has a special kind of foresight—one that now includes his own death. The chapter also highlights Marlen's vulnerability: he is not simply a wise man facing cancer, but a conflicted husband trying to leave the right kind of gift. The uncomfortable timing of the book’s arrival adds a layer of dark comedy and pathos, deepening the novel’s exploration of grief and human connection.

Study Questions and Answers

1. How does Marlen's childhood experience with prophecy shape his understanding of his cancer diagnosis?
Marlen interprets his childhood prediction—that his friend would be hit in the head—as evidence that he has prophetic ability. Later, the urgent feeling to write his book (and the underlying awareness that he doesn't have much time) becomes for him a second prophecy. When the cancer is confirmed, he sees this as proof that he foresaw his own death, rather than simply accepting it as a medical fact.

2. Why does Marlen worry that giving his book to friends and family would be irreverent?
He imagines the reverse scenario: if a friend had written a book about him dying of cancer and offered it after his diagnosis, he would have found it inappropriate. He concludes that his own novel—which features his wife's death and a world-ending disaster—feels too raw and tactless to share when his terminal illness is fresh news.

3. What does the novel's content (a gamma ray burst destroying Earth) reveal about Marlen's state of mind before he knew he was sick?
The gamma ray burst plot, which he conceived as a teenager, suggests that Marlen has long been preoccupied with catastrophic endings. The fact that he wrote it urgently when he sensed his time was limited indicates that he subconsciously connected his own impending death with a larger, inevitable destruction. The novel serves as a metaphor for his personal extinction, processed through a cosmic lens.

Navigation