Chapter summaries I Think We've Been Here Before Suzy Krause

Chapter 4 Summary: The Schnitzelkönig Dinner

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.


Summary

When Nora returns to her Berlin apartment, her roommates Petra and Sonja are waiting on the couch with a phone. The three women met online, a fact that still worries Nora's mother Hilda. Petra, a sharp‑voiced German molecular‑medicine student, has decided to buy dinner for the group as a welcome meal. She shows Nora the take‑out menu from Schnitzelkönig, written entirely in German. Nora cannot read it and feels embarrassed, but Petra eventually translates—too quickly. Panicked, Nora picks item #85. Petra leaves to place the order, and her loud phone voice confirms Sonja's earlier warning about Petra's temper.

Sonja tells Nora that Petra is extreme and that she yells at everyone, advising Nora to respect Petra's boundaries. Nora, an only child who has never yelled, nods along while feeling her anxiety spike. She sinks into a flea‑market armchair and cuddles her cat, a dependence she hadn't anticipated. Her cat soon escapes.

When Petra returns calm, she pins Nora with a comment about them not having gotten to know one another. Nora's phone rings—her mother again. Petra, amused, remarks that Nora is always on the phone with her mother. Nora slips into her bedroom to take the call but finds it has gone to voicemail. She sits on the bed and wonders what everyone would say if she moved home after only one week.


Key Events

  • Nora enters her apartment to find roommates Petra and Sonja on the couch.
  • Petra orders take‑out from Schnitzelkönig as a welcome meal; Nora cannot read the German menu and selects a random number.
  • Petra's loud phone call reveals her aggressive personality, and Sonja warns Nora about Petra's tendencies.
  • Nora's cat provides temporary comfort, then escapes, mirroring Nora's own unease.
  • Petra makes a pointed observation about Nora's frequent calls to her mother, deepening Nora's feeling of being judged.
  • Nora escapes to her bedroom and considers the possibility of moving home.

Character Development

  • Nora – Her desire to be liked forces her to downplay Petra's sharpness. She feels vulnerable and childlike, dependent on her cat and her mother. The chapter shows her struggling to assert herself in a new environment.
  • Petra – Introduced as intimidating, judgmental, and direct. Her severity is hinted at through her vocal fry, thick glasses, and the way she says “She is always on the phone with her mother.” She seems aware of the effect she has on Nora.
  • Sonja – Warm and gossipy, she acts as a buffer between Nora and Petra, offering practical advice about living with Petra without sugarcoating her flaws.
  • Hilda (Nora's mother) – Though not physically present, her anxious phone calls frame the mother–daughter dynamic and contrast Nora's attempt at independence.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Anxiety of the new – Nora's inability to read the menu, her panicked choice of #85, and her retreat to her bedroom all illustrate the stress of starting over in an unfamiliar city.
  • Dependence vs. independence – Nora clings to her cat and her mother, yet wonders what it would mean to give up and go home. The cat's quick escape mirrors Nora's own desire to flee the uncomfortable situation.
  • Perception vs. reality – The online advertisements promised compatible roommates, but Petra's actual behavior is harsh. Nora glosses over it to maintain harmony, a trait she identifies as both a strength and a flaw.
  • Mother‑daughter connection – Hilda's constant calls represent a safety net but also a leash, making Nora feel like a child at a sleepover. Petra's comment highlights Nora's ongoing reliance on her mother.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 4 establishes the core tension of Nora's Berlin life: a roommate dynamic that feels threatening rather than welcoming. Petra emerges as a force Nora must navigate, and Sonja becomes an ally. The chapter deepens Nora's internal conflict between staying and retreating, a question that will likely drive later plot decisions. It also shows Krause's skill at conveying anxiety through small, everyday moments—a menu, a phone call, a cat's jump.


Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Nora select item #85 without knowing what it is?
Nora is overwhelmed by the German menu and Petra's rapid translation. She panics and chooses a random number because she does not want to seem indecisive or cause further inconvenience.

2. What does Nora's interaction with her cat reveal about her emotional state?
She hugs the cat tightly and feels dependent on it for comfort, yet the cat quickly escapes. This mirrors Nora's own wish to flee the uncomfortable scene, as well as her awareness that her need for security may be one‑sided.

3. How does Petra's observation "She is always on the phone with her mother" affect Nora?
The comment makes Nora feel judged and childlike, reinforcing her insecurity about fitting in. It also prompts her to question whether she is too reliant on her mother—even imagining what others would say if she moved home.


Navigation