Chapter summaries I Think We've Been Here Before Suzy Krause

Chapter 52: 50 – Hank Gets a Call from Ole

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Hank has been frantically searching for his son Ole, who went missing. While sitting on the side of the road, out of ideas and drained of hope, his phone rings. It is Ole. Hank feels a chaotic mix of rage and relief. He yells at Ole, asking where he is, but before Ole can answer, Hank’s phone battery dies. Hank realizes the phone had not been charged—a metaphor for the way he has neglected himself during the search. He rushes home, where Irene is baking Christmas lefse, clinging to normalcy. When Hank bursts in with the news, Irene initially does not connect it to Ole. After he explains, they both stare at the dead phone. Once it reboots, they check recent calls and discover Ole called from Iver’s landline. The chapter ends with that stunning revelation.

Key Events

  • Hank receives a call from Ole, who says he is fine.
  • Hank’s phone dies before he can learn Ole’s location.
  • Hank drives home recklessly, sliding on ice.
  • Irene is in the kitchen baking lefse, trying to preserve Christmas traditions.
  • Hank tells Irene about the call; she reacts with shock and tears.
  • The phone reboots and they see the call came from Iver’s landline.

Character Development

  • Hank: Experiences a whirlwind of uncontrolled emotions—rage, relief, panic. His inability to keep his phone charged reflects his lack of self-care and single‑minded focus. When he reaches home, he is physically and emotionally spent, revealing how much the search has taken from him.
  • Irene: Clings to baking and holiday preparations as a way to cope with uncertainty. She has been suppressing hope and fear, and the news of Ole’s call shatters her composure, causing her to cry without realizing it. Her steady exterior cracks.
  • Ole: Although not physically present, his brief call shows he is alive and able to reach out, but he hangs up before giving his location, maintaining the mystery of his whereabouts.
  • Iver: Referenced only as the owner of the landline—his phone becomes the unexpected clue linking Ole’s disappearance to a possible connection with Iver.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Time running out: Hank’s phone battery dying and the gas tank nearly empty are explicit metaphors for his dwindling resources and the urgency of finding Ole before it is too late.
  • Hope versus despair: The rapid swings between rage and relief in Hank’s mind, and Irene’s hesitant hope that today might be different, illustrate the emotional whiplash of living in uncertainty.
  • Communication breakdown: A phone call from Ole should bring clarity, but the dead battery and cut‑off conversation only deepen the mystery. The family’s inability to communicate effectively is a running motif.
  • Christmas traditions as anchor: Irene’s insistence on baking lefse—Ole’s favorite—represents her need to keep normal rituals alive even as her world falls apart. The lefse becomes a symbol of the family she is trying to hold together.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 52 is a turning point. For the first time, the reader learns Ole is alive and has chosen to call his father. The call eases the immediate fear of harm but raises more questions: Why won’t Ole come home? Why has he gone to Iver? The discovery of the landline number ties Ole’s disappearance to Iver, a character whose involvement up to now has been ambiguous. This chapter also showcases the emotional toll on Hank and Irene, and it forces them to confront what they have been repressing. The cliffhanger of the landline propels the narrative toward the final chapters.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Hank’s phone dying at that moment matter for the story?
Hank’s phone dies before Ole can reveal his location, heightening the tension and delaying resolution. It also symbolizes Hank’s neglect of the ordinary tasks (charging his phone, keeping gas in the truck) that have fallen by the wayside as he obsessed over finding Ole.

2. What does Irene’s baking of lefse reveal about her state of mind?
Irene bakes lefse because it is Ole’s favorite Christmas food. The act helps her feel she is contributing to Ole’s return: Hank will bring him home, and she will feed him. It shows she clings to hope through ritual, even as she admits she had no good reason to feel hopeful that day—highlighting her internal conflict.

3. What is the significance of the call coming from Iver’s landline?
Iver is a character whose past and present have been intertwined with the family. The landline call connects Ole’s disappearance directly to Iver, suggesting that Ole went to Iver willingly or that Iver knows where Ole is. This revelation shifts the search from random locations to a known person and creates a new avenue for the plot.

Navigate the Chapter