Chapter summaries I Think We've Been Here Before Suzy Krause

Chapter 69 Summary: The Reunion and Harry's Warning

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

When Nora's family arrives home, the reunion is tense. Marlen is visibly unwell, and Nora initially feels angry that no one warned her. However, she quickly realizes she would have done the same in his place, and she chooses forgiveness because time is short. Marlen shakes Jacob's hand and states he has met Jacob before, though Jacob denies it. No explanation is offered.

The mood lightens as they tour the house and admire Hilda's murals—a family portrait in the kitchen, clouds in the bathroom, and birds in Nora's bedroom. Nora is amazed at her mother's hidden talent. Marlen rolls his eyes good-naturedly at Hilda's modesty, and this familiar banter makes Nora feel truly home. Nora then asks about Derek; Marlen admits he hates him, and Hilda refrains from her usual playful smack, a small adjustment that shows her sensitivity to Marlen's condition.

Finally, Nora and Hilda tell Marlen about Harry's prediction. Because Marlen knows Harry's track record, he takes it seriously. They grab their go bags and head for the car, planning to drive to Irene's. Hilda reflects that this feels like having a baby: the hospital bag is packed, the due date is set, and the baby is coming early—ready or not.

Key Events

  • The family returns home and finds Marlen unwell.
  • Nora forgives Marlen quickly, reflecting the theme of fast forgiveness.
  • Marlen shakes Jacob's hand and insists they have met before, but Jacob disagrees.
  • Hilda's murals are revealed throughout the house, showcasing her artistic skill.
  • Nora learns that Marlen hates Derek, and Hilda adapts her behavior to avoid hurting Marlen.
  • Marlen is informed of Harry's prediction and immediately agrees to go to Irene's.
  • The family packs go bags and leaves, with Hilda comparing the urgency to an early birth.

Character Development

  • Nora demonstrates emotional maturity by forgiving Marlen without resentment. She also notices and tries not to dwell on Hilda's adjustments, showing her growing awareness of her parents' coping strategies.
  • Marlen is physically unwell but mentally sharp—he recognizes Jacob and bluntly states his hatred for Derek. His willingness to act on Harry's prediction shows his trust in Harry's foresight.
  • Hilda reveals a hidden artistic talent through her murals. Her self-deprecating modesty and the subtle change in how she interacts with Marlen (avoiding physical touch) highlight her devotion and attentiveness.
  • Jacob remains confused by Marlen's claim of prior acquaintance, adding a layer of mystery.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Forgiveness as urgency: The chapter emphasizes that forgiveness must come quickly because time is limited, a recurring theme in the book.
  • Memory and déjà vu: Marlen's insistence that he has met Jacob before echoes the book's title, "I Think We've Been Here Before," and suggests a cyclical or recurring connection.
  • Family bonds: The good-natured arguing between Marlen and Hilda, and Hilda's small adjustments, show deep family love and adaptability.
  • Impending doom: The preparation of go bags and Hilda's birth metaphor signal that the family is bracing for a significant event, likely tied to Harry's prediction.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter solidifies the family's unity and their decision to act on Harry's warning, propelling the narrative toward its climax. It deepens the mystery of Marlen's condition and his possible connection to Jacob, while reinforcing the importance of forgiveness and cherishing limited time. Hilda's murals also humanize her character, revealing a creative side she had kept hidden.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Nora forgive Marlen for not warning her about his condition?
    Nora realizes she would have done the same in his shoes. She also understands that given their limited time, anger must be set aside quickly.

  2. What is the significance of Hilda's murals in this chapter?
    The murals reveal Hilda's artistic talent and provide a moment of beauty and normalcy amid the family's stress. They also symbolize the hidden depths in the characters and the home they've built together.

  3. Why does Marlen believe Harry's prediction and decide to leave immediately?
    Marlen knows Harry's track record for accurate predictions. His trust in Harry overrides any skepticism, and he acts urgently, just as the family did earlier with the go bags.

Navigation