Chapter summaries I Think We've Been Here Before Suzy Krause

Chapter 40 (38): Iver’s Backup Plan and the Price of Asking for Help

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.


Summary

After Walmart cancels his order for arcade machines, Iver turns to Plan B: contacting Elsie, his deceased wife’s best friend, whose son owns an arcade in a nearby town. Iver dreads the conversation because Elsie’s bubbly, relentless optimism has always irritated him. He accidentally misdials and lands a cheerful call with Alfie instead, then redials to reach Elsie. After strained small talk about her great-grandchildren and her son’s recent decision to close the arcade, Iver bluntly asks for the machines. Elsie agrees to ask her son, but only after Iver lies that he has missed her too—a small social debt he reluctantly pays to secure the favor. The chapter ends with Iver feeling relieved and slightly guilty, aware that his lie bought him the help he needed.


Key Events

# Event
1 Iver receives a Walmart cancellation email filled with a spelling error (“invoncenience”).
2 He decides to enact Plan B: contacting Elsie to acquire arcade machines from her son’s now-closed business.
3 First dial lands at Alfie’s; Iver exchanges pleasantries and agrees to meet at the Pot Hole.
4 Second dial reaches Elsie. Iver struggles through awkward small talk about her great-grandchildren and the funeral.
5 Elsie reveals her son closed the arcade because employees quit after “the news” (the impending end of the world).
6 Iver asks to buy or take the machines; Elsie initially dismisses the idea, saying they can just burn.
7 Iver shouts her name to keep her on the phone, then explains the machines are a very important gift.
8 Elsie agrees to ask her son, and Iver lies that he has missed her too, effectively repaying the favor.

Character Development

Iver – This chapter deepens Iver’s portrait as a man who prefers isolation and self-sufficiency. His irritation with Elsie is visceral (“irritates him on a cellular level”), yet he forces himself to be civil and even lie to accomplish his goal. The lie about missing her is a small but meaningful concession—he bends his rigid emotional boundaries because the gift matters. His memory of the funeral (seeing Elsie’s look across the church, the casket making him truly understand “permanent”) shows that his grief remains raw, and Elsie is a living reminder of that loss.

Elsie – Her relentless cheerfulness and inability to read the room are on full display. She cheerfully mentions the funeral twice by mistake, describes the end of the world as a “bonfire,” and calls the arcade machines “old things” that can burn. Yet she is not malicious; she genuinely misses Iver and immediately offers to help once he insists. Her character challenges Iver’s perception of her as merely annoying—he admits she has never hurt him and that his dislike may make him the bad person.

Alfie (briefly) – Though she appears only on a misdial, her warmth contrasts with Elsie’s energy. Iver’s remark that “Alfie is always everywhere” suggests she is a comforting, ever-present figure in his life, a stark contrast to the discomfort he feels with Elsie.


Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Plans and backups – Iver’s shift from Plan A (Walmart) to Plan B (Elsie) mirrors the larger theme of adapting to the end of the world. Technology fails (cancelled order, spelling errors), forcing him to rely on personal connections he would rather avoid.

Social debt and currency – With money rendered meaningless at the end of the world, transactions become social and emotional. Iver repays Elsie with a lie (“I’ve missed you, too”) because “no need to repay friends” is the new currency. The lie is a cheap but effective coin.

Irritation vs. obligation – Iver’s cellular-level annoyance with Elsie represents the friction between his desire for solitude and the social obligations that persist even at the end of the world. He must choose connection—even fake connection—to get what he wants.

Memory and grief – The repeated references to the funeral (the look across the church, the casket) tie Iver’s present discomfort to his unresolved grief. Elsie is a living link to his wife, which is part of why he avoids her.


Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is a turning point for Iver’s arc. Up to now, he has mostly reacted to the end-of-world announcements from a distance. Here, he actively pursues a gift for someone (likely his son), showing that he cares deeply despite his gruff exterior. The chapter also introduces Elsie as a recurring character who will likely play a role in the climax—her son’s arcade machines become a concrete symbol of Iver’s effort to create meaning in the final days. The small lie he tells (missing Elsie) suggests that Iver is capable of bending his principles for love, a theme that may reappear.


Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Iver dislike Elsie so much, and does the chapter suggest his feelings are justified?
Iver dislikes Elsie purely because her personality grates on him—she is loud, optimistic, and oblivious to social cues. The chapter reveals that she has never hurt him or his wife, and Iver suspects his dislike makes him “the bad person.” The reader may see Elsie as genuinely kind but socially clumsy, suggesting Iver’s reaction is more about his own grief and discomfort than anything she has done.

2. What does the Walmart cancellation email reveal about the state of the world in the story?
The email’s spelling error (“invoncenience”) and the blunt statement that orders “may not be delivered” show that infrastructure is collapsing. Companies are understaffed and careless because everyone knows the world is ending. Iver’s indignation at the error (“idiotic decadence of spelling errors”) highlights his own adherence to standards that no longer matter to most people.

3. How does Iver “pay” Elsie for her help, and what does this scene say about relationships at the end of the world?
Iver lies that he has missed Elsie, offering an emotional debt rather than money. The scene illustrates that with currency useless, relationships become transactional in new ways—people trade favors, time, and attention. Iver’s lie also shows that he values the gift enough to compromise his honesty, suggesting that love (or the desire to leave a meaningful gesture) can override personal integrity.


Navigate