Chapter summaries I Think We've Been Here Before Suzy Krause

Chapter 41 (39): The Berlin Decoration Project – Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

While Mr. Schmidt (Jacob) noisily tears apart a newspaper to get at the crossword puzzle, he explains to Mrs. Schmidt (Nora) that he wants to keep his mind sharp. Nora admits she has nothing to do and feels restless, comparing the sensation to dangling her feet over a cliff edge. Sensing her unease, Jacob tells her he has news: he claims he studied art design and has received a call from Berlin’s mayor, Franziska Giffey, who wants him to decorate the city for Christmas by November 18. He says he agreed and enlisted Nora’s help. Nora laughs at the absurdity but plays along, recognizing that this imaginative game is Jacob’s way of taking care of her mentally. She reflects on the nature of independence versus dependence, wondering if Petra would think her weak for letting Jacob care for her, and ultimately concludes that true marriage might be about reciprocal care.

Key Events

  • Jacob destroys the newspaper to retrieve the crossword puzzle, prompting a joking exchange with Nora.
  • Nora confesses she feels aimless and unsettled, comparing her state to sitting on a cliff edge.
  • Jacob announces that he has been hired by Berlin’s mayor to decorate the entire city for Christmas, a project that must be finished by November 18.
  • He claims he studied art design and that a former professor recommended him to the mayor.
  • Nora initially questions the truth of the story but then accepts the imaginary scenario without resistance.
  • Jacob says he needs Nora’s help because “Berlin is quite large,” extending their game of pretend into a collaborative effort.
  • The chapter ends with Nora reflecting on the value of reciprocal dependence in their relationship.

Character Development

Nora (Mrs. Schmidt): Nora experiences a shift from boredom and anxiety to tentative acceptance of support. She is aware of her reliance on Jacob and judges herself through the imagined lens of Petra’s independence. Yet she allows herself to be cared for, recognizing that emotional support does not equate to weakness. This internal debate shows Nora wrestling with societal expectations of self-sufficiency.

Jacob (Mr. Schmidt): Jacob continues his role as the playful, imaginative partner. He reads Nora’s emotional state and responds by creating an elaborate fiction that gives her purpose. His “news” about the mayor is not meant to deceive but to distract and soothe. Jacob’s sensitivity to Nora’s fragility and his willingness to include her in the project reveal his deep commitment to her well-being.

Petra (referenced): Though not present, Petra’s influence lingers. Nora wonders how Petra would judge her for being emotionally dependent, highlighting the tension between the two women’s views on independence.

Themes, Symbols, and Motifs

Interdependence vs. Independence: The chapter directly questions what it means to be independent. Nora feels lonely and incomplete when left to herself; she begins to see that a healthy relationship involves mutual support. The idea that “adults take care of each other” reframes dependence as a positive, reciprocal arrangement.

Imaginative Escape: Jacob’s fictional commission is a coping mechanism for the looming apocalypse. By focusing on a grand, creative project, both characters avoid dwelling on the end of the world. The absurdity of decorating all of Berlin highlights the need for hope and purpose in dire times.

Mental Care: Nora explicitly notes that Jacob is caring for her brain, not her physical needs. The theme of mental health surfaces as the characters find small ways to tend to each other’s psychological well-being.

The Cliff Metaphor: Nora’s image of dangling over a cliff captures the sustained dread of living in uncertainty. The initial thrill has turned into a “nauseating drone,” symbolizing the emotional toll of waiting for disaster.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 41 deepens the intimate bond between Nora and Jacob while addressing the central question of the novel: how do people sustain hope when the world is ending? Through a single, lighthearted conversation, Krause illustrates that survival often depends on shared imagination and mutual support. Nora’s internal reconciliation with accepting help moves her character forward, setting up a potential contrast with Petra’s fierce independence. The chapter also introduces a specific timeline (November 18) that may become significant in future events, giving the story a concrete goal.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Jacob tear up the newspaper, and what does this reveal about his character?
    Jacob tears the paper to extract the crossword puzzle, discarding the rest because he wants to avoid news of the apocalypse. This reveals his intentional focus on mental stimulation and his strategy of willful ignorance as a survival technique. He prioritizes keeping his mind sharp over staying informed.

  2. How does Nora’s view of independence change during this chapter?
    Nora initially craves independence but finds it lonely and unfulfilling. After experiencing Jacob’s care, she questions whether independence truly means being alone. She concludes that reciprocal dependence—taking care of each other—may be the healthier and more realistic model for a relationship, especially in a crisis.

  3. What purpose does the imaginary decoration project serve for both characters?
    The project gives Nora a sense of purpose and distracts her from anxiety, while for Jacob it is a way to channel his creativity and tend to Nora’s mental health. It reinforces their partnership: by including Nora as his helper, Jacob ensures they face the uncertain future together, turning dread into collaboration.

Navigation