Chapter summaries Any Way the Wind Blows Rainbow Rowell

Chapter 21: Penelope’s Crisis of Confidence

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Penelope wakes to urgent texts from Simon about a “magickal thing,” but she dismisses him and goes back to sleep. Later, Shepard brings her a vegan sausage roll and recounts his morning wandering London, even meeting neighbors in her building. Penelope is horrified that Shepard has been interacting with Normals and decides she must send him home. Shepard, however, argues that Penelope is a heroic, wise witch—the first person to ever sincerely offer him help with his demon tattoos. Penelope rejects the praise, confessing that she only creates problems, not solutions. She cites the disastrous road trip, being dumped multiple times by Simon without realizing it, and killing vampires in front of a camera. She insists she is an idiot who makes bad decisions. Eventually Shepard accepts her decision, and Penelope agrees to send him back to Omaha (with counterfeit money if he chooses). Shepard leaves the room, still grateful for the hope she once gave him.

Key Events

  • Penelope wakes to Simon’s middle-of-the-night texts about a “magickal problem” and tells him to contact her mother instead.
  • Shepard brings breakfast and cheerfully describes his unauthorized exploration of London, including meeting an either/orc family in her building.
  • Penelope realizes she has been neglecting Shepard and decides he must leave to protect magickal secrecy.
  • Penelope tries to send Shepard home, listing her failures: getting dumped without knowing it, causing the disastrous road trip, killing vampires on camera, and being captured repeatedly.
  • Shepard counters every point, insisting she is a “wise and powerful witch” and that her friends treat her like a Jedi Master.
  • Penelope breaks down, admitting her low self-worth and that she is not the hero Shepard believes in.
  • Shepard finally relents, and Penelope agrees to send him back to Omaha, giving him the option of Las Vegas with counterfeit money.
  • Shepard leaves with warm gratitude, still appreciative of her initial willingness to help.

Character Development

  • Penelope Bunce: This chapter strips away Penelope’s usual confident competence. She expresses deep insecurity, believing she only creates chaos. Her refusal to accept Shepard’s praise shows a vulnerable, self-critical side that contrasts sharply with the take-charge witch from earlier chapters.
  • Shepard Livingstone: Shepard reveals his genuine admiration for Penelope. His persistence in defending her goodness shows he is not merely charming but also perceptive and loyal. He demonstrates emotional intelligence by recognizing when to stop arguing and gracefully accepting her decision.
  • Simon Snow (offstage): Simon’s texts—and Penelope’s dismissal of them—highlight the continued strain in their relationship. Penelope’s mention of being dumped “multiple times” without realizing it underscores the emotional damage Simon’s past behavior has caused.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Self‑Doubt vs. Heroism: Penelope’s inner monologue and dialogue contradict Shepard’s image of her as a hero. The chapter questions what makes someone a hero—intention or outcome—and shows how even capable people can feel like frauds.
  • Secrecy and Rules of Magic: Penelope’s horror at Shepard talking to Normals and the mention of her ring being at risk for public magic reinforce the theme of magickal secrecy. The culture of hiding magic creates tension between helping Normals and following the law.
  • Friendship and Gratitude: Shepard’s gratitude, even after being sent away, contrasts with Penelope’s self‑flagellation. His forgiveness suggests that the value of a genuine offer of help is not erased by later failure.
  • The Sausage Roll as Comfort: The vegan sausage roll Shepard brings is a small, mundane act of care that punctures Penelope’s despair. It symbolizes the grounding effect of friendship, even when the friend is the one being rejected.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 21 is a turning point for Penelope’s arc. It forces her to confront the consequences of her impulsive decisions and the damage to her self‑image. It also temporarily removes Shepard from the immediate narrative, setting up a more isolated Penelope for the chapters ahead. The chapter deepens the theme of failure and redemption, showing that Penelope’s greatest challenge may not be external monsters but her own inner critic. Shepard’s departure—done with grace rather than resentment—leaves the door open for him to return later.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Penelope reject Shepard’s description of her as a “heroic person”?
Penelope lists specific reasons: she got herself and her friends into dangerous situations, she was unaware that Simon had dumped her multiple times, her vampire‑killing is probably on YouTube (risking her ring), and she was captured repeatedly after that. She sees herself as someone who creates problems, not solutions.

2. What does Shepard’s response to Penelope’s self‑criticism reveal about him?
Despite Penelope’s arguments, Shepard remains steadfast in his belief in her goodness. He points out that she is the first magickal person to offer him real help, that she tried to wipe his memory (which she did), and that her friends treat her like a Jedi Master. This shows Shepard is perceptive, loyal, and values intention over messy outcomes.

3. How does Penelope’s decision to send Shepard home relate to the theme of magickal secrecy?
Penelope is horrified that Shepard has spoken to Normals, including the either/orc family downstairs. She knows that magickal culture depends on hiding magic from Normals, and Shepard’s presence threatens that secrecy. By sending him away, she is choosing to follow the rules of the magical world even though she previously broke them by letting him see so much.

Navigation