Chapter summaries Any Way the Wind Blows Rainbow Rowell

Chapter 2 Summary – The Mage's Estate

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Simon Snow arrives at the Wellbelove home for dinner, feeling awkward. He still has dragon wings and a tail, which he wraps to hide. Mrs. Wellbelove is appalled when she sees the wings. Agatha is silent throughout dinner. After dessert, Dr. Wellbelove calls Simon into his study for a serious talk. He reveals that the Mage’s estate has been settled and Simon is the heir. Simon is shocked to learn the Mage’s real name—David Cadwallader—and refuses the inheritance, insisting he killed the Mage. Dr. Wellbelove argues that the death was self-defense and that the Mage manipulated Simon. Simon counters that he wasn’t manipulated; he wanted to help. They argue about whether Simon was the Chosen One. Dr. Wellbelove says the Coven has decided the estate is Simon’s. Simon declares he is no longer a magician. Dr. Wellbelove, exasperated, tells him to just take the money.

Key Events

  • Simon eats dinner with the Wellbeloves; Mrs. Wellbelove sees his dragon wings.
  • After dessert, Dr. Wellbelove takes Simon to his study.
  • Dr. Wellbelove explains the Mage’s estate: Simon is the heir.
  • Simon learns the Mage’s real name: David Cadwallader.
  • Simon refuses the inheritance, claiming he killed the Mage.
  • Dr. Wellbelove insists it was self-defense and that Simon was manipulated.
  • Simon insists he gave away his magic and wasn’t manipulated.
  • Simon admits he was never the Chosen One; both feel ashamed.
  • Dr. Wellbelove says the Coven has made the decision final.
  • Simon says he’s not a magician; Dr. Wellbelove tells him to take the money.

Character Development

  • Simon Snow: Overwhelmed by guilt, he cannot accept that the Mage’s death was an accident. He rejects the label of victim, insisting he acted willingly. His identity as the Chosen One is shattered, and he struggles with his new physical form (wings/tail). He is defensive and stubborn.
  • Dr. Wellbelove: Acts as a surrogate father figure, but his tone is firm and legalistic. He tries to protect Simon by urging him to accept the inheritance, showing concern for Simon’s future despite the awkwardness.
  • Agatha Wellbelove: Present but silent; her refusal to engage suggests she has distanced herself from Simon since their breakup.
  • Mrs. Wellbelove: Shows visible discomfort with Simon’s changes, indicating the loss of her idealized vision of Simon and Agatha’s future.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Guilt and Self-Blame: Simon cannot separate his actions from the outcome, even when others justify it as self-defense.
  • Inheritance as Burden: The Mage’s estate symbolizes not wealth but the weight of a tainted legacy and Simon’s unresolved feelings.
  • Identity Loss: Simon no longer has magic, is no longer the Chosen One, and his body has changed; he feels like an outsider in the World of Mages.
  • Manipulation vs. Free Will: Simon insists he was not manipulated, implying he chose to follow the Mage, complicating the narrative of victimhood.
  • The Dragon Wings: A visible symbol of Simon’s transformation and otherness, marking his difference from normal magicians.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter deepens Simon’s psychological conflict and sets up a major plot point: his inheritance of the Mage’s estate. It also provides insight into Simon’s relationship with the Wellbelove family, who have been his surrogate family. The revelation of the Mage’s real name humanizes the villain and adds complexity to Simon’s grief. The conversation about manipulation and free will challenges the reader’s understanding of Simon’s past. Finally, it reinforces Simon’s loss of magical identity, pushing him further into a state of limbo.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Simon refuse the Mage’s inheritance?
    Simon refuses because he feels responsible for the Mage’s death. He cannot accept money or property from the man he killed, even though Dr. Wellbelove calls it self-defense. Simon’s guilt is so strong that he views the inheritance as blood money.

  2. How does Dr. Wellbelove try to change Simon’s mind?
    Dr. Wellbelove argues that the Mage manipulated Simon for years and owes him something. He points out that Simon was a child and that the Mage was corrupt. He also reminds Simon that the Coven has legally decided, and he ultimately tells Simon to “just take the money.”

  3. What does Simon reveal about his magic when he says “I gave it away”?
    Simon claims that his magic was not stolen by the Mage but given away. This hints at the end of the previous book where Simon transferred his power to save Baz. It contradicts the Mage’s narrative and shows Simon’s agency in his own loss of power.

Navigation