Chapter 22 Summary, Analysis, and Discussion Questions
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
The chapter opens on Clover's twentieth birthday in Antigua, Guatemala, where she is halfway through a two-month volunteer stay at a community nursing home for elderly residents—abuelos—who have no money or family to care for them. It is the first birthday she hasn't spent with Grandpa since moving in with him. She is studying sociology at McGill University in Montreal, with plans to follow Grandpa's academic path but focus on cultural traditions surrounding death around the world.
Felicity, a med student from Vancouver who has volunteered at the home for a full semester, unlocks the gate for Clover. Clover notes Felicity's natural beauty and disarmingly generous personality. As Clover walks through the courtyard, residents cluster around her. Rosita, a small deaf woman who cannot speak, dances toward Clover and wraps her arms around her in greeting—a gesture Clover treasures, given how scarce physical affection has been in her life. Other residents sit stoically in their wheelchairs, seemingly resigned to being forgotten by society, but their sadness lifts when Clover stops to greet each of them by name.
Clover reflects on a lesson learned during her first weeks at the home: pitying the residents doesn't ease their pain. The kindest thing she can do is look them in the eye and acknowledge their presence as human beings. She promises herself she'll never turn away from someone's pain, no matter how much she wants to.
Tim, a volunteer from Seattle who started a week after Clover, arrives hungover from a night out with other volunteers—an outing Clover wasn't invited to. He mentions that the finance firms he hopes to work for value good deeds on résumés, revealing a transactional motive for his volunteering. Clover has developed feelings for Tim and has been documenting signs of his interest in her journal: casual arm touches, requests for shoulder massages, always asking her to cover his shift, and a knee squeeze during a group outing.
During occupational therapy, Clover observes the residents' matching institutional clothing, noting small personal flourishes—Valería's frilled apron, Carmen's beaded necklace, Fernanda's hand-crocheted cardigan—that preserve their individuality. She wonders what they dreamed about at her age and what they wish they'd done differently.
Arturo, a resident poet whose arthritis prevents him from writing, dictates a poem to Clover about knowing a great love exists even before meeting them, with the moon as the one thing two people share. He playfully suggests Clover has already found someone special.
Clover has planned to reveal it's her birthday at the end of her shift and invite Tim to dinner at a small corner restaurant, where she'll confess her feelings. She's even considered the logistics of a long-distance relationship and anticipates her first kiss.
When the dinner bell rings, Tim asks Clover to cover his shift for fifteen minutes. She agrees, seeing it as a chance to show she's willing to make sacrifices for the relationship. Forty-five minutes later, Tim still hasn't returned. Clover volunteers to wash dishes and, needing dishwashing detergent, goes to the storage room. She finds Tim and Felicity embracing. She grabs the detergent and exits without a word.
Standing outside the storeroom, Clover learns a second important life lesson: looking other people's pain in the eye is much easier than facing your own.
Key Events
-
Clover's twentieth birthday begins at the nursing home in Antigua, Guatemala
-
Rosita's joyful greeting contrasts with other residents' stoic resignation
-
Tim arrives hungover, revealing he went out with other volunteers without Clover
-
Tim's comment about résumé-building exposes his transactional approach to volunteering
-
Clover transcribes Arturo's poem about love and the moon as a shared connection
-
Clover plans to confess her feelings to Tim over birthday dinner
-
Tim asks Clover to cover his shift; he disappears for forty-five minutes
-
Clover discovers Tim and Felicity embracing in the storage room
-
Clover leaves silently, learning that facing her own pain is harder than facing others'
Character Development
Clover: This chapter captures Clover at a pivotal coming-of-age moment. Her twentieth birthday marks her first away from Grandpa, and her volunteer work has taught her to acknowledge others' pain. Yet her romantic hopes—carefully catalogued in her journal—are shattered when she discovers Tim with Felicity. Her silent exit and the lesson she draws reveal both her emotional maturity and her tendency to suppress her own suffering.
Tim: His character is revealed through small details: the hangover, the résumé comment, the casual physicality with Clover, and ultimately his deception. His request for Clover to cover his shift while he's with Felicity shows a casual disregard for her feelings.
Felicity: Though kind and generous on the surface, her embrace with Tim complicates her portrayal. She's described as beautiful and genuine, making the betrayal feel more acute.
Rosita: Despite being deaf and unable to speak, Rosita embodies zest for life, offering Clover the physical affection she craves.
Arturo: The resident poet provides romantic wisdom and a symbolic connection through the moon, unknowingly setting up the chapter's emotional arc.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Facing one's own pain vs. others': The chapter's central lesson. Clover has learned to confront the residents' suffering but discovers she cannot so easily face her own heartbreak.
Anonymity and reinvention: Clover notes that in Guatemala she isn't a weird loner but fun, confident, and adventurous—a persona she's been trying on for the past month.
Transactional altruism: Tim's comment about résumé-building contrasts with Clover's genuine engagement with the residents.
Individuality within conformity: The residents' matching institutional clothes are distinguished by small personal flourishes, symbolizing preserved identity.
The moon as shared connection: Arturo's poem about the moon as something two people share becomes poignant given Clover's unrequited feelings.
Journaling as self-reflection: Clover's journal documents her romantic hopes, mirroring the book's broader theme of reflection.
Elderly forgotten by society: The residents' stoicism and Clover's acknowledgment of their humanity.
Zest for life despite limitations: Rosita's joyful greeting despite her deafness.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter is a turning point in Clover's emotional development. It establishes her capacity for empathy with the elderly while revealing her vulnerability in romantic matters. The discovery of Tim and Felicity is a formative heartbreak that connects to the book's larger themes about regret, love, and the difficulty of confronting one's own pain. The chapter also grounds Clover's academic ambitions—studying death traditions—within her lived experience of witnessing aging and loss.
Study Questions and Answers
1. How does Clover's approach to the nursing home residents differ from Tim's, and what does this reveal about each character?
Clover engages with residents as individuals, greeting each one and acknowledging their humanity. She learns that pity doesn't ease their pain and commits to never turning away from someone's suffering. Tim, by contrast, admits he's volunteering partly to build his résumé for finance firms, and he misidentifies Rosita as Juanita, showing a lack of genuine connection. This contrast establishes Clover's empathy and Tim's transactional approach.
2. What role does Arturo's poem play in the chapter's emotional arc?
Arturo's poem about knowing a great love exists even before meeting them, with the moon as a shared connection, mirrors Clover's own romantic hopes for Tim. His playful suggestion that she's found someone special seems to validate her feelings. The poem's romantic idealism makes the subsequent discovery of Tim with Felicity more devastating, as the promise of connection is revealed to be one-sided.
3. Why does Clover leave the storage room silently instead of confronting Tim and Felicity?
Clover's silent exit reflects her established pattern of suppressing her own pain. She has learned to face others' suffering—looking residents in the eye, acknowledging their humanity—but when confronted with her own heartbreak, she retreats. The chapter's final lesson—that facing your own pain is harder than facing others'—explains her choice and sets up her ongoing emotional journey.
Navigation
-
Book Hub: The Collected Regrets of Clover