Chapter 63 Summary: Deal or No Deal – Hugh
Spoiler Notice: This page contains detailed plot points from Chapter 63. If you haven't read the chapter, proceed with caution.
Summary
On Monday morning, November 2, 1998, Hugh is still angry at Feely for previously asking Lizzie to be his girlfriend. Feely tries to dismiss the issue, arguing that he asked months ago and was rejected, so it shouldn't matter. Hugh insists the betrayal lies in Feely keeping it a secret. Gibsie turns around and joins the argument, defending Hugh's feelings for Lizzie and calling Hugh a gentleman. Feely teases Hugh for being too scared to ask Lizzie out himself. Gibsie then warns Feely not to pursue his own crush, Claire, threatening violence if he does. Feely laughs and promises to stay away from Claire. He then formally apologizes to Hugh, admitting he should have been honest, and promises to keep out of Hugh's pursuit of Lizzie. Hugh accepts the apology, and they shake hands, making a deal to move past the conflict.
Key Events
- Feely tries to downplay his past request to Lizzie; Hugh remains furious about the secrecy.
- Gibsie joins the conversation, declaring that Hugh loves Lizzie and is a gentleman.
- Feely accuses Hugh of being a coward for not asking Lizzie out.
- Gibsie warns Feely off Claire with a mock threat.
- Feely apologizes to Hugh and agrees not to interfere with Lizzie.
- Hugh shakes Feely’s hand, sealing their renewed friendship.
Character Development
Hugh: Reveals a jealous and possessive side regarding Lizzie, yet his anger stems from a sense of betrayal rather than fear. He is still working up the courage to confess his feelings.
Feely: Shows he is not deliberately malicious – he simply didn't realize his actions would hurt Hugh. By apologizing and offering a deal, he prioritizes their friendship over his own pride.
Gibsie: Acts as a mediator and defender, using humor to defuse tension while also making it clear he will fiercely protect his own romantic interest (Claire).
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- Friendship and Betrayal: The conflict highlights how even small secrets can strain close bonds. The handshake deal symbolizes trust restored.
- Jealousy and Unspoken Feelings: Hugh’s reaction shows the power of unexpressed romantic interest, while Feely’s apology reflects the code of loyalty among the boys.
- Protective Humor: Gibsie’s playful threat about Claire underscores how the group uses banter to both warn and maintain closeness.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter deepens the dynamics of the core male friendship group. It reveals Hugh’s vulnerability regarding Lizzie and establishes Feely as a friend who values their bond over a romantic chance. The unresolved tension around Hugh’s feelings sets up future developments in his relationship with Lizzie.
Study Questions and Answers
-
Why is Hugh so angry with Feely?
Hugh is angry because Feely asked Lizzie to be his girlfriend without telling Hugh, and he kept it secret for four months. Hugh feels this violates the trust in their friendship, especially since he has feelings for Lizzie. -
How does Feely defend himself initially, and what changes his mind?
Feely argues that since Lizzie rejected him, it shouldn’t matter. He also accuses Hugh of being too cowardly to ask her out. He changes his mind after Gibsie’s intervention and when he sees how much Hugh cares; he apologizes and promises to stay out of it. -
What deal do Hugh and Feely make at the end of the chapter?
They agree that Feely will stop pursuing Lizzie and stay out of Hugh’s romantic plans. Hugh accepts the apology, and the two shake hands, restoring their friendship.