Chapter summaries If I Tell You the Truth Jasmin Kaur

Chapter 87: Grad Caps & Feels Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

The narrator crosses the stage at graduation and accepts a scholarship to art school. Roop, who has barely spoken to the narrator since her breakup with Jeevan, leans over in the dark auditorium to comment enviously. Roop calls her “so lucky” and says her own parents would consider art school a waste of time. The words trigger a cascade of memories: a tense spring day on the Skytrain with her mother when they barely escaped a police officer; the day she got her learner’s permit even though her mother did not have valid identification; all the bullshit her mother tolerated at work, earning next to nothing despite long hours. The narrator counts every tear-drenched night she carried herself to dawn waiting for her mother’s PR card to finally arrive. She realizes that her mother wanted her in art school more than she wanted her own breath. So the narrator honors that wish by accepting the opportunity, even though she feels it may have landed in the wrong life.

Key Events

  • The narrator walks across the stage and receives a scholarship.
  • Roop speaks to the narrator for the first time since the breakup, expressing jealousy.
  • The narrator recalls a stressful spring day on the Skytrain with her mother when they narrowly avoided a police officer.
  • She remembers the day she got her learner’s permit despite her mother lacking valid ID.
  • Memories surface of her mother being underpaid and mistreated at work.
  • The narrator reflects on many nights spent crying over the long wait for her mother’s permanent residency card.
  • She chooses to accept the art school opportunity, feeling it honors what her mother sacrificed.

Character Development

  • The narrator shows growth in self-awareness and gratitude. She connects her present success directly to her mother’s hidden struggles, acknowledging that her mother’s wishes for her art education were more important than her own comfort. The decision to accept the scholarship is an act of resolve, not simply luck.
  • Roop appears defined by family pressure. Her envy reveals a contrasting home environment where creative ambitions are not valued. In just a few words, she highlights how differently the narrator’s mother supported her dreams.
  • The mother — though not present in the scene — is revealed through memory as a woman who endured exploitation, legal insecurity, and emotional exhaustion, all while nurturing a quiet hope for her daughter’s artistic future.

Themes, Symbols, and Motifs

  • Sacrifice and maternal devotion: The mother’s willingness to bear indignities at work and her hope for the PR card are framed as acts of love that culminate in the narrator’s art school acceptance.
  • Immigrant precarity: The memories of the Skytrain cop, the missing ID, and the PR card all underline the family’s vulnerability and the high stakes of daily survival.
  • Art as a reclaimed dream: Art school is not simply a personal ambition; it becomes a legacy of the mother’s unspoken desires and a defiance of the barriers they faced.
  • Memory as emotional weight: The “black and white memories” that collide with Roop’s words show how the narrator’s present is haunted by past hardship. The chapter suggests that achievement is inseparable from the pain that made it possible.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is a turning point for the narrator’s motivation. Up to now, the practical challenges of survival — immigration status, underpaid work, family conflict — have dominated the story. Here, the narrator explicitly ties her art school dream to her mother’s sacrifice, making the scholarship feel both precious and bittersweet. The line about the opportunity finding her “in the wrong lifetime” introduces doubt: she wonders if she deserves this chance when her mother could not have it. The chapter deepens the novel’s exploration of generational hope and the emotional cost of escaping hardship.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does the narrator feel the scholarship opportunity “found me in the wrong lifetime”? She senses a painful mismatch between her own good fortune and her mother’s continued struggles. The memories show that her mother endured exploitation, legal limbo, and poverty — all so the narrator could have a future. Accepting the opportunity feels like stepping into a life her mother never got to live, creating guilt and gratitude in equal measure.

2. How does Roop’s comment contrast with the narrator’s memories? Roop calls the narrator “so lucky” and complains that her own parents would dismiss art school as a waste. The narrator’s internal memories, however, reveal that her path required enormous sacrifice, not luck. The contrast highlights how outsiders see only the result, not the years of hardship and the mother’s hidden support.

3. What does the narrator’s decision to accept art school reveal about her relationship with her mother? It shows that the narrator understands and honors her mother’s deepest wish. She chooses not to waste the opportunity because her mother wanted art school “more than she wanted her own breath.” The decision affirms their bond: the narrator carries forward her mother’s dream, even as she acknowledges the pain that made it possible.

Navigation