Chapter 10: Molly — Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Molly waits for Alex at a coffee shop inside the campus architecture building, annoyed that Alex is thirteen minutes late. When Alex finally arrives, she announces a five-step plan called “How to Get the Girl,” with the first step being to get someone’s phone number. Molly is skeptical and tries to leave, but Alex makes a bet: if Alex can get a random woman’s number, Molly has to stay and complete the step.

Alex spots a woman in a power suit with a briefcase and orders the same drink she does. By timing her approach at the pickup counter, Alex strikes up a conversation and successfully gets the woman’s number. Molly is impressed but still resistant. Alex explains that confidence is everything and frames the exercise as a low-stakes practice run—like a practice exam before the final, with Cora as the final.

Molly reluctantly tries to copy Alex’s move with a girl wearing a Pride pin, but she knocks over her coffee and fails. Alex admits she should have given more direction and advises Molly to adapt her approach based on the person, showing a part of herself the other person can relate to. Just then, a classmate named Dustin returns Molly’s dropped textbook. Molly, remembering that he struggled in anatomy, asks if he wants to study sometime and gets his number. Alex insists Dustin was interested in more than studying.

Alex then leaves for a food truck job interview. Molly, feeling a mix of gratitude and skepticism, tells Alex not to be so herself for the interview. The chapter ends with Molly feeling anxious about trusting Alex with her love life, given Alex’s chaotic, seat-of-the-pants lifestyle.

Key Events

Alex arrives late to the coffee shop and presents her five-step plan to win over Cora.
Alex bets Molly that she can get a random woman’s number; she succeeds by ordering the same drink and using confidence.
Molly attempts to copy Alex’s move but knocks over her coffee, failing.
Dustin returns Molly’s textbook, and she asks for his number; he gives it.
Alex tells Molly that Dustin was interested in her, not just studying.
Alex leaves for a food truck job interview, and Molly advises her not to be herself.
Molly ends the chapter feeling anxious about trusting Alex.

Character Development

This chapter marks a significant step in Molly’s arc. She begins paralyzed by self-doubt, convinced she could never approach Cora. Through the bet and the practice exercise, she takes a small but real risk—asking Dustin for his number—and discovers that she can initiate contact when she finds a genuine connection point. Alex’s coaching pushes her to move from copying a script to adapting her approach, which is a key lesson for Molly’s growth.

Alex, meanwhile, shows a more patient and strategic side. She doesn’t just give Molly a pep talk; she models the behavior, explains the reasoning, and adjusts her teaching when Molly fails. Her line about “showing the part of yourself you think they’ll relate to” reveals that Alex’s confidence isn’t just bravado—it’s a skill she can articulate. However, her own life remains chaotic, as evidenced by her last-minute job interview and Molly’s parting jab.

Dustin’s brief appearance also matters. He remembers Molly from a class where she helped him, and his nervousness mirrors Molly’s own, making the interaction feel safe. This encounter shows Molly that she already has the ability to connect with people when she’s not overthinking.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Confidence building: Alex frames confidence as something that can be practiced, not an innate trait. The bet is a deliberate exercise to build Molly’s courage.
Stepping out of comfort zone: Molly is forced to approach a stranger, and even though she fails initially, she eventually succeeds with Dustin.
Authenticity vs. imitation: Molly’s failed attempt to copy Alex’s exact move highlights that imitation doesn’t work; Alex teaches her to adapt and show a genuine part of herself.
Practice as preparation: Alex uses the analogy of a practice exam versus a final, emphasizing that low-stakes failures are necessary before the real thing.
Low-stakes risk-taking: The coffee shop setting is deliberately low-stakes—Molly will never see these people again—which makes it easier to try.
Mentorship: Alex acts as a mentor, modeling behavior, giving feedback, and adjusting her approach to help Molly learn.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is pivotal because it establishes the framework for Molly’s entire romantic pursuit. Alex’s five-step plan gives the novel a clear structure, and step one—getting a number—is the first concrete action Molly takes toward Cora. The chapter also deepens the dynamic between Molly and Alex, showing that Alex is genuinely invested in helping Molly, even if her methods are unconventional. Molly’s small success with Dustin proves that she is capable of taking initiative, which sets up her confidence for future steps. The ending, with Molly’s anxiety about trusting Alex, adds tension and foreshadows potential complications in their partnership.

Study Questions and Answers

What is the purpose of Alex’s bet with Molly?

The bet forces Molly to attempt the first step of the plan—getting a phone number—in a low-stakes environment. Alex wants Molly to practice the skill of approaching someone and asking for contact information, so that she can later apply it to Cora. The bet also gives Molly a concrete reason to stay and try, rather than backing out.

How does Molly’s failed attempt with the beanie girl teach her a lesson about authenticity?

Molly tries to copy Alex’s exact move—ordering the same drink and reaching for it at the same time—but she knocks over the coffee. Alex explains that the same approach doesn’t work for everyone; you have to adapt based on the person and show a part of yourself they can relate to. This lesson is reinforced when Molly succeeds with Dustin by using their shared academic history as a natural conversation starter.

Why does Molly feel anxious at the end of the chapter?

Molly has just taken a small step toward confidence, but she is also aware that she is entrusting her love life to Alex, who lives impulsively and is late to meetings. The chapter ends with Molly questioning whether she can rely on Alex’s plan, especially since Alex is about to go to a job interview that she is already late for. This anxiety sets up doubt about the sustainability of their partnership.

Navigation

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter
Book Hub