Chapter 11: Tenth Grade — Summary, Themes, and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Tenth grade is the last year Gary Gulman spends most of his free time with his parents. Every Saturday night his father comes over, and the two split a large pepperoni pizza and watch a movie on the family's new VCR. This arrangement doubles the time father and son spend together, and Gary is grateful for it, even as his father periodically offers to let him off the hook. His older brothers are busy with their own lives—Rick is expecting a child, Max is planning a wedding—so Gary remains close to his mother, though he is now embarrassed by that closeness and resents her opinions about his clothes and hair.

The night before school starts, Gary is excited and hopeful about finally getting a girlfriend, a desire he keeps entirely to himself. He has grown to six foot five but weighs only 170 pounds. While preparing his outfit for the first day—a discounted Ralph Lauren polo from a factory store and Levi's 501 jeans—he catches his profile in a pair of mirrors and is horrified to discover his nose is hooked, a family trait he calls the "Wasserman hook." The discovery deepens his commitment to hiding his romantic ambitions.

The next morning his mother insists on photographing him on the lawn, despite his protests. She uses her familiar phrases—"I don't ask for much" and "You're a one-way street"—and ends with "You're so odd." Gary endures the photo shoot while a harsh inner voice, imagining a crowd of teenagers mocking him, plays in his head.

At school, Gary is pleased to find Lori Kremer in his homeroom. He meets his teachers: Ms. Carmody for geometry (who has a speech impediment), Mrs. Congdon for world history (where he first encounters the word "syllabus"), Mrs. Yost for English, and Frau Power for German II. At lunch, he tries to sit near the popular upperclassmen, including basketball player Mike Womack and his friend Sully. Sully immediately hazes him about his mustache, threatening to hold him down and shave it. After three days of this, Gary relocates to a table with friends from Jewish Community Center basketball, where he is treated with something close to reverence. These friends share comedy tapes by Emo Philips, George Carlin, and Richard Pryor.

Gary makes the varsity basketball team and is named "a diamond in the rough" in a local newspaper preview. When the starting small forward breaks his ankle, Gary becomes the first player off the bench. In the season opener against top-ranked Brockton, he hits his first shot but is called for an offensive foul. Coach Ron Bitter blames him for the team's deficit and benches him for the rest of the game—and, effectively, for the entire season. Gary spends the next nineteen games on the bench, and the team's tournament run extends his misery.

After the season, Gary turns to comedy. He listens repeatedly to a Steven Wright tape given to him by a friend, and he begins recording his own bits on the boom box he received for his bar mitzvah. His first routine is a parody of Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous called Lifestyles of the Broke and Hopeless, in which he tours his own house and car, mocking the evidence of poverty. He also records a fake ad for a product called "stick in the door," inspired by his mother's habit of wedging a broomstick in the sliding glass door. When he plays the tape for his friends, it is a hit.

In German class one Friday in May, Gary makes Lori and her friend Kristel Holland laugh with a mournful routine about the Cheers theme song. Frau Power scolds him, but Gary is thrilled: he made teenaged girls laugh and got in trouble on a Friday. He later asks Lori to invite Kristel to a group movie outing. The group picks up Kristel at her home, where Gary meets her warm mother Vicki and her gruff but good-natured father Paul. At the multiplex in Revere, Gary deploys his practiced movie jokes and sits next to Kristel, resting his head on her shoulder twice during the film.

Afterward, Gary works up the courage to call Kristel. He rehearses his opening lines, leaves a message on her family's answering machine, and spends the next day hovering near the phone. She calls back around five o'clock and asks to borrow his comedy tape. They agree to meet at Symphony Park the next day. When she arrives, she invites him to come swimming at her house. Gary walks with her, leaving his basketball behind at the park.

The chapter flashes forward to November 2017. Gary is recovering from a mental illness that for nearly three years prevented him from reading a single book. He now uses the Lynnfield Public Library's app to download audiobooks, which soothe his anxiety and make his solitary walks and light jogs less lonely.

Key Events

Gary's Saturday-night pizza-and-movie ritual with his father begins, marking the closest period of their relationship.
Gary discovers his hooked nose in a mirror the night before tenth grade.
His mother photographs him on the first day of school, using her signature guilt phrases.
Sully hazes Gary about his mustache at lunch, driving him to sit with his JCC basketball friends.
Gary makes varsity basketball but is benched after an offensive foul in the season opener against Brockton.
He records his first comedy tape, including Lifestyles of the Broke and Hopeless.
He makes Lori and Kristel laugh in German class with a Cheers-themed routine.
He arranges a group movie outing with Kristel and meets her family.
He calls Kristel, leaves a message, and she calls back; they meet at Symphony Park, where she invites him swimming.
A flash-forward shows Gary in 2017 using audiobooks from the Lynnfield library to cope with anxiety.

Character Development

Gary's self-image takes a major hit this year. The mirror discovery about his nose joins his existing insecurities about his weight, hair, braces, and mustache. His inner critic is relentless, imagining a chorus of teenagers mocking his every move. Yet the chapter also shows him beginning to find a new identity. When basketball fails him, comedy becomes his refuge. The laughter he generates in German class and from his friends gives him a sense of accomplishment that sports no longer provide.

His relationship with his father deepens through the Saturday-night ritual, even as his relationship with his mother grows more strained. He is embarrassed by her attention but still depends on her. His first real crush on Kristel Holland shows him stepping outside his usual social circle and taking emotional risks, from arranging the group outing to making the phone call.

The 2017 flash-forward reveals an older Gary still using humor-adjacent tools—audiobooks—to manage his mental health, connecting his teenage discovery of comedy's healing power to his adult recovery.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Body image insecurity: The hooked nose, the mustache, and his lanky frame all feed Gary's self-criticism and his belief that he is unlovable.
Comedy as solace: The Steven Wright tape is described as both "painkiller and vaccine," and Gary's own recording sessions become restorative. His comedy gives him a sense of mastery and connection.
First crush and phone call anxiety: Gary's elaborate planning for the phone call—choosing "speak to" over "speak with," deciding when to hang up—captures the terror and hope of adolescent romance.
Class differences and materialism critique: The Lifestyles of the Broke and Hopeless parody mocks the worship of wealth, and Gary contrasts the Hollands' bright, open home with his own darker, more guarded one.
Father-son bonding: The Saturday-night pizza and movie ritual is a rare period of closeness between Gary and his dad.
Mental illness recovery: The 2017 flash-forward shows audiobooks as a practical tool for managing anxiety and loneliness, echoing the earlier theme of humor as healing.
School social hierarchy: The cafeteria seating map—clique-ahs, burnouts, and the "suburbs"—shows how status is negotiated and how Gary finds belonging among the JCC basketball players.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter marks a turning point in Gary's adolescence. It is the last year he spends most of his free time with his parents, and it is the year basketball—his longtime dream and supposed solution to all his problems—fails him. His benching is a painful lesson in the limits of athletic achievement. But out of that disappointment comes his discovery of comedy as a genuine passion. The German class routine and the homemade tape are his first real performances, and the positive response he gets from Lori, Kristel, and his friends gives him a new sense of purpose.

The chapter also introduces Kristel Holland, Gary's first serious crush, and shows him taking the initiative to pursue her, despite his deep insecurities. The flash-forward to 2017 connects this formative period to his adult struggles with mental illness, showing how the coping mechanisms he began to develop as a teenager—humor, distraction, and later audiobooks—continue to sustain him.

Study Questions and Answers

1. How does Gary's discovery of his hooked nose affect his behavior in the rest of the chapter?

The mirror discovery reinforces his commitment to keeping his romantic desires secret. He already believes his appearance makes a girlfriend unlikely, and the nose confirms his pessimism. It also feeds his harsh inner critic, which torments him during the first-day-of-school photo shoot and makes him hyperaware of his body throughout the year.

2. What role does comedy play in Gary's life after he is benched from basketball?

Comedy becomes his primary source of joy and self-worth. He listens to comedy tapes obsessively, records his own routines, and finds that making others laugh gives him a sense of accomplishment that basketball no longer provides. His successful routine in German class and the positive reaction to his homemade tape show that comedy is becoming his new identity.

3. How does the 2017 flash-forward connect to the rest of the chapter?

The flash-forward shows Gary as an adult recovering from a serious mental illness. He cannot read, but he can listen to audiobooks, which soothe his anxiety and make his walks less lonely. This connects to the chapter's theme of finding healing through external voices—just as comedy tapes soothed him as a teenager, audiobooks soothe him now. It also shows the continuity of his coping strategies across decades.

Navigation

Previous chapter: Chapter 10
Next chapter: Chapter 12
Back to book hub