Chapter 27 Summary: 2005 to 2006

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

{#summary}

The chapter opens during the 2005–2006 holiday break. Sully is home from college in New York, and he and Georgette meet outside Cowtown Cup, where she has been working as a barista for a couple of months. Sully breaks up with her, explaining that the distance is too hard. Georgette reacts with studied sadness—kissing his cheek and thinking of her mother—but privately feels almost nothing. She recognizes that Sully never really had a chance with her emotionally numb heart.

The next day, Nana draws the story out of her over chicken pot pie. She offers platitudes about other fish in the sea and suggests Georgette try a new hairstyle, which Georgette deflects with sarcasm. Christmas passes with just the two of them: Georgette gives Nana a Miles Davis record, Nana gives her a photography book, and Georgette fakes gratitude. Photography, like so much else, feels dead to her. Nana leaves a message for Georgette's father, but he never calls back.

The day after Christmas, Shauna Darnell calls to invite Georgette and Nana to a New Year's Eve party. Georgette declines at first, but Nana insists, eventually delivering the line that the living have living to do. Georgette relents and calls Shauna back, only to learn that her father has been invited too.

At the party, Georgette wears a secondhand dress Nana bought for the occasion, paired with sneakers as a small act of defiance. She avoids her father and notices that Kendi is absent. Shauna reveals that Kendi chose to stay away so Georgette would feel more comfortable. When her father arrives, Georgette retreats to the bathroom and makes herself sick, then endures a stilted conversation with him about his work at the science museum. She walks away mid-conversation.

On the porch, her father follows her out. He says he came to the party for her, not for New Year's. Georgette confronts him about missing her nineteenth birthday and about his drinking. He admits he drank the night before but not that day, because he wanted to see her. Georgette tells him she is not her mother and will not keep giving him chances. He responds that her mother didn't pretend there was no problem—she just loved him anyway. Nana emerges, and Georgette leaves without ceremony.

Back home, Georgette texts Kendi. He is at their old park, and she joins him with a pint of Blue Bell ice cream and two spoons. They share memories: the New Year's with pistachios, the letter they wrote to a celebrity on Shauna's behalf, and the middle-school New Year's when they practiced kissing each other before kissing Ben and Cassidy at midnight.

Then Kendi apologizes for not saving her mother. He says he is sorry he was there and she wasn't, and that he didn't sense anything was wrong. Georgette, for the first time, considers his pain and tells him he couldn't have done anything differently. She realizes she had been blaming him to make sense of her mother's death. They catch up on his aerospace engineering studies at LeTourneau and his new girlfriend, Leah. Georgette tells him about the breakup with Sully. They part on friendly terms, and Georgette reflects that her mother is still dead and her father is still drinking, but she has her best friend back.

Key Events

{#key-events}

Sully ends the long-distance relationship with Georgette outside Cowtown Cup.
Georgette and Nana spend Christmas alone; Nana's call to Georgette's father goes unanswered.
Nana persuades Georgette to attend the Darnells' New Year's Eve party.
Georgette learns from Shauna that Kendi stayed away from the party to make her comfortable.
Georgette confronts her father on the porch about his drinking and his absence from her life.
Georgette texts Kendi and meets him at their old park with ice cream.
Kendi apologizes for not saving Georgette's mother, and Georgette forgives him.
The two catch up on their lives and part as friends.

Character Development

{#character-development}

Georgette begins the chapter emotionally numb, describing herself as feeling little when Sully breaks up with her. By the end, she is crying openly with Kendi and offering him forgiveness. The chapter traces her movement from avoidance—hiding in the bathroom, scanning rooms for exits—to direct engagement with the two people she has been avoiding: her father and her best friend. Her confrontation with her father shows a new willingness to name the problem, even as she refuses to absorb it. Her forgiveness of Kendi marks a shift from blame to understanding.

Kendi carries visible guilt for being present when Georgette's mother died. His apology is halting and raw, and he has clearly needed absolution for years. His willingness to stay away from the party to protect Georgette's comfort shows a continued attentiveness to her needs, even after their long estrangement.

Nana acts as the chapter's quiet engine. She pushes Georgette out of the house, orchestrates the porch encounter by deliberately retrieving her shawl, and delivers the chapter's central philosophy: the living have living to do. Her persistence is gentle but relentless.

Dad appears briefly but significantly. He shows up sober for the day, admits his drinking honestly, and tries to connect with Georgette, but his years of absence have left too much damage. His line about Georgette's mother loving him anyway reveals his own grief and guilt, even as Georgette refuses to accept it as an excuse.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

{#themes-symbols-or-motifs}

Emotional numbness and reawakening. Georgette's reaction to Sully's breakup—acting sad while feeling nothing—establishes her emotional state. Her tears with Kendi mark the first real feeling she has allowed herself in some time.

Forgiveness and guilt. Kendi's apology and Georgette's absolution form the emotional core of the chapter. Georgette realizes she had been using blame as a way to make sense of her mother's death, and that realization allows her to let go.

The living have living to do. Nana's phrase becomes the chapter's thesis. It is what pushes Georgette to the party, to the porch, and ultimately to the park.

Memory as a way to change the past. Georgette reflects that the past cannot change, but memory can, which is almost the same thing. The shared memories with Kendi—pistachios, practice kisses, celebrity letters—rebuild the bridge between them.

Fireworks and New Year's. The fireworks that frighten Seth and punctuate the porch confrontation also mark the passage into a new year. The chapter ends with Georgette watching Kendi leave, having chosen connection over isolation.

The party dress and sneakers. Georgette's refusal to fully dress up—sneakers with a shiny party dress—symbolizes her resistance to performing a version of herself she does not feel.

Why This Chapter Matters

{#why-this-chapter-matters}

This chapter resolves one of the novel's longest-running tensions: the rift between Georgette and Kendi. His apology and her forgiveness restore the friendship that has been fractured since her mother's death. The chapter also stages Georgette's most direct confrontation with her father, in which she finally tells him she is not her mother and will not keep giving him chances. Both scenes show Georgette moving from numbness and avoidance toward feeling and engagement. The chapter ends on a note of qualified hope: her mother is still dead and her father is still drinking, but she has her best friend back.

Study Questions and Answers

{#study-questions-and-answers}

1. Why does Georgette react so flatly to Sully's breakup, and what does that reveal about her emotional state?

Georgette acts sad and kisses his cheek, but privately she feels almost nothing. She reflects that Sully never had a chance. This numbness is a symptom of her unprocessed grief over her mother's death. She has been going through the motions of life—working at Cowtown Cup, living with Nana—without actually feeling it. The breakup barely registers because she has walled herself off from emotion.

2. What does Kendi's apology accomplish, and why is Georgette able to forgive him?

Kendi apologizes for being present when Georgette's mother died and for not sensing that something was wrong. Georgette realizes for the first time that she had been blaming him as a way to make sense of her mother's death—a way to land the pain on someone she trusted. When she tells him he couldn't have done anything differently, she is also telling herself. The forgiveness is mutual: he needed absolution, and she needed to let go of blame.

3. How does Nana's insistence that Georgette attend the party shape the chapter's outcome?

Nana pushes Georgette to the party, delivers the line about the living having living to do, and then deliberately leaves Georgette alone on the porch with her father by retrieving her shawl. Without Nana's persistence, Georgette would have stayed home, avoided the confrontation with her father, and never texted Kendi. Nana's gentle manipulation sets the entire chapter in motion.

Navigation

{#navigation}