Chapter 25 Summary and Analysis: The Years 2001 to 2002
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
The chapter opens with the narrator moving into her father's apartment after her mother's death, a move she describes as happening by default rather than by choice. The apartment quickly proves unlivable: her father's drinking has intensified to a degree she has never witnessed, though she recognizes that her mother had seen this side of him before. His behavior becomes unpredictable—shouting at objects, throwing things, or retreating into silence—and the narrator responds by keeping her distance. The apartment itself is dark, stocked only with ramen and expired cereal.
After several months, her grandmother intervenes. Nana tells her she has prepared the guest room with new jersey-knit sheets, and the narrator leaves with her dog Seth. Her father watches her go with an expression the narrator compares to someone waking from a flying dream.
At Nana's house, the narrator is met with practical, attentive care. Nana asks her to write down her favorite foods, ice cream flavors, and Seth's kibble, then reads the list aloud and heads to the store. The guest room is furnished with a lamp, towels, trinkets from Nana's teaching career, and an extra blanket. The narrator settles in with Seth, aware of the contrast with her father's apartment.
In September 2001, the World Trade Center attacks kill thousands, including the aunt of a boy from school—a nurse. The narrator reflects bitterly that so many people died while her father remains alive.
Nana insists on therapy. One session includes her father, and the narrator finds it unbearable. Her father refuses to talk about her mother, deflecting to other topics, while Nana later describes the avoidance as an elephant in every room he enters.
The narrator passes her driving test and receives Nana's Corolla. She notes that she resembles her father in the license photo and wishes her mother were there to critique her driving. She admits to fantasies of being careless behind the wheel, imagining the metal of a crash pulling her under—a quiet expression of suicidal ideation.
When school ends, she sleeps excessively, day and night. Nana tries to draw her out with banana bread, walks with Seth, and documentaries, but the narrator wants only sleep. She entertains the thought that one life is nothing, then counters it by thinking of her mother: one life can be everything. Eventually, she gets up for a slice of banana bread.
On the first anniversary of her mother's death, she visits the grave alone. She remembers touching her mother's hair that night, the only part of her that felt normal, and regrets not cutting a lock to keep. A young tree grows near the grave—possibly an oak, too small for shade. She sketches the living tree on a page from her sketchbook, then buries the drawing beside the grave, wondering if she is going a little crazy.
Key Events
-
The narrator moves in with her father after her mother's death
-
Her father's alcoholism makes the apartment unlivable
-
Nana invites her to stay; she moves with Seth
-
The 9/11 attacks kill thousands, including a schoolmate's aunt
-
A difficult therapy session with her father
-
She passes her driving test and receives Nana's Corolla
-
She spends the summer sleeping excessively
-
On the anniversary of her mother's death, she visits the grave, sketches a young tree, and buries the drawing
Character Development
The narrator moves through this chapter in a state of profound grief. Her resentment toward her father is explicit and raw—she wishes he had died instead of her mother. Her grief manifests in escapism (sleep), in fantasies of self-harm (the car), and in a complicated relationship with the idea of death itself. Yet the chapter also shows small movements toward living: she gets up for banana bread, she passes her driving test, she makes the pilgrimage to her mother's grave. The act of sketching and burying the tree suggests a need to ritualize her grief, even if she doubts her own sanity in doing so.
Dad is present mostly through absence. His alcoholism has transformed him into someone unpredictable and emotionally unavailable. He cannot speak about his wife's death, and his denial is so pronounced that Nana describes it as an elephant stampede in every room he enters. His watching the narrator leave is one of the few moments of visible feeling, though it reads more like disappointment than engagement.
Nana emerges as the chapter's steady presence. Her care is practical—sheets, groceries, a car—but it is also attentive. She reads the narrator's list aloud, prepares the guest room, and keeps trying to lure her out of bed. She insists on therapy, even when the narrator resists. Her love is expressed through action rather than words.
Seth the dog is a quiet constant, moving with the narrator from one home to another and providing companionship during a period of isolation.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Grief and escapism. Sleep becomes the narrator's primary escape from grief. She describes wanting to sleep for a week, a month, a lifetime, and the chapter links this to a broader existential questioning: is one life nothing or everything?
Mortality and randomness. The 9/11 attacks amplify the chapter's meditation on death. Thousands die in a single morning, including a nurse who probably wasn't an alcoholic, while the narrator's father—whose drinking she resents—survives. The unfairness of who lives and who dies is central.
The young tree. The oak sapling near the grave is the chapter's richest symbol. It is new life growing beside death, too small to provide shade but alive. The narrator sketches it on paper made from a dead tree, then buries the drawing—an offering, a ritual, a way of placing her grief in the ground.
The guest room. Nana's prepared room—lamp on, towels stacked, trinkets displayed—represents care made physical. It is the opposite of her father's dark apartment, and it signals that someone has made space for her.
The Corolla. The car represents a step toward independence, but it is also a site of loss: the narrator wishes her mother were there to criticize her driving, and the car becomes the setting for her fantasies of self-destruction.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter establishes the narrator's living situation and emotional state in the year after her mother's death. It introduces Nana as a central caregiver, shows the father's decline into alcoholism, and places the narrator's personal grief against the backdrop of a national tragedy. The anniversary scene—the grave, the tree, the buried sketch—is a pivotal moment of ritual and reckoning, showing the narrator actively engaging with her loss rather than only escaping it. The chapter also deepens the book's exploration of mortality, memory, and the strange arithmetic of who lives and who dies.
Study Questions and Answers
1. How does the narrator's relationship with sleep reflect her state of mind in this chapter?
Sleep functions as both escape and erasure. The narrator describes wanting to sleep for a week, a month, a lifetime, and the thought that one life is nothing slides through her mind. Sleep is a way of not being present, of not feeling the grief. But the chapter also shows her pushing back against that impulse—she thinks of her mother and concludes that one life can be everything, and she eventually gets up for banana bread. Sleep is the pull of death, and getting up is the pull of life.
2. What does the young tree symbolize in the grave scene, and why does the narrator bury her sketch of it?
The young tree is new life growing beside death—an oak too small for shade, still growing. The narrator's sketch of it on paper made from a dead tree creates a layered image: life drawn on death, then buried in the ground. The act of burying the drawing is a ritual, an offering, a way of placing something of herself in the earth beside her mother. It suggests that grief is not something to be resolved but something to be tended, like a sapling.
3. How does Nana's care differ from Dad's, and what does it provide the narrator?
Dad's care is absent or destructive: the apartment is dark, the pantry is bare, and his drinking makes him unpredictable. Nana's care is practical and attentive—she prepares a guest room, asks what the narrator likes to eat, reads the list aloud, and goes shopping. She insists on therapy and keeps trying to draw the narrator out of bed. Nana's care provides structure, safety, and the sense that someone has made space for her. It is the difference between a home and a place to stay.
Navigation
-
Previous chapter