Chapter summaries The City and Its Uncertain Walls Haruki Murakami

Chapter 57 (Chapter 56) Summary & Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

The narrator arrives at the library the morning after Mr. Koyasu’s death and immediately feels a fundamental change in the atmosphere. Yellow Submarine Boy is absent from his usual reading-room spot. After three days of absence, Mrs. Soeda contacts the boy’s mother and learns that M** disappeared from his locked bedroom overnight, wearing only pajamas, with all doors and windows secured from inside and no clothes missing. The boy’s father visits the narrator that afternoon. He explains that M** has always had peculiar abilities, including the power to absorb information at incredible speed and to assemble fragmentary details into a complete picture. The father confesses his own failure to connect with his son, who never responded to him. The narrator reveals that he and the boy discussed a fictional town, and that M** drew a remarkably accurate map of it. The father leaves to continue the search, and the narrator and Mrs. Soeda share a quiet fear that the boy may have crossed into that other world.

Key Events

  • The narrator senses the library has changed irrevocably after Mr. Koyasu’s death.
  • Yellow Submarine Boy does not appear at the library for three consecutive days.
  • Mrs. Soeda phones the boy’s home and learns he vanished from a locked room in his pajamas.
  • The boy’s father visits the narrator, describing his son’s special abilities and his own parental isolation.
  • The narrator admits to discussing a fictional town, and that M** drew a detailed map of it.
  • The father leaves to continue investigating; the narrator and Mrs. Soeda are left anxious.

Character Development

  • Narrator: He experiences the weight of losing Mr. Koyasu’s wisdom just when he needs it most. His careful negotiation with the boy’s father shows his growing understanding of the boundaries between worlds.
  • Yellow Submarine Boy (M):** His disappearance deepens his mystery. He is revealed to have a precise mapping gift and a deep attachment to the fictional town, suggesting he may have intentionally crossed over.
  • Boy’s father: A figure of authority and control, he is humbled here. He admits his powerlessness as a parent, envies Mr. Koyasu’s bond with his son, and struggles to make sense of events beyond common sense.
  • Mrs. Soeda: She becomes a conduit of news and shares the narrator’s quiet dread, revealing her own attachment to the boy.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • The Locked-Room Mystery: The boy’s disappearance from a secure room with no sign of forced exit echoes classic impossible crime puzzles, but here it hints at a metaphysical transition rather than a physical one.
  • The Fictional Town as Portal: The map the boy drew of a place that should not exist becomes a symbol of his ability to access another reality. The narrator’s earlier descriptions of the walled town take on new weight.
  • Parent-Child Silence: The father’s confession that his son treated him like a stone statue highlights the theme of emotional disconnection even within a family.
  • Intuitive Knowledge vs. Common Sense: The boy’s gifts and the narrator’s hidden knowledge contrast with the father’s reliance on rational explanation, yet the father remains open enough to seek help.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter escalates the novel’s central mystery: the boy has apparently crossed into the walled town, and the narrator must now grapple with the real-world consequences of his earlier storytelling. The father’s visit forces the narrator to weigh honesty against protecting the fragile boundary between worlds. It also deepens the character of Yellow Submarine Boy, showing him as a being with unique cognitive gifts and a chosen destination. The chapter sets up the possibility that the narrator himself may be next to cross over.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does the narrator decide not to tell the boy’s father the full truth about the walled town?
Answer: The narrator knows that the father operates within the rules of common sense and would dismiss the idea of a literal other world. Revealing the truth could cause more harm than good, and the narrator feels compelled to protect the integrity of the town as a separate realm.

2. What does the boy’s father reveal about his own relationship with M?**
Answer: He admits that M** never showed any interest in him and that he felt like a stranger in his own home. Despite his success as an educator, he was powerless to reach his son and envied Mr. Koyasu for the connection he had.

3. How does the detail of the boy leaving his Yellow Submarine parka behind support the idea of a supernatural departure?
Answer: The parka was his favorite and always calmed him. Leaving it behind suggests he did not run away but was instead taken or transported elsewhere, consistent with the narrator’s earlier hints about crossing into the walled town.

Navigate the Chapter