Chapter summaries The Margaret Atwood 4-Book Bundle Margaret Atwood

Alias Grace Chapter 25: A Morning of Tensions and Unspoken Hierarchies

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Chapter 25 unfolds through Grace Marks' first-person narrative as she describes her morning routine at Thomas Kinnear's house. She wakes at dawn, performs her chores—emptying the slop pail, pumping water, starting the stove, milking the cow, gathering eggs—and interacts with the other servants, James McDermott and Nancy Montgomery. Grace observes McDermott's odd early-morning step-dancing and his grinning, flirtatious demeanor. She has her first falling-out with Nancy over the household hierarchy, culminating in a disagreement about the Susanna and the Elders engraving in Mr. Kinnear's room. Mr. Kinnear enters and clarifies that the story is from the Apocrypha, not the canonical Bible, which embarrasses Nancy and reveals her jealousy of Grace's quick mind. Grace reflects that Nancy had hired her hoping they would be like sisters—as Grace had been with Mary Whitney—but now realizes that will not happen.

Key Events

  • Grace wakes at dawn, opens the shutters, and prepares for her day, noting the locked bedroom door and the lack of a mirror.
  • She completes outdoor chores: empties the slop pail, pumps water, milks the cow, and feeds the horses carrots furtively.
  • Grace hears McDermott step-dancing alone in the hayloft and later encounters him at the pump; he gives her a friendly wave and a grin.
  • Nancy comes down in a gingham dress; Grace makes tea and learns that Mr. Kinnear takes his tea upstairs.
  • Grace brings the tea tray to Mr. Kinnear’s dark bedchamber; he speaks weakly and thanks her.
  • Back downstairs, Nancy insists on breakfasting with Mr. Kinnear and says he likes to be fussed over.
  • Grace idly asks why Mr. Kinnear never married; Nancy responds sharply that rich men can pay for what they want.
  • The first significant falling-out occurs: while making Mr. Kinnear’s bed, Nancy criticizes Grace’s methods, and Grace challenges Nancy’s assertion that the Susanna engraving is a Biblical subject.
  • Mr. Kinnear hears the argument, explains the Apocrypha, and jokes about Grace’s cleverness, further angering Nancy.
  • Nancy redirects her frustration by scolding McDermott about her shoes.
  • Grace concludes that Nancy does not intend to be a friend or sister to her.

Character Development

  • Grace Marks: Demonstrates keen observation, resourcefulness, and a stubborn pride in her knowledge. Her memory of Mary Whitney and the “And so forth” evasion with Dr. Jordan show how she controls her story. Her internal reflections reveal both humility (her wish for a house of her own) and defiance (her silent anger at Nancy’s orders).
  • Nancy Montgomery: Exposed as insecure and possessive of Mr. Kinnear’s attention. Her sharp retort about rich men paying for what they want hints at a transactional relationship with Kinnear. Her jealousy of Grace’s intelligence and experience in a grander household fuels her hostility.
  • James McDermott: Still an unsettling presence. His early-morning dancing suggests restless energy, and his grin when watching Grace implies interest, but Grace resolves to keep a cordial distance.
  • Thomas Kinnear: Shown as a cultured, amused gentleman who enjoys intellectual banter, but also as a man who expects to be served and fussed over. His reference to the Apocrypha indicates a liberal religious education.

Themes, Symbols, and Motifs

  • Servitude and Hierarchy: The chapter vividly depicts the rigid social order within a household. Grace knows her place but resents Nancy’s micromanaging. Nancy, herself a former servant, is more tyrannical than a born lady would be. Grace’s silent comparisons to Mrs. Alderman Parkinson’s house underscore the complexity of class mobility.
  • Religious Knowledge and Authority: The dispute over the Susanna engraving exposes how knowledge is a form of power. Mr. Kinnear’s casual correction undermines Nancy’s authority in front of Grace. Grace’s question about voices hearing God touches on her own experience with Mary Whitney’s voice, linking religious inspiration to her traumatic past.
  • Suspicion and Jealousy: Nancy’s behavior—hovering in Mr. Kinnear’s room, her anger at Grace’s question about marriage, flouncing out to scold McDermott—drips with jealousy. Grace notes that Nancy did not want to leave her alone with Mr. Kinnear.
  • Memory and Storytelling: Grace’s narrative is filtered through her present-day conversations with Dr. Jordan. Her refusal to describe the privy act (“And so forth”) demonstrates her control over what she reveals. The mention of Mary Whitney reinforces that past friendships haunt her present.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 25 is crucial for establishing the domestic tensions that will erupt later. It foreshadows the murder by showing the growing antagonism between Grace and Nancy, and McDermott’s strange behavior. It also deepens our understanding of Grace’s character: her intelligence, her pride in her work, and her emotional isolation. The conversation about the Apocrypha and voices hearing God subtly parallels Grace’s own claim of hearing Mary Whitney, hinting at a theme of unreliable revelation. The chapter roots the story in the mundane details of 1840s servant life, making the violence to come more shocking.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Grace react so strongly when Nancy claims the Susanna engraving is a Biblical subject? Why does Mr. Kinnear’s intervention embarrass Nancy?
    Grace takes pride in her knowledge of the Bible, having learned it at the penny school and from Mrs. Alderman Parkinson’s household. She feels Nancy is trying to lord her authority over her, and being corrected in front of Mr. Kinnear undermines Nancy’s status. Mr. Kinnear’s explanation (that the story is in the Apocrypha) shows Nancy to be less learned than Grace, a humiliation she cannot forgive.

  2. What does Grace’s description of McDermott’s step-dancing suggest about his state of mind?
    The dancing is “strange,” “furious,” as if with two hammers. Grace wonders if it comes from joy or “animal spirits,” but decides it does not seem joyful. This suggests McDermott is agitated or restless, possibly foreshadowing his violent actions later. His later grin and wave are a contrast, making him unpredictable.

  3. How does the chapter reveal the power dynamics between Nancy, Grace, and Mr. Kinnear?
    Mr. Kinnear is the ultimate authority—his word settles the argument, and his approval flatters Grace while angering Nancy. Nancy tries to control Grace through orders and criticism, but Grace subtly resists by comparing methods from her previous job. Nancy’s jealousy of Grace’s access to Mr. Kinnear (taking up the tea) shows her insecurity. Grace is the lowest in rank but uses her intelligence and memory of Mary Whitney to maintain her own dignity.

Navigation