Chapter 7 Summary & Analysis – Simon Jordan’s Unsettled Mind
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
Simon Jordan sits at his writing desk in Kingston, staring at the choppy waters of Lake Ontario. He is dispirited and uneasy despite the jaunty hopefulness he has previously expressed. His background is revealed: he studied medicine partly to rebel against his wealthy mill-owner father, but his father’s business collapsed, leaving Simon with a much smaller inheritance than his mother believes. He dreams of establishing a private asylum but lacks the funds and must first build a reputation. He considers marrying for money but recoils at the thought of a candidate like Miss Faith Cartwright.
His breakfast is late, brought by Dora, his landlady’s maid-of-all-work. Simon finds her repulsive and imagines she deliberately ruins his food. He thinks of writing a letter to his mother but feels fraudulent. From his drawer he takes a pamphlet sent by Reverend Verringer that contains the confessions and portraits of Grace Marks and James McDermott. He recalls his first meeting with Grace, where his melodramatic expectations were undercut by her calm, assessing demeanour. Dora brings his breakfast; Simon is annoyed at the undercooked egg and hard toast. He mentally composes a falsely cheerful note to his mother about the spring weather.
Key Events
- Simon’s uneasy morning: He sits at his writing table, watching the stormy lake and feeling dispirited about his precarious situation.
- His background revealed: He studied medicine to rebel against his father, but the family mills collapsed, leaving him with a reduced inheritance and dependent on his reputation.
- Private asylum dream: He imagines writing a prospectus for an asylum with cheerful rooms, proper ventilation, and a flowing river, but knows it is a pipe dream without money or a name.
- Marriage pressure: He considers the option of marrying for money, thinking of Miss Faith Cartwright with distaste.
- Dora brings breakfast: Simon’s aversion to Dora is detailed; he suspects she deliberately burns his toast and undercooks his egg.
- The murder pamphlet: He reviews the engraved portraits of Grace Marks and James McDermott, noting the sentimentalized depiction of Grace.
- First interview with Grace recalled: He remembers entering her cell expecting a hysterical, dishevelled woman, but instead finding a composed, observant prisoner who assessed him.
- Dora returns: After banging down the tray, Simon has an associative thought linking Dora to a pig, which leads him to reflect on the mechanism of mania.
- Breakfast disappointment: The egg is nearly raw and the toast cracks; he mentally composes a bland letter home.
Character Development
- Simon Jordan: This chapter deepens his portrait as a man caught between ambition and financial reality. His initial rebellion against his father has become a struggle for survival. He is intelligent but prone to melodramatic imagination, as shown by his contrasting first impressions of Grace. His irritation with Dora reveals a class-based impatience and a tendency toward objectifying women (imagining Dora as a prostitute or a ham). He is also self-aware enough to recognize his own “overheated brain.”
- Dora: Though seen only through Simon’s hostile perspective, Dora emerges as a resentful working-class woman who uses small acts of sabotage to assert power. She is stout, scowling, and deliberately tardy with breakfast.
- Grace Marks (offstage): Though not present in the scene, the memory of her first meeting with Simon contrasts sharply with the portrait in the pamphlet. She appears self-possessed and analytical, defying Simon’s expectations and his own earlier wishful thinking.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- Observation vs. imagination: Simon chides himself for “indulging” in melodrama and vows to stick to scientific observation. This theme recurs throughout the novel, as the boundaries between objective fact and subjective interpretation blur.
- Class and domestic servitude: Dora’s sullen resistance represents a class conflict invisible to Simon’s privileged upbringing. He thinks of European servants as “knowing their places”; Dora’s defiance unsettles him.
- Associative thought and madness: Simon’s mental leap from Dora to pig to ham leads him to theorize that mania may be a failure to distinguish literal from fanciful associations—an early clue to his scientific method and to the novel’s interest in how the mind works.
- Visual imagery and deception: The engraved portrait of Grace as a sentimental heroine clashes with the real woman he meets, setting up a motif of appearances that mislead.
Why This Chapter Matters
Chapter 7 establishes Simon Jordan’s personal and professional vulnerabilities, making him a more complex character than a detached scientist. His financial precarity and his dependence on reputation explain his intense interest in Grace Marks: she is his best chance for a breakthrough. The chapter also introduces the central tension between romanticized expectations (the prison scene) and the reality of Grace’s composed, watchful nature. Finally, Simon’s reflections on associative logic foreshadow the novel’s exploration of memory, trauma, and the construction of truth.
Study Questions and Answers
1. What does Simon’s reaction to Dora reveal about his character?
Simon views Dora with disgust and imagines her as stubborn, vengeful, and sub-human (a “pig”). His lack of empathy and his mental objectification of her reflect his class bias and his tendency to reduce women to stereotypes. At the same time, he is introspective enough to analyze his own thoughts, showing a dual nature of observation and prejudice.
2. Why does Simon think of Asylum reform but lack the means to pursue it?
Simon’s father’s bankruptcy wiped out the fortune that would have allowed him to pursue science without financial worry. He now needs a practical success—such as a discovery about Grace—to attract investors. The chapter highlights how economic reality constrains even noble ambitions.
3. How does the memory of his first interview with Grace challenge Simon’s self-image?
Simon had prepared himself to encounter a hysterical, insane prisoner, but Grace’s calm, assessing look made him the object of scrutiny. He realizes he was “indulging” in melodrama and imagination rather than scientific detachment. This moment humbles him and sets him up to approach Grace with more caution.
Previous Chapter
Chapter 6 Summary
Next Chapter
Chapter 8 Summary
Back to Book Hub
The Margaret Atwood 4-Book Bundle