Chapter summaries The Margaret Atwood 4-Book Bundle Margaret Atwood

Chapter 23 Summary: Tony Tells Zenia the Story of Her Parents

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

In Christie’s Coffee Shop late at night, Tony recounts to Zenia the story of her mother's abandonment. Anthea ran off to California with a life insurance man named Perry, leaving Tony alone with her father. Tony recalls the empty house, Ethel the housekeeper's cold reaction, and her father's silent grief over tomato soup. Over the following years, Griff (Tony's father) became an alcoholic, occasionally chasing Tony through the house. Tony coped by studying backwards etymology and history. Anthea sent postcards and ill-fitting clothes, but never visited. She died by drowning off Baja California, supposedly an accident. Tony took the call from the new man, Roger. Griff later committed suicide after Tony's high school graduation, leaving a note and a Luger pistol. Tony tells Zenia she feels no nightmares, only a historian's detachment. Zenia pressures Tony to dispose of her mother's ashes, calling them bad luck. The chapter ends with the two of them scattering the metal cylinder from a ferry into the lake at twilight.

Key Events

  • Tony narrates her mother Anthea's departure with Perry to California, as recalled in the coffee shop.
  • The immediate aftermath: Tony finds her mother's closet full of clothes, sees them as hostages.
  • Ethel informs Tony matter-of-factly that “your mother’s run away,” offering no comfort.
  • Griff warms tomato soup for supper; both eat in awkward silence.
  • Tony’s father develops alcoholism; she learns to monitor his drunkenness and barricade her room.
  • Anthea's sporadic, ill-fitting gifts and postcards arrive; later, she sends photographs with different men.
  • Griff gives away Anthea’s clothes to the Salvation Army, confirming she will never return.
  • Tony receives a phone call from Roger: Anthea drowned off Baja California.
  • Griff dies by suicide after Tony's graduation, leaving a note and his Luger.
  • Tony inherits the house money and her mother's ashes; she stores them on a sweater shelf.
  • Zenia convinces Tony the ashes are unlucky; they take a ferry and throw the canister into the lake.

Character Development

  • Tony: Reveals her childhood coping mechanisms—linguistic reversal, historical study, emotional suppression. She describes herself as “well armoured” against violent death. Her detachment is shown in her lack of rage or nightmares. Yet she admits she once longed for comfort from the unlikeliest source (Ethel). Tony’s agreement to scatter the ashes suggests she is still susceptible to Zenia’s influence.
  • Zenia: Displays a new side: superstition and a belief in ill-wishing. She laughs at Tony’s story but shifts to an urgent, almost intrusive caretaking role. Her remark “you are a gruesome little creature” is both playful and condescending.
  • Griff: Portrayed as a weak, drinking man who cannot articulate his pain. His suicide note states Tony’s graduation was all he was waiting for. Despite his violence and abandonment, Ethel remembers him as “considerate, a gentleman.”
  • Anthea: Remains an absent presence. Her actions—running off, sending wrong-sized clothes, dying ambiguously—define her as a figure of perpetual loss. Tony’s final act of scattering her ashes symbolizes a reluctant release.
  • Ethel: A minor but pivotal figure: pragmatic, unsentimental, yet the one who handles Tony’s first period and the eventual cleanup. Her muttered “Pleaseplease” hints at her own grief.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Linguistic reversal: Tony whispers words backwards (“otamot” for tomato, “aehtna” for Anthea) to empty them of meaning. This motif underscores her attempt to control trauma by stripping language of emotional weight.
  • Clothes as hostages: Anthea’s abandoned wardrobe symbolizes Tony’s belief that her mother would return. When the clothes are given away, Tony accepts permanence.
  • Tomato soup and casseroles: The inadequate food prepared by Griff and Ethel represents the emotional and nutritional neglect of the household.
  • Ashes and water: The mother’s ashes—first stored, then tossed into the lake—serve as a tangible remnant of unfinished grief. Zenia’s insistence on disposal highlights her desire to sever Tony’s past.
  • History as armor: Tony’s study of dates and battles (Julius Caesar, sieges) is a deliberate strategy to fill emptiness and shield herself from pain. She is “steeled” to violence.
  • The absent father’s unspoken story: Griff’s unsaid accusations and excuses—the suspicion that Tony was an “accident” from a hasty wartime marriage—hover over the narrative.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter provides the backstory that explains Tony’s adult personality: her emotional detachment, her love of order and languages, her avoidance of deep personal attachments. It also deepens the reader’s understanding of her relationship with Zenia. Tony voluntarily shares her most vulnerable memories with Zenia, and Zenia’s response—laughing, then commanding—foreshadows the manipulative power she wields. The chapter establishes Tony’s parents as ghosts that still influence her, despite her claims otherwise. The ash-scattering scene is a turning point: Tony performs a ritual she doesn’t believe in, purely to please Zenia, revealing her loneliness and need for connection.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Tony feel “no rage” about her mother’s desertion, and what does this suggest about her coping mechanisms?
    Tony says she does not discover any fury, only cold panic and desolation. She speculates that rage might be dangerous—or a relief. This suggests she learned early to suppress strong emotions, replacing them with intellectual pursuits (backwards words, historical study). Her lack of rage is a survival strategy, not genuine forgiveness.

  2. What is the significance of Tony pouring out her father’s liquor?
    Tony performs this experiment to test her own fear. She notices that the ensuing chaos (broken glass) no longer frightens her. This moment marks a shift: she ceases to see herself as responsible for her father’s behavior and begins to regard his suffering as “flat” and “wordless”—a mirror of her own. It demonstrates her growing emotional hardening.

  3. How does Zenia’s reaction to Tony’s story differ from Tony’s own reaction, and what does this reveal about their relationship?
    Zenia expresses shock and says she would have been enraged; she later calls Tony “gruesome” for keeping the ashes. Tony, in contrast, speaks with clinical calm. Zenia’s push to dispose of the ashes shows she wants to take control of Tony’s narrative. Tony complies not out of belief but to please Zenia, indicating she values Zenia’s companionship more than her own autonomy in this moment.

Navigation