Good Dirt Chapter 78: Hesitation – Summary and Analysis
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
Ebby continues to delay her departure from France. She acknowledges that much of her hesitation is linked to Robert—his demeanor, his treatment of his grandfather, and the comfort she finds in their daily life. She also wants to wait for Hannah to return so they can take the trips they planned. However, if she stays much longer, she will have to call her parents and tell them about Henry's visit before they hear it from someone else. Three weeks have passed since Henry left. Ebby picks up her phone to call her mother but realizes it is the middle of the night in Connecticut. Unable to act, she sits down to write.
Key Events
- Ebby reflects on why she keeps postponing her departure from France.
- She links her hesitation to her feelings for Robert and his family.
- Ebby considers the need to inform her parents about Henry being in France.
- She notes that three weeks have elapsed since Henry left.
- Ebby reaches for her phone to call her mother but stops, remembering the time difference.
- She chooses to sit down and write instead.
Character Development
Ebby is caught in an emotional stalemate. Her attachment to Robert is deepening, but her sense of obligation to her family (especially regarding Henry's visit) pressures her to act. Her hesitation shows a conflict between personal happiness and family duty. By choosing to write rather than call, Ebby delays a difficult conversation, revealing her tendency to avoid confrontation when possible.
Robert is not directly quoted but is characterized through Ebby's observations: his way with her, his treatment of his grandfather. This paints him as a nurturing, grounded person, which strengthens Ebby's reluctance to leave.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- Hesitation: The title encapsulates Ebby's indecision. Her delay is not just about logistics but emotional risk.
- Duty vs. Desire: Ebby must choose between her growing attachment to Robert and her responsibility to her family.
- Time and Distance: The time difference between France and Connecticut symbolizes the gap between her new life and old obligations.
- Writing as Action: When Ebby cannot make a phone call, she writes. Writing here becomes a substitute for direct communication, a way to process without committing.
Why This Chapter Matters
Chapter 78 marks a turning point in Ebby's internal journey. It crystallizes the central conflict of her stay in France: she has built a life she loves, but her past (embodied by Henry and her parents) remains unresolved. Her hesitation sets the stage for a crucial decision in the coming chapters. The act of writing hints that Ebby may find a way to articulate her feelings—perhaps to Robert, to her parents, or to herself.
Study Questions and Answers
-
What specific reasons does Ebby give for hesitating to leave France?
Answer: Ebby cites her feelings for Robert, his kind treatment of his grandfather, and her enjoyment of waking up in the cottage by the river. She also wants to wait for Hannah so they can take their planned trips together. -
Why does Ebby decide not to call her mother immediately?
Answer: She picks up her phone but remembers it is the middle of the night in Connecticut, so there is nothing she can do at that moment. -
What does Ebby do instead of making the phone call?
Answer: She sits down to write.