Chapter summaries Things we never got over Lucy Score

Chapter 46: Tina Sucks – Naomi’s Kidnapping and a Desperate Countdown

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

After an emotional breakdown following Knox’s confession, Naomi receives a frantic text from Waylay saying she’s in trouble. Rushing outside, Naomi is met by her twin sister Tina, who claims Waylay has been taken. Naomi gets into Tina’s car, but Tina quickly handcuffs her to the dashboard with fluffy handcuffs. Tina explains she needs the USB stick that Waylay hid; it contains valuable information that her boyfriend Duncan wants. Tina drives to a dilapidated warehouse where Naomi is brought before Duncan Hugo—the red-haired man from earlier chapters—and several armed men. Inside, Waylay is tied to a chair and gagged. Duncan reveals his affiliation with the Hugo crime syndicate. He threatens to shoot Naomi unless Waylay reveals the USB’s location. Tina argues with Duncan, but he begins a countdown from five. The chapter ends with the count at two, leaving Naomi and Waylay in mortal danger.

Key Events

  • Naomi receives a worrying text from Waylay while cleaning up after a tense conversation with Knox.
  • Tina lures Naomi into her car under the pretense of rescuing Waylay, then handcuffs her.
  • Tina admits she made a bet with Duncan that she could bring Naomi voluntarily; she wins the bet.
  • Naomi is taken to a warehouse filled with stolen goods, cash, and armed men.
  • Waylay is discovered bound and gagged on a chair; the dog Waylon is present.
  • Duncan reveals his full identity as a member of the Hugo crime syndicate.
  • He threatens to shoot Naomi if Waylay does not hand over the missing USB stick.
  • The chapter closes with Duncan counting down from five, reaching two.

Character Development

  • Naomi transitions from heartbreak over Knox to fierce protectiveness when Waylay is in danger. She shows resourcefulness by trying to inch closer to Waylay during the standoff. Her internal resolve to be her own hero marks a significant growth point.
  • Tina remains chaotic and selfish, yet reveals unexpected affection for Waylay and anger at Duncan for insulting her daughter. Her priorities are still misplaced (money before freeing her child), but she does challenge Duncan’s body-shaming.
  • Waylay demonstrates defiance and bravery: she attempted to kick Duncan and bit him, and later tries to tip her chair to escape. Despite being tied up, she remains alert and communicates through her eyes.
  • Duncan (Duncan Hugo) is established as a volatile, cruel figure who weaponizes his gun and enjoys psychological intimidation. His mockery of family and his own “daddy issues” shows his instability.
  • Knox is absent from this chapter, but his previous words linger in Naomi’s thoughts, influencing her decision to stand alone.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Family Bonds: The chapter contrasts Tina’s toxic familial role with Naomi’s genuine care for Waylay. Even Tina’s flawed love surfaces when she defends Waylay from body-shaming.
  • Betrayal and Trust: Tina exploits Naomi’s trust to kidnap her, yet the bond between Naomi and Waylay deepens under threat.
  • Survival and Self-Reliance: Naomi realizes she cannot rely on Knox or the police in this moment; she must save herself and Waylay, reinforcing the theme of personal agency.
  • The USB Stick symbolizes both Tina’s criminal schemes and a potential key to their escape—it represents information as power.
  • Fluffy Handcuffs: A darkly comedic motif underscoring Tina’s absurdity and the twisted nature of their sibling relationship.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 46 shifts the plot from romantic tension to a high-stakes thriller. Naomi’s kidnapping forces her to confront her past with Tina head-on and to act without Knox’s protection. The chapter raises the stakes for Waylay’s custody battle and reveals the criminal network behind Tina’s disappearances. It sets up a life-or-death countdown that will likely be resolved in the next chapter, making this a critical turning point for Naomi’s character arc.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Question: Why does Tina win the bet with Duncan, and what does this say about her manipulation skills?
    Answer: Tina wins the bet because she correctly predicts that Naomi will voluntarily get into her car after hearing about Waylay’s danger. It shows Tina’s ability to exploit Naomi’s protective instincts, revealing that she understands her sister’s weaknesses even after years of estrangement.

  2. Question: What does Duncan’s countdown reveal about his psychology and the power dynamics in the room?
    Answer: The countdown demonstrates Duncan’s need for control and his enjoyment of terror. By giving a deadline, he forces Waylay to comply and creates panic. It also shows that Tina’s influence over him is limited—his threat supersedes her objections.

  3. Question: How does Naomi’s mindset change from the beginning to the end of the chapter?
    Answer: At the start, Naomi is emotionally reeling from Knox’s confession. By the end, she shifts into survival mode, focusing entirely on freeing Waylay. She accepts that she must be her own hero, a major step in her independence.

Navigation