Chapter summaries The Devils Joe Abercrombie

Chapter 72: Saint Tabitha’s Day – Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

The chapter opens on the fourth of Generosity in the Holy City. Mother Beckert, a veteran missionary, rides through crowded streets filled with flagellants, beggars, prostitutes, and the din of competing church bells. She shares a carriage with a flamboyant young man named Caruso, who introduces himself as a “mongrel” from everywhere and nowhere. Their conversation reveals Beckert’s deep disgust with the corruption of the Church, especially the hypocrisy she sees in the cardinals and the so-called Saved. She learns that Caruso has been summoned by the Pope, but she suspects the real meeting will be with Cardinal Zizka, the Head of the Earthly Curia. Beckert reveals she also received a letter summoning her to become a replacement, likely for the Thirteenth Chapel—a mysterious chapel within the Celestial Palace that, according to Caruso, does not exist among the twelve standard chapels. The chapter ends with Beckert observing that Caruso has much to learn about virtue.

Key Events

  • Mother Beckert’s carriage is buffeted by flagellants and passes through a square filled with licensed beggars, burning of straw elves, and numerous prostitutes.
  • Beckert shares the carriage with Caruso, who is also heading to the Celestial Palace for an audience with Her Holiness.
  • Beckert criticizes the hypocrisy of the Holy City, stating that the prostitutes are merely a symptom of a deeper sickness.
  • She reveals that her own mother was a prostitute, and that she disapproves of hypocrisy—the pretence of being holier than one is—more than any other sin.
  • Caruso shows his summons letter; Beckert shows hers as well.
  • Beckert identifies Cardinal Zizka as the true orchestrator behind the appointments and describes their long history as rivals.
  • Beckert names the Thirteenth Chapel as her likely destination, a place Caruso had not heard of.
  • Caruso’s accent slips, hinting at a hidden background, possibly German.

Character Development

Mother Beckert emerges as a hardened, blunt, and principled woman. She has spent years in extreme missionary work and views bodily discomfort as a means to purify faith. She despises dishonesty and the institutional hypocrisy of the Church. Her backstory (a former prostitute’s daughter, a seminary classmate of Zizka) adds depth and reveals her personal stake in the confrontation to come. She is the “rock on which the water breaks,” positioning herself as immovable against Zizka’s adaptable, sea-like nature.

Caruso is introduced as charming, handsome, and evasive. He claims to be from everywhere and nowhere, with a silver tooth and filed nails. His nervous chatter and occasional slips in accent (a German tinge) suggest he is not who he pretends to be. He is both excited and afraid when he learns the meeting is with Zizka, not the Pope.

Cardinal Zizka remains offstage but is powerfully evoked through Beckert’s words: “ever hungry, never sated … treacherous as the tide.” The chapter establishes her as a formidable political operator.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Hypocrisy vs. Honesty: Beckert frames hypocrisy as the only unforgivable sin, contrasting the Church’s public piety with its inner corruption.
  • Rock and Sea: Beckert describes herself as a rock, Zizka as the sea. This motif suggests an eternal struggle between steadfast principle and adaptable power.
  • The Thirteenth Chapel: A symbol of hidden truth or forbidden knowledge. The number twelve relates to the Twelve Virtues; a thirteenth implies something outside the official order, possibly a place for dealing with the unexplained or the diabolical.
  • Saint Tabitha’s Day: The saint’s day provides the setting, a public holiday during which the Church performs a formal reading of miracles. The contrast between holy celebration and the squalor of the streets reinforces the theme of religious hypocrisy.
  • The Carriage: A confined space where two strangers reveal their purposes and clash in worldview, setting the stage for their future partnership or conflict.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 72 reintroduces Mother Beckert, a character who plays a central role in the novel’s exploration of faith, corruption, and the battle for the soul of the Church. It establishes the Holy City as a morally rotten heart of Christendom and sets up the mystery of the Thirteenth Chapel. Beckert’s history with Zizka creates immediate tension, and her meeting with Caruso hints at an alliance or rivalry that will drive the plot forward. The chapter also deepens the theme of hidden identities and the cost of honesty in a system built on appearances.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. What is the significance of the Thirteenth Chapel, and why does Caruso not know about it?

    • The Thirteenth Chapel is a secret or forgotten chapel within the Celestial Palace. Caruso, despite his worldly knowledge, has never heard of it, suggesting it is deliberately concealed from public or even clerical knowledge. Beckert’s summons to it implies she is being brought back for a sensitive, possibly dangerous assignment. The twelve chapels represent the official virtues; a thirteenth suggests something that does not fit the official narrative—perhaps a place for dealing with heretics, demons, or unsanctioned miracles.

  2. How does Mother Beckert’s view of hypocrisy shape her character and her conflict with Cardinal Zizka?

    • Beckert sees hypocrisy as the worst sin because it is a form of dishonesty that cannot be forgiven without sincere confession. She criticizes the Holy City’s prostitutes as symptoms of a deeper sickness: the Church’s own hypocrisy. Her opposition to Zizka is rooted in Zizka’s willingness to adapt her principles to achieve power. Beckert’s self-image as the “rock” implies she will not compromise, making her a direct antithesis to Zizka’s fluid, political nature. This sets up a fundamental clash between integrity and expedience.

  3. What does Caruso’s reaction to learning of Cardinal Zizka reveal about his character and his role in the story?

    • Caruso is both afraid and excited, indicating he knows Zizka’s reputation as a dangerous and powerful figure. His earlier flippancy vanishes, revealing a more serious and vulnerable side. The slip in his accent hints that he may be hiding his origins, possibly being German like Beckert. This suggests Caruso is not merely a charming rogue but has a hidden past that will connect him to the central conflict. His fate is likely tied to the Thirteenth Chapel and to Beckert’s mission.

Navigation