Chapter 14 Summary: Lizzy's August 20, 2019 Narrative
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
On August 20, 2019, Lizzy and Skink meet three teenagers—Alex, Riley, and Zoey—at a pier in downtown Chickering Island, Vermont. Lizzy is recording an interview for her podcast about the disappearance of Lauren Schumacher. The teens are friends of Lauren and have agreed to share their stories.
The interview begins with the teens describing Lauren as a poet and artist with a “genius” mind, but also as someone who acts tough and moody. Alex reveals that Lauren was expelled from her Massachusetts school for choking a classmate, an act he believes shows she is “messed up.” Riley defends Lauren, suggesting the classmate deserved it, and criticizes Lauren’s parents for sending her to a treatment program in Upstate New York, which she describes as a “brainwashing place” and a “cult.” Lauren reportedly hated the six-week program, saying she’d rather be in prison. After the program, her parents brought her to the island for “together time,” but Lauren resented being dragged to a place with no Wi-Fi or cell service.
The teens explain that Lauren often escaped to Loon Cove, a secluded pebbly beach. She kept personal items—weed, cigarettes—in a hollow tree there. One day she found a flower in the tree, then a coin, then a piece of sea glass. Zoey believes these were gifts from Rattling Jane, a local legend. Lauren eventually called out to Jane, who appeared from the water, draped in weeds and bones. Jane told Lauren she had to “earn” a wish. Lauren continued visiting the cove, and Jane left more gifts, eventually giving Lauren a “wishing stone.” Lauren showed the stone to her friends, but later became upset, saying she had angered Jane by showing it to others and that Jane would not grant her wish.
The teens disagree about whether Rattling Jane is real. Alex insists it’s all a story Lauren made up for attention, calling her “fucked in the head.” Zoey, however, is convinced Jane is real and fears she took Lauren. Riley is uncertain. They all admit they haven’t returned to Loon Cove since Lauren disappeared. The chapter ends with Lizzy looking out at the water, wondering if the legend could be true.
Key Events
-
Lizzy and Skink interview Alex, Riley, and Zoey at the pier.
-
The teens describe Lauren’s background: her artistic talent, her expulsion for choking a classmate, and her time in a treatment program.
-
Lauren’s parents brought her to the island for family time, but she fought with her father, who was controlling and allegedly hit her.
-
Lauren spent nights at Loon Cove, where she found gifts in a hollow tree.
-
Lauren called out to Rattling Jane, who appeared and told her she had to earn a wish.
-
Jane gave Lauren a wishing stone, but Lauren angered Jane by showing it to others.
-
The teens last saw Lauren on the day she disappeared, upset about Jane’s anger.
-
The teens disagree on whether Rattling Jane is real, and none will return to Loon Cove.
Character Development
Lizzy demonstrates her investigative approach, gently guiding the interview and probing for details. She listens without judgment, allowing the teens to share conflicting views. Her internal reflection at the end shows she is open to the possibility of the supernatural, as she watches the water “as if it were really touched by magic.”
Skink serves as a local guide, vouching for Lizzy and reinforcing the legend of Rattling Jane. His comment “you don’t want to piss off Rattling Jane” shows his belief in the story.
Alex is skeptical and dismissive, viewing Lauren as dramatic and attention-seeking. He calls her “messed up” and believes she fabricated the entire story to escape her life.
Riley is more sympathetic, defending Lauren’s actions and criticizing her parents. She provides details about the gifts and the wishing stone, but remains uncertain about Jane’s existence.
Zoey is the most convinced of Jane’s reality. She is visibly shaken, hugging herself and rocking, and refuses to return to the cove. Her belief gives weight to the legend.
Lauren is portrayed through the teens’ memories as a complex figure: a talented artist with a rebellious streak, a victim of parental control, and a girl who may have sought escape through a supernatural encounter.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Belief vs. Skepticism: The chapter centers on the conflict between Alex’s rational dismissal and Zoey’s fearful belief. This tension drives the mystery and reflects how people interpret unexplained events.
Parental Control and Abuse: Lauren’s father is described as controlling and physically abusive, and her parents sent her to a treatment program she hated. This theme highlights the ways authority can push a young person toward desperate measures.
Escape and Disappearance: Lauren’s disappearance is framed as either a runaway act or a supernatural abduction. The hollow tree and the cove represent places of refuge and potential danger.
The Wishing Stone: A symbol of hope and desire, but also of consequence—Lauren must “earn” her wish, and her failure to keep the stone secret leads to her downfall.
Persona vs. True Self: Zoey argues that Lauren’s tough exterior is a “total persona” hiding her real artistic soul. This motif questions identity and the masks people wear.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter introduces key witnesses to Lauren’s disappearance and establishes the central legend of Rattling Jane. It provides crucial background on Lauren’s troubled life, her conflicts with her parents, and her secretive behavior at Loon Cove. The teens’ conflicting accounts create ambiguity about whether Lauren ran away, was taken by a monster, or was a victim of something else. The chapter also deepens Lizzy’s investigation, showing her willingness to consider supernatural explanations, and sets up future developments in the search for Lauren.
Study Questions and Answers
1. What are the main points of disagreement among the teens about Rattling Jane?
Alex believes Lauren invented the story to get attention, calling her “fucked in the head” and dismissing the stone as “just a regular rock.” Zoey is convinced Jane is real and took Lauren, refusing to return to the cove. Riley is uncertain, providing details but not committing to a belief. Their disagreement highlights the central mystery of the chapter.
2. How does Lauren’s background explain her behavior and her attraction to Loon Cove?
Lauren was expelled from school for choking a classmate, sent to a treatment program she hated, and brought to an island with no Wi-Fi or cell service. Her father was controlling and allegedly hit her. Loon Cove offered an escape from her parents and a place where she could keep secrets. The hollow tree and the gifts from Jane gave her a sense of agency and hope, which she desperately needed.
3. What is the significance of the hollow tree and the gifts Lauren received?
The hollow tree serves as a secret hiding place for Lauren’s contraband and later as a conduit for Jane’s gifts. The progression from a flower to a coin to sea glass suggests a growing relationship with Jane. The gifts create a sense of wonder and obligation, leading Lauren to call out to Jane and eventually receive the wishing stone. The tree symbolizes the boundary between the ordinary world and the supernatural, and Lauren’s willingness to cross it.
Navigation
-
Next Chapter: Chapter 15 Summary