Chapter summaries Take My Hand Dolen Perkins-Valdez

Chapter 39 Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

The trial of the Williams case opens in early October 1973 in the Montgomery federal courthouse, the same building where Judge Frank Johnson issued landmark civil rights rulings. Lou Feldman delivers his opening statement, describing Mace and Mrs. Williams as illiterate farmers who were deceived by Mrs. Seager. Civil, listening from the audience, internally rejects this characterization. She knows the Williamses are intelligent and resourceful—Mrs. Williams can identify the exact amount of nutmeg in a pie, and Mace understands soil and trees in ways Civil cannot. They are not simple victims, but a family whose potential was limited by poverty and lack of opportunity.

The defendants, Caspar Weinberger (Secretary of HEW) and Alvin Arnett (Director of OEO), sit at the defense table with their lawyers. Civil notes that she is the only Black person in the courtroom audience, a stark reminder of the racial and class divide between the Washington officials and the Williamses.

During a recess, Lou shares troubling news: the ACLU has sent him documents revealing that hundreds of Black women in North and South Carolina were sterilized, but the defense objects to introducing this evidence because it was not part of pretrial discovery. Lou is frustrated but continues. He presents FDA regulations requiring informed consent for investigational drugs, citing the Kefauver-Harris Amendment. The judge questions whether the plaintiffs can claim injury from Depo-Provera, and Lou admits they cannot yet prove physical harm. Lou then submits affidavits from three Alabama clinic directors stating that written notices were not standard practice. The defense counters that the federal government treats all people the same and that written notices were available upon request. Civil finds this absurd, especially given the Tuskegee syphilis study.

Lou’s strategy becomes clear: first prove that Depo-Provera was administered without informed consent, then argue that sterilization was part of a systemic abuse of poor Black families. Civil reflects on her own guilt—she injected India with the drug without fully understanding it, and she knows she should have questioned Mrs. Seager.

Meanwhile, Civil continues teaching Mace to read on Sundays. Their lessons grow intimate, and one afternoon, Mace kisses her. Civil is surprised but ready; their attraction has been building for months. They begin a relationship, though Civil tries to convince herself she has everything under control. When Mrs. Williams enters the room, Civil continues the lesson as if nothing happened, and she nervously offers to teach Mrs. Williams to read, but Mrs. Williams declines.

Key Events

  • The trial opens in the Montgomery federal courthouse, with Lou Feldman delivering his opening statement.

  • Civil observes that she is the only Black person in the audience, highlighting the racial and class divide.

  • Lou receives ACLU documents about sterilizations of Black women in the Carolinas, but the defense objects because they were not in pretrial discovery.

  • Lou presents FDA regulations on informed consent, but the judge questions whether the plaintiffs can claim injury.

  • Lou submits affidavits from three clinic directors stating that written notices were not standard practice.

  • The defense argues that the government treats everyone the same, which Civil finds disingenuous.

  • Lou reveals his two-part strategy: first prove lack of informed consent, then argue sterilization as systemic abuse.

  • Civil and Mace share a kiss during a reading lesson, beginning a romantic relationship.

Character Development

Civil is deeply affected by the trial. She struggles with guilt over her role in India’s sterilization, acknowledging that she should have questioned the drug before injecting it. Her internal monologue reveals a growing awareness of her own privilege and the systemic failures that allowed such abuses to happen. She also begins to confront her feelings for Mace, which complicate her professional and personal life.

Lou Feldman is portrayed as determined and strategic, but also under immense pressure. He works tirelessly, often neglecting his personal life. His frustration with the legal obstacles—such as the discovery objection—shows the difficulty of proving systemic injustice in court.

Mace shows vulnerability in his willingness to learn to read, and his kiss with Civil reveals a more assertive, passionate side. He is not just a victim; he is a man with desires and agency.

Mrs. Williams remains a quiet presence, but her refusal to learn to read suggests a certain pride or resignation, and her observation of Civil and Mace hints at her awareness of their connection.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Informed Consent and Medical Ethics: The chapter centers on the legal argument that Depo-Provera was administered without proper consent, highlighting the ethical failures of medical experimentation on marginalized communities.

Systemic Racism in Healthcare: Civil’s reflection on Tuskegee and the defense’s claim that the government treats everyone the same underscore the deep-seated racial biases in medical institutions.

Class Divide: The contrast between the Washington officials and the Williamses—and Civil’s own position as a middle-class Black woman—emphasizes the chasm between those with power and those without.

Guilt and Accountability: Civil’s guilt over India’s injection drives her commitment to the case, but also weighs on her conscience.

Forbidden Love: The kiss between Civil and Mace crosses boundaries of class, education, and perhaps propriety, adding a personal dimension to the political struggle.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is pivotal because it establishes the legal framework of the trial and reveals the obstacles Lou faces in proving systemic abuse. It also deepens Civil’s character, showing her internal conflict between her professional duty and her personal guilt. The romantic development with Mace adds a layer of complexity, suggesting that Civil’s involvement with the Williams family is not purely professional. The chapter also highlights the broader historical context of forced sterilizations and medical racism, making the case a symbol of larger injustices.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Civil disagree with Lou’s portrayal of the Williamses in his opening statement?

Civil knows the Williamses are intelligent and skilled—Mrs. Williams can identify ingredients by taste, and Mace has deep knowledge of the natural world. She feels Lou reduces them to “illiterate farmers” and victims, ignoring their resilience and potential.

2. What is Lou’s two-part legal strategy in this chapter?

Lou first aims to prove that Depo-Provera was administered without informed consent, using FDA regulations and affidavits from clinic directors. Then he plans to argue that sterilization was part of a systemic abuse of poor Black families, connecting the case to broader patterns of medical racism.

3. How does Civil’s guilt about India influence her actions and thoughts during the trial?

Civil reflects on her failure to question the drug before injecting India, and she feels a deep sense of responsibility. This guilt motivates her to support the case, but it also makes her more aware of the power dynamics between medical professionals and patients.

Navigation

← Previous Chapter

Next Chapter →

Back to Book Hub

Published by What Happened?

How this guide was made Report an error