Chapter 4 Summary, Analysis, and Key Takeaways

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Return to the book hub if you'd like to start from the beginning.

Previous chapter | Next chapter

Summary

The chapter opens the morning after the tense carpool arrangement began. The narrator, Scots, deliberately arrives early to Irene's house, but Irene is already waiting, and they immediately clash over music and a spilled coffee. Scots blasts Fine Young Cannibals to provoke Irene, and they ride in silence.

By Thursday, the school is buzzing with Homecoming energy. The principal announces that final voting for Homecoming Court will happen during Friday homeroom, and Irene's name is on everyone's lips. At lunch, Scots and her friends—Gunther, Kevin, and Danielle—are lounging on the grass when Charlotte Pascal, the varsity soccer captain, approaches. Charlotte hands Scots a Rice Krispies Treat and asks for her vote for Homecoming Queen. The group is stunned by the attention, and Scots notes that Charlotte and Irene have a long-standing rivalry. Scots also mentions her theory that Charlotte gives off queer energy, a theory only her ex Tally ever agreed with.

That afternoon, the cheerleaders show up to watch the basketball team practice, this time bringing the boys' basketball team with them. The crowd boosts the team's performance, and Danielle is impressed, but Scots dismisses Irene's role, insisting she's just bored. After practice, Irene lingers to talk to Honey-Belle, and Scots honks the horn impatiently. When Irene finally gets in the car, she announces she's getting her car back this weekend and won't need rides anymore. Scots is relieved, but the relief turns to conflict when they argue about cheerleading's legitimacy. Irene reveals she's pursuing Student Athlete of the Year, a prestigious award no cheerleader has ever won. Scots dismisses the idea, and the argument escalates until Scots makes a cutting remark about Irene's mother, implying that even Irene's mom doesn't take her seriously. Irene is visibly hurt, her eyes wet, and they ride in silence. When they arrive at her house, Irene slams the door.

That night, Scots tells her sisters Thora and Daphne about the fight. Thora suggests Scots has been insecure ever since dating Tally, and that Tally got into her head. Scots privately reflects on the tow truck incident—a prank Irene pulled on her last year—but she doesn't share the details with her sisters. She wonders if her insecurity stems from that event and from Tally's rejection, and she admits that carpooling with Irene made her feel cool for the first time all year.

Key Events

Scots and Irene clash over music and a coffee spill during the morning drive.
The principal announces Homecoming Court voting for Friday homeroom, and Irene's name circulates widely.
Charlotte Pascal gives Scots a Rice Krispies Treat and asks for her vote for Homecoming Queen.
The cheerleaders and boys' basketball team attend the girls' basketball practice, drawing a crowd.
Irene tells Scots she's getting her car back and won't need rides anymore.
Scots and Irene argue about cheerleading's competitiveness, and Irene reveals her goal of winning Student Athlete of the Year.
Scots makes a cruel remark about Irene's mother, leaving Irene upset.
Scots confesses to her sisters that she was cruel, and Thora suggests she's been insecure since dating Tally.
Scots reflects on the tow truck incident but keeps it to herself.

Character Development

Scots shows a darker side in this chapter. Her need to provoke Irene—turning up the music, honking the horn—reveals a petty streak, but her cruelty toward Irene's mother crosses a line she herself recognizes. She admits to her sisters that she