Chapter 25: The Seething Knot

Spoiler Notice: This page contains full spoilers for Rhythm of War through Chapter 25. Proceed only if you have read this chapter.

Summary

Adolin spends much of the chapter preparing for the expedition into Shadesmar—first by agonizing over his jacket choice, then by assembling weapons and checking on his team. Shallan teases him about his fashion deliberation. After settling on a custom uniform Dalinar had once rejected, Adolin uses his spare hour to visit Kaladin, who now works in a clinic run by his parents. Their conversation reveals Kaladin's lingering trauma; Adolin gives him a coin from Zahel inscribed with conflicting messages about war. Syl appears and warns Adolin about honorspren, who prioritize felt morality over logic—especially with Honor dead.

On the Oathgate platform, Adolin inspects his horse Gallant and enthusiastically catalogs his non-Shardblade weaponry to Godeke. He speaks with Zu about Shardblades, then mentally reviews the expedition roster: soldiers, Radiants, and Shallan's Lightweavers. Jasnah tests Vathah and Ishnah on Soulcasting while Shallan watches. Dalinar delivers a speech, then confronts Adolin privately, warning him against Taravangian's utilitarian philosophy. Adolin suppresses his seething anger over Dalinar's past—particularly his mother's death—and realizes his father hopes he will bond a spren and become a Radiant. Shallan activates the Oathgate by manipulating the mechanism, and the expedition transfers into Shadesmar.

Key Events

Adolin chooses a uniform he designed years ago, which Dalinar once called disgraceful.
Shallan arrives in practical traveling clothes, not in her Veil persona.
Adolin visits Kaladin at the sixth-floor clinic and notices Kaladin's instinctive reach for surgery knives at sudden movement.
Adolin gives Kaladin Zahel's coin with dual inscriptions: "War is the last option of the state that has failed" and "But it is better than having no options."
Syl warns Adolin that honorspren follow felt morality over logic, complicating the diplomatic mission.
Adolin reviews his arsenal of conventional weapons and argues that variety compensates for the loss of Shardblades in Shadesmar.
Jasnah evaluates Shallan's agents on Soulcasting; Vathah transforms obsidian into lavis pulp.
Dalinar delivers a speech and later privately warns Adolin against ends-justify-means reasoning.
Adolin suppresses fury over his mother's death, recognizing it as a "seething knot" he cannot forgive.
Dalinar reveals his hope that Adolin will bond a spren.
Shallan manipulates the Oathgate mechanism with her living Shardblade to transfer the team into Shadesmar.

Character Development

Adolin dominates the chapter. His jacket deliberation parallels duel preparation—both rely on trained instinct. Choosing the once-rejected uniform signals his growing independence from Dalinar. His visit to Kaladin shows genuine concern and emotional intelligence, while the weapon cataloging reinforces his identity as a dueling enthusiast who finds joy in mastery rather than killing. His internal struggle with the "seething knot"—unforgiveness toward Dalinar for his mother's death—adds depth to a character often defined by charm and competence. He ends the chapter feeling like "still a little boy" despite being highprince and expedition leader.

Kaladin appears briefly but significantly. Working in the clinic relaxes him, yet his reflexive reach for knives at a sudden noise betrays unresolved trauma. Syl confirms he still has nightmares. His reluctance to enjoy combat contrasts with Adolin's philosophy that one can "hate killing and enjoy the contest."

Dalinar attempts to guide and warn Adolin but comes across as controlling. His evocation of Taravangian's philosophy and the pointed mention of "murdering a man in a back alley" shows he suspects Adolin killed Sadeas. His admission that he wants Adolin to become a Radiant adds pressure to an already strained relationship.

Shallan is present but largely observational, watching Jasnah test her agents while grappling with her inconsistent Soulcasting abilities.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Instinct and Preparation: Adolin frames both fashion and combat as arenas where instinct built through deliberate practice determines success.
The Seething Knot: The chapter title directly references Adolin's suppressed rage over his mother's death—a wound he intellectually understands Dalinar wasn't fully responsible for, but cannot emotionally forgive.
War and Moral Philosophy: Zahel's coin offers two opposing views on war: it is a failure of the state, yet better than powerlessness. Dalinar contrasts his journey-based ethics with Taravangian's utilitarian calculations.
Honor as Subjective: Syl's warning that honor is "what humans and spren define it to be" foreshadows the difficulty of negotiating with honorspren whose moral frameworks may differ radically from the humans'.
Fatherhood and Control: Dalinar's hand on Adolin's shoulder is perceived not as comfort but as a positioning tactic, reflecting their communication breakdown.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter serves as the expedition's launch point, assembling the team and establishing interpersonal tensions that will play out in Shadesmar. It deepens Adolin's characterization by revisiting his unresolved anger toward Dalinar—a crucial emotional arc that has simmered since Oathbringer. Kaladin's brief appearance tracks his recovery progress while honestly depicting its limits. Dalinar's speech about Taravangian's philosophy lays groundwork for later revelations about the Diagram and Taravangian's betrayal. Syl's explanation of honorspren psychology sets expectations for the diplomatic challenge ahead. Finally, Jasnah's focus on Soulcasting over illusion hints at the strategic importance of supply lines in the coming war.

Study Questions and Answers

Why does Adolin choose the uniform he designed, and what does this choice reveal about his relationship with Dalinar? Adolin selects a custom uniform Dalinar had previously condemned as "disgraceful." The choice demonstrates Adolin's growing willingness to assert his own identity even at the cost of his father's approval. He explicitly thinks he's "more willing to let you be disappointed by that person," showing a shift from seeking validation to accepting their values may permanently differ.
What is the significance of Zahel's coin, and how does it relate to Kaladin's internal conflict? The coin bears two messages: "War is the last option of the state that has failed" and "But it is better than having no options." It encapsulates the tension between pacifism and the necessity of martial skill. For Kaladin, who "shouldn't enjoy killing" yet finds purpose in protecting others, the coin validates that one can hate violence while still valuing combat readiness.
How does Syl's warning about honorspren connect to the larger themes of the book? Syl explains that honorspren follow "morality" rather than "laws," and that "what we feel can often be more important to us than what we think." This is especially problematic because Honor is dead, leaving no objective standard. This connects to the book's recurring exploration of broken oaths, subjective honor, and whether binding agreements retain meaning when the enforcing deity is gone.

← Previous Chapter | Next Chapter → | Return to Book Hub