Chapter summaries None of This Is True Lisa Jewell

Chapter 39: Wednesday, 28 October – Stolen Objects and a Dangerous Letter

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

DC Albright visits Alix Summer on the afternoon of Wednesday, 28 October, to return a Jiffy bag containing the personal items Josie Fair stole from Alix’s home the previous year. Alix hesitates but then methodically replaces each object around the house: Eliza’s drawing, a receipt, a Nespresso pod, a teaspoon, hand soap, and a strip of passport photographs of Leon (which she pins on the corkboard instead of hiding). The last item is her golden bracelet from Nathan; she asks Leon to help her fasten it and they share a moment affirming that the three of them are “good.” The chapter then jumps to a Netflix documentary segment showing Alix reading a letter she received on 2 November 2020, two months after her podcast ended. The letter, from Josie, accuses Alix of turning her “truth” into “tacky true crime rubbish,” insists she did not intend to kill Nathan, and ominously asks Alix to keep her children—especially Leon—safe. Alix folds the letter, and the text notes she has not heard from Josie since.

Key Events

  • DC Albright arrives at Alix’s home and returns the bag of stolen objects.
  • Alix learns that some items (corsage, hair scrunchie) belonged to Brooke, but the phone case remains unidentified.
  • Alix repositions each object in its original place; she pins Leon’s passport photos on the corkboard instead of hiding them.
  • Leon helps Alix fasten her bracelet and they share a quiet moment of reassurance.
  • A Netflix documentary segment shows Alix reading Josie’s letter aloud.
  • In the letter, Josie berates Alix for the podcast, denies intentionally killing Nathan, and threatens Alix’s family by name-dropping Leon.

Character Development

  • Alix Summer: After months of living with the unease of violated boundaries, Alix reclaims her domestic space by physically restoring the stolen items. Her decision to display Leon’s youthful photos rather than hide them shows a shift toward preserving joy in spite of fear. The bracelet scene with Leon reveals her need to reestablish family unity after Nathan’s death and Josie’s intrusion.
  • DC Albright: The detective’s praise for Alix’s podcast and mention of following a lead in Northampton shows her continued professional investment in the case. Her comment about the phone case being “a mystery” reinforces the unresolved threads of the investigation.
  • Josie Fair: Though absent from the scene, her letter is a masterclass in manipulative rhetoric—she flatters, guilt-trips, denies responsibility, and ends with a veiled threat against Leon. She positions herself as a victim of both Alix and the world, unable to see her own culpability.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Reclamation and Invasion: The act of returning each stolen item becomes a ritual of reclaiming Alix’s home and sense of safety. The physical insertion of the pin into the same old hole on the corkboard symbolizes a near-surgical restoration of order, yet the bracelet’s return simultaneously reminds her of Nathan’s absence.
  • Letters and Voice: Josie’s written letter contrasts with the oral narrative of the podcast. It is a deliberate, crafted attempt to reassert control over how her story is told. The letter also shows Josie’s fixation on being understood and on maintaining a bond with Alix.
  • The Threat of the Familiar: Josie’s mention of Leon by name (“Keep him safe”) weaponizes the domestic intimacy she once had with Alix’s family. The warning turns the restored home into a place that must be guarded again.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter closes the narrative that began with the stolen items in Chapter 1, giving Alix a sense of closure even as the letter reopens the wound. It explicitly connects the podcast’s release to Josie’s response, showing the consequences of Alix’s public storytelling. The postscript—that Alix has not heard from Josie since—creates an ambiguous but unsettling resolution: the threat remains unresolved, and the cat-and-mouse game may continue indefinitely.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Alix decide to pin Leon’s passport photographs on the corkboard instead of hiding them in the messy drawer? Alix chooses to display the photos because they capture Leon before he experienced pain and grief. By celebrating that “caught moment,” she transforms a memento of vulnerability into a symbol of resilience. It is a small act of defiance against Josie’s invasion: she will not hide the people she loves.

2. How does Josie’s letter attempt to manipulate Alix? Provide two specific examples. Josie uses flattery (“I thought you were special”) and guilt (“I gave you my truth, Alix. And what did you do with it?”) to undermine Alix’s credibility and frame herself as a misunderstood martyr. She then introduces a direct threat by claiming she had a “soft spot” for Leon and telling Alix to “keep him safe,” which is both a warning and a reminder of the power she once held inside their home.

3. What does the chain of events in this chapter suggest about Alix’s emotional state? Alix moves methodically through the house replacing objects, which indicates a need for ritual and control after the chaos Josie caused. Her request for Leon’s help with the bracelet and the subsequent “We’re good, aren’t we?” conversation shows she is actively seeking reassurance that her family unit remains intact. The letter, read months later, re-exposes her fragility, but her wry headshake to the interviewer suggests a weary acceptance of the unfinished story.

Navigate