Chapter summaries None of This Is True Lisa Jewell

Chapter 38 Summary: The Interview with Katelyn and the Podcast’s End

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Alix Summer meets Katelyn in person on 15 July 2020, recording their conversation for her podcast. Katelyn apologises and explains that Josie Fair manipulated her into helping trap Nathan. Katelyn insists Nathan was devoted to Alix and never wanted another woman. After the interview, the narrative jumps to the final episode of Hi! I’m Your Birthday Twin! released in August 2020. Alix reflects on the lack of closure—Josie remains at large—and delivers a furious closing statement, calling Josie evil. The screen fades to black as the recording ends.

Key Events

  • Alix meets Katelyn in a socially distanced setting (July 2020, during the pandemic).
  • Katelyn recounts meeting Josie at an alterations shop and believing she was helping Alix escape a cheating husband.
  • Katelyn reveals she took over Nathan’s phone, lied to him that Alix was coming, and instead let Josie collect him.
  • Alix struggles with rage but proceeds with the interview.
  • The chapter then shows the final episode of the podcast, recorded in August on the anniversary of Nathan’s funeral.
  • Alix announces a new puppy, a potential documentary deal, and that her daughters are moving in together.
  • She delivers a blistering monologue condemning Josie’s crimes and rejects any justification.
  • The podcast ends with a single click; the screen goes black.

Character Development

  • Alix Summer – Transforms from a grieving widow into a determined podcaster who refuses to be a passive victim. Her final speech shows new strength and anger, moving beyond sorrow.
  • Katelyn – Initially presented as a reckless co‑conspirator, she now appears remorseful and self‑aware. She acknowledges Nathan’s innocence and takes responsibility for her lies.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • The podcast as testimony and weapon – Alix uses the podcast to control her own narrative, turn public opinion, and deny Josie any sympathetic storyline.
  • Closure vs. ambiguity – Alix admits there is no neat ending; Josie remains free but trapped in a self‑made prison. The unresolved conclusion mirrors true crime’s frequent lack of resolution.
  • Truth and manipulation – Katelyn’s account reveals how easily Josie exploited kindness and misgendered intentions for her own ends.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 38 provides the fullest account of Nathan’s last night from an eyewitness, confirming his loyalty to Alix. It also presents the culmination of Alix’s podcast journey: instead of a tidy resolution, Alix reclaims her voice and definitively condemns Josie. The chapter functions as the emotional climax for Alix, while leaving the wider story (Josie’s fate) deliberately open.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Katelyn agree to participate in Alix’s podcast?
    Katelyn says she wants to help make Alix’s podcast huge, partly out of guilt and partly because she initially believed she was acting for the “sisterhood” to free Alix from a bad marriage.

  2. What does Alix reveal about her feelings toward Nathan in her final podcast message?
    Alix admits she had considered leaving Nathan in the months before his death because of his drinking and absences, but she emphasises that Josie stole her choice and robbed Nathan’s children of their father.

  3. How does the chapter challenge the idea of a happy ending?
    Alix explicitly states that true crime podcasts rarely provide complete closure; Josie is still free, and Alix must learn to live with grief and unanswered questions.

Navigation