Chapter One Summary & Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Julia speaks at the funeral of her close friend Gabe, a talented musician who died suddenly after a shower slip. Her eulogy feels hollow because a month earlier the two friends had slept together—a mistake that left their relationship unresolved. In the restroom, she borrows a tampon from a stranger who turns out to be Elizabeth, Gabe’s ex-girlfriend. Elizabeth icily tells Julia she knows precisely what Julia meant to Gabe, leaving Julia shaken. Later, Julia confesses the hook-up to her friend Will, but keeps it from Casey. The memory of meeting Gabe floods back. Twelve years before, in Barcelona at an arts program, Julia heard Gabe singing in a courtyard. At a party she met him in person; they bonded over his voice, architecture, and songs by women, then walked through Gaudí’s Parc Güell and shared a first kiss. Back in the present at the burial, Julia’s grief curdles into anger: she mentally calls Gabe a “fucking jerk” for leaving things so broken.

Key Events

Julia delivers a eulogy at Gabe’s funeral, hiding her complicated anger.
Kathy, Gabe’s manager, shares an old story of Gabe going out of his way to see Julia.
In the bathroom, Elizabeth (Gabe’s ex) hands Julia a tampon, then coldly confronts her.
Julia tells Will that she and Gabe slept together a month ago and that he then stopped responding.
Flashback to the summer of the HEYSA arts program in Barcelona, where Julia first heard Gabe sing.
At a party hosted by Professor Roberta, Gabe makes Julia a peanut butter sandwich.
Julia and Gabe explore Parc Güell, talk about music and feminism, eat dinner, and his first kiss.
At the cemetery, Julia watches the coffin lowered and silently rages at Gabe.

Character Development

Julia: The narrator reveals her layered grief: public poise (the eulogy) versus private anger and confusion. Her willingness to confide in Will but not Casey shows strategic vulnerability. The flashback exposes her early loneliness and how quickly Gabe became meaningful to her.
Gabe (posthumous): Through Julia’s memories, he emerges as a precocious, earnest artist who defied gender norms by singing only women’s songs, yet also as someone capable of disappearing after an intimate mistake.
Elizabeth: Only seen briefly, but her sharp “I know exactly who you were to Gabe” introduces a mystery about what Gabe might have told others about Julia.
Casey & Will: Provide immediate friendship support; Will’s therapist-in-training honesty draws out Julia’s secret, while Casey remains unaware.
Kathy Liu: Manager and story-teller; her anecdote about Gabe detouring to Austin now feels hollow to Julia, underlining how memories are being reevaluated.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Grief and Unresolved Tension: The chapter contrasts the public ritual of mourning with Julia’s private fury. Her mental “you fucking jerk” shows grief can coexist with resentment when the dead leave loose ends.
Friendship vs. Romantic Entanglement: Julia insists she and Gabe were real friends, not a rom-com trope, yet their one-night stand wrecked that friendship. The chapter questions whether cross-gender platonic bonds can survive physical intimacy.
The Performance of Grief: The eulogy itself is a performance Julia gives while feeling disconnected from her words. The funeral becomes another kind of stage, echoing Gabe’s own musical performances.
Objects as Clues: The garnet ring Elizabeth wears—spotted earlier in Gabe’s selfies—functions like a narrative puzzle piece. The tampon exchange becomes an intimate gesture between two women connected by the same dead man.
Architecture as Connection: Gaudí’s designs (Parc Güell’s dragon, La Sagrada Família) symbolize the organic, unusual friendship Julia and Gabe built. Their meandering walk mirrors the structure of memory.
First-Meet Narrative: The flashback establishes the foundation of their bond—music, humor, shared values—so that the present-day loss cuts deeper.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter One establishes the novel’s central emotional paradox: Julia must mourn someone she is also furious with, all while guarding a secret that could alter everyone’s perception of Gabe. The dual timeline immediately tells the reader that the past will intrude on the present, and the bathroom confrontation with Elizabeth plants a seed of distrust—what else did Gabe hide? By ending at the burial with Julia’s silent rage, the chapter hooks us into her need to untangle what Gabe really meant to her, setting up a journey of memory reconsideration.

Study Questions and Answers

Why does Julia’s eulogy feel like a performance to her? Because she is consciously avoiding the truth—that she and Gabe slept together and he then ignored her. She selects safe, anecdotal memories to fit the occasion, creating a disconnect between her outward composure and her inner turmoil.
How does the flashback to Barcelona shape our understanding of Julia and Gabe’s relationship? It shows that their bond was instantaneous and deeply personal. Gabe’s singing moved Julia before she knew him, and their conversation revealed mutual passions. This history makes his later silence and death more devastating, explaining why Julia can’t simply mourn him as a perfect friend.
What is the significance of Elizabeth’s line, “I know exactly who you were to Gabe”? It implies Elizabeth possesses knowledge that contradicts Julia’s own perception. Because the statement is delivered with hostility, it suggests that Gabe may have described Julia in a jealous or negative light to Elizabeth, complicating Julia’s belief in their friendship’s purity.

← Book Hub | Next Chapter →