Chapter summaries Last Night at the Telegraph Club Malinda Lo

Chapter 20: Lily's First Night at the Telegraph Club

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Lily and Kath arrive at the Telegraph Club. Lily is surprised by the smaller-than-expected white neon sign and the black door under a circular awning. The bouncer is a woman in a suit, whom Lily initially mistakes for a short stocky man. Kath confidently tells the bouncer that they are in the right place, and the bouncer lets them in with a grin.

Inside, the club is narrow, dim, and smells of booze, perfume, sweat, and cigarette smoke. Lily follows Kath down the side of the room past a mirrored bar where women turn to look at them. The space opens into a wider room with a tiny stage, a spotlight, and a microphone. A woman pianist in a boxy suit begins to play. The audience hushes. Lily trembles with anticipation.

A murmur announces the arrival of the performer, Tommy Andrews. Tommy steps onto the stage, back facing the crowd, and begins to sing “Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered” in a low, husky voice. The audience gasps at the perfect male impersonation. Lily is transfixed by Tommy’s swagger, the sheen of pomade, the precise bow tie, the gold signet ring. Tommy’s physicality feels unspeakably charged to Lily, as if her secret desires are exposed.

When Tommy spins around, the audience erupts in applause. Lily watches the rest of the performance, feeling the heat and intimacy of the packed room. She becomes overwhelmed and looks away, examining the audience: some men with wives, a mix of reactions, many women dressed in masculine clothing. Lily notices she is the only Chinese girl in the room. She presses herself against the wall to feel safer.

Tommy performs another song, stepping off the stage to flirt with women at tables. Lily is both drawn and alarmed; the fantasy figure has become flesh-and-blood reality. The chapter ends with Lily realizing that the real Tommy frightens her most of all.

Key Events

  • Lily and Kath arrive at the Telegraph Club; the neon sign is smaller than Lily expected.
  • The bouncer is a woman in a suit; Kath uses her previous visit to gain entry.
  • Inside, Lily absorbs the sensory details: smell, mirrored bar, women’s gazes.
  • Tommy Andrews performs “Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered” in a stunning male impersonation.
  • Lily feels a powerful, unsettling attraction to Tommy’s physicality and swagger.
  • Overwhelmed, Lily looks away and surveys the diverse audience (men, couples, women in masculine attire).
  • Lily realizes she is the only Chinese person present and hides against the wall.
  • Tommy flirts with audience members during a second song; Lily feels nervous and confused.
  • Lily confronts the gap between her imagined Tommy and the real, living performer.

Character Development

Lily Hu: Lily’s internal conflict deepens. She has long desired to see Tommy Andrews, but the actual experience triggers both ecstasy and fear. She struggles with her attraction, shame, and a longing to belong. Her observation of the audience and her own isolation highlights her growing self-awareness of her difference and her desires.

Kath Miller: Kath appears confident and experienced, smoothly handling the bouncer and leading Lily through the club. She remains attentive to Lily’s discomfort, asking if she is all right, showing care beneath her adventurous facade.

Tommy Andrews: Tommy emerges as a commanding, charismatic performer who breaks down the boundary between stage and audience. Her ease in her masculinity and her flirtatiousness challenge conventional gender roles and unsettle Lily.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Performance and Identity: Tommy’s male impersonation is a deliberate act that exposes the constructed nature of gender. Lily’s reaction shows how performance can blur the line between reality and desire.

Visibility and Invisibility: Lily is hypervisible as the only Chinese girl yet also tries to hide against the wall. The club is a space where women dressing as men are openly visible, yet Lily still fears recognition from Chinatown.

Reality vs. Fantasy: Lily’s idealized, distant image of Tommy collides with the real, sweaty, flirtatious woman. This clash forces Lily to face the tangible nature of her feelings.

Desire and Shame: Lily’s physical reaction—sweating, flushed, needing to look away—mirrors the conflict between wanting something and feeling it is shameful, especially as she interprets the smirking wife’s expression as “shameful.”

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 20 marks the long-awaited arrival at the Telegraph Club and the first live encounter with Tommy Andrews. It transforms Lily’s private fantasy into a public, embodied experience. The chapter forces Lily to acknowledge the intensity of her desires while also confronting the real social complexities of the club: the mixture of excitement and danger, the presence of other queer women, and her own racial isolation. This moment is a turning point in Lily’s journey toward self-acceptance and understanding the community she may belong to.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. How does Lily’s perception of Tommy Andrews change when she sees her perform live?
    Lily had imagined Tommy as a distant, pure, matinee-idol figure from a newspaper photo. In reality, Tommy is bold, swaggering, and flesh-and-blood—singing intimately, flirting with women, and exuding confidence. This direct encounter frightens Lily because it makes her desires feel real and undeniable.

  2. What details in the club environment affect Lily’s emotional state?
    The smell of booze, perfume, sweat, and smoke creates a sensory overload. The dim lighting, the press of bodies, and the intimacy of the packed room make Lily feel both excited and claustrophobic. Seeing other women in masculine attire and hearing the audience’s reactions reinforces that she is in a queer space, which both thrills and unsettles her.

  3. Why does Lily feel the need to hide against the wall after Tommy’s first song?
    Lily is overwhelmed by the intensity of her attraction and the realization that Tommy is real, not a fantasy. She also becomes acutely aware that she is the only Chinese girl in the room—visible and potentially vulnerable. Pressing against the wall gives her a sense of safety and distance from the stage, allowing her to process her feelings without being seen.

Navigation