Reshmina's 9/11: Chapter 36 Summary
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
⚠️ This page contains major plot details from Chapter 36 of Ground Zero. If you haven't read the chapter yet, you may want to do so first.
Summary
Reshmina wakes up on the riverbank, dazed and aching, but alive. Her mother is beside her, and Taz stands nearby, smiling. The explosion from the mine had blown a hole in the wall they hid behind, allowing everyone to escape, though Taz had to abandon his battle belt. Reshmina quickly checks on her siblings and grandmother—Zahir, Marzia, and Anaa are all safe, and American and Afghan soldiers are treating the wounded.
Her father, Baba, soon appears with other villagers who had been trapped in a cave. The cave-in had only separated the groups, not killed everyone. Baba tells Reshmina that a few died, but many survived, and he credits her bravery. Reshmina, however, is consumed by guilt, believing she led everyone to their deaths. Baba comforts her, and she reveals that Pasoon has joined the Taliban. Baba admits he feared this might happen.
As the Americans clear the village, Taz is joined by three soldiers, including Carter, who wears a tattoo reading “INFIDEL.” Carter and Taz exchange remarks about the day being significant. Reshmina asks what they mean, and Taz explains that it is September 11—the anniversary of the 2001 attacks on the World Trade Center. He shows her a magazine photo of the Twin Towers with smoke pouring from them, but neither Reshmina nor her family recognizes the image. Taz then shows a photo of himself as a boy with his father, Leo Chavez, who died in the North Tower. Taz reveals his adopted name, Brandon Lowery, taken in honor of the man who helped him escape.
Reshmina translates the story for her family, and Anaa recognizes it as badal—revenge. Reshmina confronts Taz, pointing out that the attackers were from al Qaeda, not the Taliban, and that the United States has killed far more Afghans in retaliation. She asks why the Americans are still there, especially since Osama bin Laden was killed nearly ten years ago. Carter responds with “If you’re not with us, you’re against us,” and Reshmina bitterly notes that the rules are different for the United States.
Suddenly, Carter receives a radio call about insurgents in a house at the top of the village. He calls in an airstrike. An Apache helicopter fires a missile, but the blast triggers a catastrophic landslide that collapses the entire village, burying everything in dust and rubble. Carter mutters, “Bombed ’em back up to the Stone Age,” and adds, “That’s for 9/11.” Taz apologizes, horrified, but Reshmina can only watch as her home—and her entire world—disappears.
Key Events
-
Reshmina wakes up by the river and reunites with her mother, Taz, and other survivors.
-
Baba returns with villagers who had been trapped in a cave, and Reshmina learns Pasoon joined the Taliban.
-
Taz explains that the date is September 11, the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks, and shows photos of the Twin Towers and his late father.
-
Taz reveals his adopted name, Brandon Lowery, and explains that al Qaeda, not the Taliban, carried out the attacks, but the U.S. invaded because the Taliban harbored bin Laden.
-
Reshmina challenges the American presence and the double standard of retaliation.
-
Carter calls in an airstrike on a house with insurgents, but the missile triggers a landslide that destroys the entire village.
-
Carter remarks that the strike was “for 9/11,” and Taz apologizes as Reshmina watches her home collapse.
Character Development
Reshmina grows from a curious, sheltered girl into a sharp critic of the war. Her confrontation with Taz shows her ability to see the larger political picture, even as she struggles with personal guilt. She questions the morality of revenge and the unequal rules between nations, and her final collapse on her knees underscores her emotional breaking point.
Taz is humanized through his backstory. He is not just a soldier but a survivor of 9/11 who lost his father. His discomfort when Reshmina challenges him reveals his internal conflict—he knows the war has caused immense suffering, yet he cannot fully justify it. His apology at the end shows his regret, but also his helplessness.
Carter embodies the blunt, unreflective side of the American military. His “INFIDEL” tattoo, his casual dismissal of Afghan lives, and his “that’s for 9/11” comment highlight a mindset that sees the war as simple revenge. He represents the cultural arrogance that Reshmina calls out.
Baba shows resilience and acceptance. He does not blame Reshmina for Pasoon’s choice, and his comfort reflects the strength of family bonds in the face of tragedy.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
-
Badal and the Cycle of Violence: Anaa immediately recognizes the American invasion as badal, the Pashtun code of revenge. Reshmina points out that the U.S. is seeking revenge against the wrong people, and the chapter shows how violence only begets more violence.
-
Cultural Misunderstanding: Reshmina and her family have never heard of 9/11, while Taz and Carter cannot fathom that. The photo of the Twin Towers is a symbol of American trauma that is meaningless to Afghans, highlighting the vast gap in perspective.
-
The Apache Helicopter as a Symbol: Reshmina reflects that the helicopter is named after a defeated tribe, and suggests the next one should be called “Afghan.” This symbolizes how the U.S. treats Afghanistan as another conquest, erasing its people’s humanity.
-
The Shrine to Failed Conquerors: Reshmina’s earlier thought about the battle belt being “one more artifact for the shrine to failed conquerors” recurs implicitly, suggesting that the American presence will eventually be seen as another failed invasion.
-
The “With Us or Against Us” Mentality: Carter’s line encapsulates the binary thinking that forces Afghans into impossible choices and justifies indiscriminate violence.
-
Collateral Damage and the Loss of Home: The landslide that destroys the village is a literal and symbolic erasure of Afghan life, showing how a single “surgical” strike can wipe out an entire community.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter is a turning point in the novel, bringing the two timelines together thematically. It forces the reader to confront the human cost of the War on Terror, not just in abstract terms but through the destruction of Reshmina’s entire world. The revelation of Taz’s personal connection to 9/11 adds depth to his character, while Reshmina’s pointed questions challenge the justification for the invasion. The chapter also sets up the emotional climax of her story, as she loses everything she has ever known. It underscores the novel’s central message about the futility of revenge and the importance of understanding across cultures.
Study Questions and Answers
1. Why does Reshmina argue that the American invasion is an act of badal?
Reshmina explains to Taz that the attacks on 9/11 were carried out by al Qaeda, not the Taliban, and that the U.S. invaded Afghanistan because the Taliban harbored bin Laden. She points out that the U.S. has killed far more Afghan civilians than the 3,000 who died in the attacks, and that seeking revenge against an entire country for the actions of a few is exactly the kind of cycle of violence that badal perpetuates.
2. How does Taz’s backstory complicate his role as a soldier?
Taz is not a detached warrior; he is a survivor of 9/11 who lost his father. His personal trauma explains his presence in Afghanistan, but it also makes him more sympathetic to Reshmina’s arguments. He cannot meet her eyes when she challenges the double standard, and his apology after the village is destroyed shows that he recognizes the injustice, even if he cannot change it.
3. What does the destruction of the village symbolize in the context of the novel?
The landslide that buries the village represents the indiscriminate nature of modern warfare, where a single missile can erase an entire community. It also symbolizes the erasure of Afghan culture and history by American military action, echoing Reshmina’s earlier thought about the “shrine to failed conquerors.” The village’s destruction is the ultimate consequence of the cycle of violence and cultural misunderstanding that the chapter explores.
Navigation
-
Next Chapter: Chapter 37 Summary