Chapter summaries With a Vengeance Riley Sager

Chapter 34: Anna's Shocking Discovery About Judd's Death

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Anna, alone with Reggie in her room after Seamus leaves to calm the other passengers, insists the killer is framing her. She draws parallels to how her father was framed years ago. Reggie is skeptical, and his body language suggests he thinks Anna might be guilty. He urges her to stay in her room until Chicago to avoid a mutiny.

Anna reflects on the three murders: Judd (poisoned), Edith (suffocated but staged as strangulation), and Herb (throat slit). Each was designed to implicate her. She suspects Jack Lapsford but acknowledges he lacks the physical ability to climb out of windows or move between cars externally. The conversation shifts to Judd's death. Anna realizes Judd never took a sip of his poisoned martini. She reconstructs the moments in the lounge: Dante poured four martinis from the same shaker; the others chose glasses; Lapsford brushed Judd's arm, but before Judd held his drink; no one got close to Judd while he held the glass. The poison must have been self-administered or Judd faked his death.

Anna gasps at the implication: Judd might be alive and the killer. She rushes to his room, followed by Reggie and a confused Seamus. When they enter, the bed is empty—Judd is gone.

Key Events

  • Anna explains her framing theory to Reggie, who appears unconvinced.
  • Reggie advises Anna to stay in her room to prevent passenger unrest.
  • Anna recalls Judd's death in detail and realizes he never drank the martini.
  • She deduces Judd likely faked his death and is the real killer.
  • Anna, Reggie, and Seamus go to Judd's room and find the bed empty.

Character Development

  • Anna: Demonstrates sharp observation by reconstructing the lounge scene. Her isolation from childhood surfaces, but now she refuses to be passive. She acts decisively, risking confrontation.
  • Reggie: Doubts Anna's innocence despite helping her. His concern for group dynamics outweighs personal trust, showing he is practical but conflicted.
  • Seamus: Reveals he lacks medical knowledge (didn't check Judd's pulse correctly), undermining his earlier authority. His confusion highlights his amateur status.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Framing: The killer's pattern mirrors how Anna's father was framed. Each murder is staged to point at Anna.
  • Deception: Judd's apparent ressurrection—the ultimate trick. The chapter challenges what is seen versus what is true.
  • Memory: Anna treats her recollection like a movie, scanning for overlooked details. The motif of “missing” details (the sip that never happened) drives the plot.
  • Isolation: Anna's childhood solitude taunts her; now solitude feels unsafe because the killer moves freely.
  • Guilt by Association: Reggie's suspicion and the passengers' potential "mutiny" show how quickly suspicion spreads.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter overturns the central assumption that Judd was a victim. His disappearance reframes the entire mystery: the killer may have been among them from the start, playing dead. Anna's shift from suspect to active investigator energizes the narrative. The revelation that Judd never drank the poison explains the contaminated glass without a poisoner, setting up a direct confrontation.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Question: Why does Anna initially believe Jack Lapsford is framing her, and what evidence suggests otherwise?
    Answer: Anna thinks Lapsford wants to eliminate those who could implicate him while making her look guilty. However, Reggie points out Lapsford's age and infirmity would prevent him from climbing out the train window onto the roof, casting doubt on that theory.

  2. Question: What detail does Anna recall from the lounge scene that leads her to suspect Judd faked his death?
    Answer: She remembers that Judd never took a single sip of the martini he carried. The poison was found in his glass, but no one could have added it while he held it, meaning Judd must have put it there himself—or not drunk it at all.

  3. Question: How does Reggie's attitude toward Anna change during this chapter, and what does it reveal about his character?
    Answer: Reggie begins to treat Anna as a potential threat, advising her to stay in her room to prevent a mutiny. This shows his priority is crowd management over personal loyalty, and he is not fully convinced of her innocence despite his help.

Navigation