Chapter summaries We Solve Murders Richard Osman

Chapter 43 Summary: Max Highfield’s Visit to The Wilberforce

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Max Highfield arrives at The Wilberforce, a London private members’ club just off Pall Mall, to meet Henk van Veen in the library. At the reception desk, a porter in a bowler hat stops him because of his trainers. Max initially expects his celebrity to grant him entry, but the porter politely enforces the club’s dress code. After a brief negotiation, Max borrows a pair of size ten brown brogues, though his feet are size six and the shoes are too big. He asks for assurance he will not be photographed, and the porter confirms that inside the club oil paintings are more common than photographs. Max reflects on how he handled the situation with calm, crediting his therapy sessions with Melanie—an older woman, but someone he respects. Therapy is teaching him to control his temper, though he still prioritises box-office numbers over deeper self-examination. Inside, Max thinks about the death threat slipped under his dressing-room door—“You will die, Highfield.” He also notes that Jeff Nolan has stopped returning his calls, so Henk van Veen is the next best option for help. Max lives by one rule: keep moving forward, never look back. His therapist questioned whether that rule is healthy, but Max defends it, arguing that you do not remake old movies—you make sequels or even prequels, which, he points out, can go both forward and backward at the same time. He follows the porter to the library, his borrowed shoes slapping uncomfortably.

Key Events

  • Max Highfield arrives at The Wilberforce club to meet Henk van Veen.
  • The porter denies Max entry due to his trainers; Max borrows ill-fitting brown brogues.
  • Max shares that he has received a death threat and that Jeff Nolan is no longer answering calls.
  • Max reflects on his therapy sessions and his “forward moving” philosophy.
  • He walks to the library, physically uncomfortable in the borrowed shoes.

Character Development

Max Highfield shows noticeable growth from his portrayal in earlier chapters: he does not lose his temper when confronted by the porter, instead reasoning and accepting the compromise. He credits his therapy with this change. Yet his entitlement remains—he expects special treatment because of his fame, and he dismisses his therapist’s insights when they conflict with his career ambitions. The death threat deepens his vulnerability, making him more than a brash action star.

The Porter serves as a foil to Max: polite, firm, and unimpressed by celebrity. His calm enforcement of rules underscores the theme of privilege and the limits of fame.

Henk van Veen is not physically present in the scene, but his name carries weight within the club, suggesting he holds significant influence that Max hopes to leverage.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Celebrity and Privilege: Max believes his fame should override club rules, but the porter treats him like any other member. The borrowed shoes symbolise the discomfort of playing by others’ rules.
  • Forward vs Backward Movement: Max’s mantra “keep moving forward and never look back” is questioned by his therapist and undercut by the mention of a prequel. The chapter suggests that growth sometimes requires revisiting the past.
  • Therapy and Self-Awareness: Max attends therapy and recognises his improvements, yet he refuses to apply its lessons to his ambition. The tension between self-help and ego is central.
  • Violence and Threat: The death threat note injects genuine danger into Max’s seemingly glamorous life, reminding readers that the murder plot is ongoing.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter deepens Max Highfield’s character, moving him from a comic action star to a more complex figure who is both vulnerable and self-aware. It establishes Henk van Veen as a key contact in Max’s search for protection, setting up future alliances. The death threat raises the stakes and connects Max’s personal story to the larger mystery of who is targeting the people around him. The therapy subtext adds nuance to his decision-making, showing that his forward-moving rule may be a coping mechanism rather than a virtue.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Max choose to see Henk van Veen instead of anyone else?
Max has been trying to reach Jeff Nolan, but Nolan has stopped returning his calls. Henk van Veen is the next best option because he can provide similar services, and Max believes he can also bring Henk other clients, making it a mutually beneficial deal.

2. How does Max’s interaction with the porter illustrate his character development?
Max initially expects his fame to let him bypass the dress code, but he does not explode in anger. Instead, he reasons with the porter and accepts the loan of shoes. This shows the positive effect of his therapy, though his request not to be photographed and his complaint about the brown shoes reveal that his sense of entitlement remains intact.

3. What is the significance of Max’s “forward-moving” philosophy, and why does his therapist question it?
Max lives by the rule “keep moving forward and never look back,” which he applies to his career—always making the next, bigger film. His therapist, Melanie, asks whether this approach is healthy for himself and the people around him. Max defends it but inadvertently undercuts his own argument by noting that Rampage 8 is a prequel, meaning it goes backward even as the franchise moves forward. The therapist’s skepticism suggests that true growth may require facing past mistakes rather than simply ignoring them.

Navigation