Chapter summaries Upside Down Danielle Steel

Chapter 12: Doubts and Delays

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

After returning from Paris, Ben and Morgan return to their separate apartments. Ben meets with his attorney, Stan Silver, who explains Tracy McCarthy’s extortion strategy: she wants a lump sum and child support if the baby is his, or a settlement paid to avoid a rape accusation if the baby is not. Stan calls Tracy a “flat-out crook” and warns Ben that the network may fire him over a scandal.

Morgan arranges a DNA test through her med‑school friend Perry Blackstone. When Perry tries to draw Tracy’s blood, he discovers she is two weeks less pregnant than claimed — the conception date falls after Morgan and Ben began dating. Morgan realizes this means either Tracy became pregnant by someone else later (exonerating Ben) or Ben had sex with Tracy after meeting Morgan (making him a liar). She does not share the date with Ben.

Morgan avoids Ben that evening, feigning a headache. She confides in her mother Ardith, who listens without judgment and offers support. Ardith later tells her partner Josh about the situation. Morgan and Ben exchange loving texts before bed, but Morgan’s trust is severely shaken. The chapter ends with Morgan unsure whether Ben is a cheater who made a terrible mistake or a good man caught by a greedy woman.

Key Events

  1. Ben meets with Stan Silver — Stan explains Tracy’s extortion demands and the risk of losing Ben’s job.
  2. DNA test postponed — Perry Blackstone reveals Tracy is not eight weeks pregnant; the conception is two weeks later than stated.
  3. Morgan calculates the conception date — She compares it with her calendar and realizes it falls after she and Ben became intimate.
  4. Morgan avoids Ben — She claims a headache, does not answer his calls, and sends only a brief text.
  5. Phone call with Ardith — Morgan tells her mother about Ben, Tracy, and her trust issues. Ardith reacts supportively.
  6. Ardith updates Josh — She explains Ben’s predicament but does not yet reveal her own relationship to Morgan.
  7. Late‑night texts — Ben and Morgan exchange “I love you” messages, though uncertainty lingers.

Character Development

  • Morgan — Her trust in Ben erodes as she connects the conception date to his timeline. She begins to question the “once a cheater, always a cheater” maxim. She also opens up to her mother for the first time in years, showing emotional growth.
  • Ben — He remains unaware of Morgan’s new knowledge. He is desperate and apologetic, but his credibility suffers in Morgan’s eyes.
  • Stan Silver — Sharp, pragmatic, and protective of Ben; he sees Tracy as a “two‑bit crook” and advises a cautious legal approach.
  • Ardith — Supportive and non‑judgmental, she offers Morgan a safe space. Her own relationship with Josh makes her sympathetic to age‑gap couples.
  • Perry Blackstone — He provides key medical information while emphasizing HIPAA confidentiality, though he bends it for Morgan.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Trust and Betrayal — The central conflict. Morgan must decide whether Ben’s timeline is honest or whether he cheated.
  • Extortion and Power — Tracy uses pregnancy and the threat of a #MeToo accusation to control Ben and extract money.
  • Time and Timelines — The conception date becomes a symbol of uncertainty; “two weeks” shifts Morgan’s perception entirely.
  • Mother‑Daughter Reconciliation — Morgan’s call with Ardith represents a thaw in their strained relationship, a minor sub‑theme of healing.
  • The Past Repeating — Amanda’s description of Ben as a “cheater” echoes Ardith’s earlier warning about Morgan’s father, reinforcing the idea that old patterns may hold.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 12 is a turning point for the central romance. Until now, Morgan believed Ben’s story that he slept with Tracy before meeting her. The medical discovery introduces irrefutable evidence that the timing is off, forcing Morgan to confront the possibility that Ben lied. The chapter also deepens the connection between Morgan and Ardith, setting the stage for future family revelations (e.g., Ardith’s relationship with Josh). The legal subplot intensifies, and the uncertainty about the DNA result keeps both characters and readers in suspense.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why is the DNA test postponed, and what information does Morgan learn from Perry?

The test is postponed because Tracy is not eight weeks pregnant as she claimed; she is only about six weeks along, meaning the conception date is two weeks later than originally believed. Perry gives Morgan that date, which she compares with her calendar and discovers it falls after she and Ben began dating.

2. How does Morgan’s conversation with her mother differ from their earlier interactions?

Earlier, Morgan kept her mother at a distance and rarely shared personal details. In this chapter, she voluntarily tells Ardith about Ben, the paternity suit, and her trust dilemma. Ardith listens without criticizing Ben’s age or the situation, and Morgan appreciates the support. This marks a shift toward mutual respect and openness.

3. What does Stan Silver mean when he says, “You lie down with dogs, you get fleas”?

Stan uses the proverb to warn Ben that his indiscriminate sexual choices have led to consequences. By sleeping with someone like Tracy — whom Stan calls a “crook” — Ben has entangled himself in an extortion scheme that will cost him heavily, regardless of whether the baby is his or not.

Navigation