Chapter summaries Tom Clancy Defense Protocol Brian Andrews and Jeffrey Wilson

Chapter 62 (Chapter 60) Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Captain Shen, still nursing a cracked rib from tackling Colonel Sun, sits in combat control central aboard the Type 055 destroyer Nanchang, which trails the USS Jason Dunham in the Strait of Taiwan. Pain and anxiety over imprisoning his political commissar make him restless. The officer of the watch brings tea and painkillers. Suddenly, the combat coordinator announces two supersonic anti-ship missile launches from Huayu Island, bearing toward either the Nanchang or the Jason Dunham. The Dragon’s Eye radar tracks the inbound Hsiung Feng III missiles. The American destroyer hails via bridge-to-bridge radio, and Captain Kreutz declares his intention to shoot down the missiles with SM-6 surface-to-air missiles, stressing it is defensive action, not an attack on the Nanchang. Kwok translates the message.

Shen, after reflecting, tells Kwok to reply that the Nanchang does not need help and will handle the threats itself. He orders his combat coordinator to ready a defensive salvo. Before Kwok can finish relaying the refusal, the Jason Dunham launches two SM-6s on intercept course. Shen acknowledges the American captain’s quick thinking with a grim smile and tells his coordinator to hold fire. The XO, Commander Tan, questions the Americans’ motives, suggesting they might intentionally miss to leave the Nanchang vulnerable. Shen dismisses the idea because the SM-6 uses active-radar homing; there would be time to launch a counter salvo if the intercept fails. Instead, Shen theorizes a false-flag operation: Taiwan and the U.S. might have staged the missile launch so the Jason Dunham can take credit for saving the Nanchang, painting China as the aggressor. He decides to do nothing, conserving missiles for future orders. Just then, Lieutenant Kwok receives flash traffic from Southern Theater Command. Shen reads the new orders and realizes that carrying them out will guarantee war.

Key Events

  • Captain Shen’s cracked rib causes physical and emotional strain.
  • Two Hsiung Feng III anti-ship missiles are launched from Taiwan, targeting the Nanchang or the Jason Dunham.
  • The USS Jason Dunham radios that it will shoot the missiles down.
  • Shen initially refuses help, preparing his own counter salvo.
  • The Jason Dunham launches two SM-6s before Shen can act; he holds fire.
  • XO Tan suspects a trick; Shen concludes it might be a false flag operation.
  • New flash orders from Southern Theater Command arrive, and Shen fears they will spark war.

Character Development

  • Captain Shen: His physical pain mirrors the moral and command pain he feels after imprisoning Colonel Sun. Despite injury and stress, he remains analytical. His suspicion of American motives shows a shift toward seeing the situation as a grand deception rather than a simple accident. The final orders force him to confront the possibility that he is being used to start a war.
  • Commander Tan: The XO offers a skeptical alternative reading of events, demonstrating a loyal officer willing to challenge his captain. His suspicion validates Shen’s eventual conclusion about the false flag.
  • Captain Kreutz (offstage): His proactive, respectful hail and immediate launch of SM-6s demonstrate competence and de-escalation tactics, but also prompt Shen’s distrust.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • False Flag Operations: The chapter explores how nations can orchestrate events to frame adversaries. Shen’s theory that the missile launch is staged by the U.S. and Taiwan echoes real-world concerns about provocation.
  • Pain and Authority: Shen’s broken rib symbolizes the fractured command structure on the Nanchang. His physical discomfort clouds his judgment and foreshadows the painful decisions ahead.
  • Escalation by Inaction: Choosing to do nothing (holding fire) is an active choice that may have unintended consequences. Shen wants to conserve missiles, but the new orders force him to act.
  • Technology and Trust: The SM-6’s active-radar homing is cited as a counterargument to deception, yet Shen still distrusts American motives. Radar reliability does not erase political doubt.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter raises the stakes dramatically. Missiles have been fired, and the Jason Dunham has engaged. The carefully managed “warning shot” from earlier chapters now looks like a trigger for real combat. Shen’s refusal to shoot down the missiles himself and his theory of a false flag suggest that the crisis may be manufactured. The final lines—new orders that guarantee war—set up the novel’s climax. Readers understand that the next chapter will force Shen to choose between following orders and preventing catastrophe.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Captain Shen decide to hold fire after the Jason Dunham launches its SM-6s?
    He reasons that the Americans have already taken the lead, so he can conserve his own missiles for future orders. He also suspects the missile launch may be a false-flag operation, making it strategically wiser to let the U.S. destroyer take the credit (or blame) for the intercept.

  2. What does XO Tan suggest, and why does Shen dismiss that concern?
    Tan worries the SM-6s might intentionally miss, leaving the Nanchang vulnerable. Shen dismisses it because the SM-6’s active-radar seeker would make such a failure unlikely, and even if it missed, the Nanchang would still have time to launch its own counter salvo.

  3. What is the likely content of the “flash traffic” orders from Southern Theater Command?
    Although not explicitly stated, the orders almost certainly require the Nanchang to take aggressive action against the U.S. or Taiwan forces. Shen’s reaction—a lump in his throat and the thought “If I do this, it guarantees war”—confirms the orders are a major escalation.

Navigation