Chapter summaries Think Twice Harlan Coben

Think Twice Chapter 22: Myron Confronts the Past at the Cemetery

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Myron Bolitar arrives at a cemetery overlooking a schoolyard, summoned by Ben Staples, the ex-husband of murder victim Cecelia Callister. Before meeting Ben, Myron is drawn to the grave of Brenda Slaughter, a woman from his past whose tragic death still haunts him. He reflects on the emotional breakdown that followed her murder and the brief relationship with Terese Collins, now his wife, that emerged from that pain.

Ben Staples stands before two mounds of dirt—Cecelia and her son Clay’s final resting places. He explains that he still loved Cecelia and brings succulents instead of flowers because she thought flowers died too soon. Myron asks if Ben thinks Greg Downing killed Cecelia. Ben instead points to Lou Himble, Cecelia’s estranged husband, who ran a Ponzi scheme and faced her testimony. Ben also reveals that Clay was not his biological son—Cecelia confessed the pregnancy was from another man. Clay later discovered his father through genealogy databases, but Ben does not know if he ever made contact.

When Myron asks about Cecelia’s behavior before the divorce, Ben recalls she was moody, withdrawn, and possibly taking pills. Myron then reveals that Cecelia confided in Emily Downing that she had been raped. Ben is devastated. He identifies the rapist as Howard Mostring, a Broadway producer who died by suicide after multiple sexual-assault accusations, landing on a bystander and killing her as well. Ben believes Mostring cannot be connected to the murder because he is dead. He struggles to understand how Greg Downing ends up taking the blame.

Key Events

  • Myron visits Brenda Slaughter’s grave and is overwhelmed by grief.
  • Ben Staples explains that Cecelia and Clay are buried side by side and that the temporary name placards were stolen.
  • Ben reveals that Lou Himble, Cecelia’s husband, is a suspect because she was about to testify against him.
  • Ben shares that Clay was not his son; Cecelia confessed the pregnancy from another man.
  • Clay used genealogy databases to discover his biological father, but Ben is unsure if he made contact.
  • Myron discloses to Ben that Cecelia told Emily Downing she was raped.
  • Ben identifies the rapist as Howard Mostring, a now-dead Broadway producer.
  • The chapter ends with Ben questioning how Greg Downing is implicated in the murders.

Character Development

  • Myron Bolitar: He displays vulnerability as he confronts Brenda Slaughter’s grave, acknowledging the lasting trauma and his complicated path to marrying Terese. He handles Ben’s emotions with care and presses for information without cruelty.
  • Ben Staples: Initially stoic, Ben reveals deep pain through his story of betrayal, his enduring love for Cecelia, and his devastation upon learning she had been raped. He transforms from a passive mourner to a source of critical information, though he remains conflicted about sharing the rape secret.
  • Cecelia Callister (discussed): Her past is fleshed out—she was depressed before the divorce, was a victim of sexual assault, and carried the burden of Clay’s paternity. Her decision to testify against Lou Himble adds a strong motive for her murder.
  • Howard Mostring (referenced): Though dead, he is defined as a predatory figure whose suicide left a final victim and cut off a direct link to the assault.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • The Past Returning: The cemetery setting forces Myron and Ben to confront unresolved grief: Myron with Brenda, Ben with Cecelia. The missing grave placards symbolize how memories and names can be stolen or obscured.
  • Guilt and Regret: Myron admits he would trade his marriage to save Brenda, yet recognizes that people are defined by their mistakes. Ben’s guilt over not recognizing Cecelia’s distress mirrors Myron’s own.
  • Secrecy and Shame: Cecelia hid her rape and her son’s paternity, illustrating how victims often suffer in silence. The revelation recontextualizes her earlier depression and withdrawal.
  • Predators and Justice: Howard Mostring’s suicide after numerous accusations critiques a system that failed to hold him accountable and caused further tragedy.
  • Blame and Misplaced Suspicion: Ben initially suspects Lou Himble, but the rape revelation introduces a more intimate violence. The chapter ends with the question of how Greg Downing fits—suggesting the truth may be more layered.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter deepens the mystery by providing an alternate suspect in Lou Himble and a powerful motive—silencing a key witness. More significantly, it recasts Cecelia’s life through the lens of trauma, making her murder feel even more tragic. Myron’s personal connection to Brenda Slaughter recalls his own history with loss, adding emotional weight to his determination. The revelation of Howard Mostring introduces a possible link between the rape and the current case, even though he is dead, and leaves open the question of whether someone else—perhaps Greg Downing—is covering for another. Ben’s closing line sets up the next chapter’s tension: why does Greg appear to be taking the fall?

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Why does Myron visit Brenda Slaughter’s grave before meeting Ben? Myron is drawn to the grave because the cemetery is the same one where Brenda is buried. He has never fully processed her death and the subsequent emotional breakdown, which led to his marriage to Terese. The visit reopens old wounds and grounds the investigation in Myron’s personal history of loss.

  2. What new information does Ben Staples reveal about Cecelia’s past, and how does it change the focus of the investigation? Ben reveals that Cecelia was raped by Broadway producer Howard Mostring, a secret she kept even from him. This disclosure shifts the potential motive from Greg Downing’s envy to a possible connection between the rape and the murders. Because Mostring is dead, it raises questions about whether someone else is involved or whether the rape is a red herring.

  3. How does the chapter use the setting of the cemetery to reinforce its themes? The cemetery symbolizes confrontation with death, unresolved grief, and the lingering presence of the past. Myron’s involuntary visit to Brenda’s grave shows how trauma can resurface unpredictably. Ben standing before the empty dirt mounds with stolen name placards underscores the fragility of memory and the way justice can be delayed or denied.

Navigation