Chapter 135 (137) Summary and Analysis: Strike Meets Amelia Crichton
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
A week after visiting the Edensors, Strike agrees to meet Charlotte’s sister, Amelia Crichton, at her Belgravia fabric shop. He dresses in a sober suit out of respect for the dead and the bereaved, though he expects no personal resolution. Amelia leads him to a nearby restaurant. Once seated, she reveals that Charlotte left a multi‑page suicide note. Amelia, after reflection, burned the letter instead of delivering it to Strike. She offers to summarise Charlotte’s words. Strike correctly guesses the contents: Charlotte claimed that if he had answered her calls, everything would have been different; she accused him of starting an affair with Robin days after leaving her; she dismissed Robin as biddable and unchallenging; and she insisted that Strike would eventually regret losing Charlotte. Amelia confirms the note blamed everyone, including a single line about her children. Strike tells Amelia she did the right thing, arguing that Charlotte was drunk and high when she wrote it and that the duty is to the living. Strike shares his view that Charlotte nurtured a “cult of her own unhappiness.” They make forced small talk about London life and politics, eat quickly, and part with an air kiss. Strike walks away, his eyes stinging—he attributes the sensation to the sun breaking through clouds.
Key Events
- Strike meets Amelia Crichton a week after the Edensor visit.
- Amelia reveals she burned Charlotte’s suicide note instead of delivering it.
- Strike correctly predicts the note’s accusations: blame for not answering calls, a false affair with Robin, and claims about his preference for biddable women.
- Amelia admits the letter also blamed everyone and contained a troubling instruction about her children.
- Strike argues Charlotte was under the influence and that Amelia owes a duty to the living.
- Strike and Amelia share a stilted lunch, making conversation on impersonal topics.
- They part with a formal air kiss; Strike’s eyes sting from the sun.
Character Development
- Cormoran Strike: Demonstrates a mature sense of duty by meeting Amelia despite dreading it. He refuses to engage with Charlotte’s posthumous accusations, showing growth and emotional distance. His reflection on Charlotte’s cult of unhappiness reveals his understanding of her psychology and his own hard‑won perspective on happiness as a choice.
- Amelia Crichton: Initially presented as acerbic and patrician, she shows vulnerability and moral conflict over the letter. Her decision to burn the note prioritises her niece and nephew’s wellbeing over Charlotte’s final wishes. She softens toward Strike, acknowledging his professional success and thanking him.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
- Cult of unhappiness: Strike explicitly diagnoses Charlotte’s embrace of her own misery, comparing it to a cult that becomes impossible to leave. This theme echoes the UHC’s ideological control over members, linking personal and institutional manipulation.
- Closure without resolution: The chapter rejects the idea that a final letter or meeting brings neat closure. Strike gains no new insight; instead, he confirms what he already knows. Amelia’s burning of the note symbolizes choosing the living over the dead.
- Duty to the living: Both Strike and Amelia act out of obligation to the living—Strike to the bereaved, Amelia to Charlotte’s children—rather than to the deceased’s wishes.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter provides the emotional coda to Strike’s long‑standing relationship with Charlotte. By refusing to be drawn into her final accusations, Strike demonstrates his growth and his commitment to his present life, including his partnership with Robin. Amelia’s act of burning the note underscores a major thematic concern of the novel: that surviving family members must protect the vulnerable from the destructive legacies of the dead. It also clarifies that Strike and Robin’s relationship—now public enough for Charlotte to have known—is genuine and not the simple hero‑worship Charlotte imagined.
Study Questions and Answers
-
Why does Strike agree to meet Amelia despite his reluctance?
Strike feels a sense of obligation and military‑bred respect for the dead and bereaved. He believes he owes Amelia at least the meeting, even if he expects no personal resolution from it. -
What does Strike reveal about his understanding of Charlotte’s psychology when he says she was “in love with” her own unhappiness?
He suggests that Charlotte deliberately cultivated her misery, making it a core part of her identity. This made it difficult for her to escape her destructive patterns, much like members of a cult find it hard to leave. The remark shows Strike’s psychological insight and his recognition that he could not save her. -
How does Amelia’s decision to burn the letter reflect her character development in this scene?
Initially conflicted, Amelia chooses to protect her niece and nephew from Charlotte’s hateful words, prioritising the living over the dead. This act reveals a softer, more compassionate side beneath her patrician exterior, and it earns Strike’s respect.