Chapter 69: The Bitcoin Deception Unravels

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

In Chapter 69, Davey Noakes confesses to the Thursday Murder Club that the Bitcoin he paid Holly and Nick years ago was a fraud. He had been paid in Bitcoin for amphetamine and, after agreeing to pay Holly and Nick in the same currency, simply wrote random numbers and letters on a piece of paper instead of the real key. Over the years, the value of the real Bitcoin soared to an estimated 350 million, but Davey cashed out at various peaks, amassing around 31 million for himself. He never told Holly and Nick because he gambled the cryptocurrency craze would fade. When Holly and Nick finally decided to cash out two weeks ago, Davey knew the con would be exposed. He was about to confess when Holly informed him about a car bomb, which changed the situation. Elizabeth confirms the piece of paper they recently stole from the safe is completely worthless.

Key Events

• Davey’s confession begins. Ibrahim asks what the group won’t like, and Davey admits responsibility for paying Holly and Nick in Bitcoin.
• Explanation of the original deal. Davey explains he had been paid in Bitcoin for amphetamine and thought paying Holly and Nick the same way was a harmless novelty.
• Creation of the fake Bitcoin. Davey writes random numbers and letters on a piece of paper instead of the genuine Bitcoin key, keeping the real cryptocurrency for himself.
• Growth of the con. As Bitcoin’s value rose from 20,000 to hundreds of millions, Davey continued to deceive Holly and Nick, persuading them not to cash out.
• Davey’s financial reckoning. He reveals that his own scattered assets total about 31 million pounds, far less than what he would owe Holly and Nick.
• The car bomb disrupts the confession. Davey was ready to come clean when Holly told him about the car bomb, changing the circumstances.
• The safe’s contents are worthless. Elizabeth confirms that the paper they retrieved from the safe earlier has no value.

Character Development

• Davey Noakes: Davey is forced to reveal his long-running deception. He admits vulnerability and poor judgment, calling the scam “perfectly innocent” at first but recognizing its growing weight. His confession shows a man who gambled and lost control of a lie, now facing consequences.
• Elizabeth: Elizabeth pieces together the truth quickly, asking pointed questions. She shows her sharp investigative instincts and calm demeanor even when confronted with a massive fraud.
• Ibrahim: Ibrahim prompts Davey with direct questions, maintaining his analytical approach. He also admits he “likes a gamble,” revealing a parallel risk-taking nature.
• Joyce: Joyce expresses dismay (“Oh, Davey”) but also offers a relatable aside about consolidating a pension. She grounds the conversation in everyday experience.
• Joanna: Joanna clarifies the scale of the deception by contrasting the original 20,000 with the current millions, emphasizing the emotional and financial stakes.
• Paul: Paul asks clarifying questions, helping the reader follow the complex financial explanation.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

• Deception and Trust: The central theme of the chapter is the betrayal of trust. Davey exploited Holly and Nick’s trust by providing a worthless piece of paper, and he maintained the lie for years by convincing them not to withdraw.
• Value vs. Perception: The Bitcoin’s value exists only because Holly and Nick believe it is real. Davey’s fake document symbolizes how perceived value can be manufactured. The actual Bitcoin’s worth is abstract until converted to cash.
• Consequences of Greed: Davey’s initial “why not” attitude and his continued gambling that the value would drop illustrate how greed can snowball a small deception into an enormous liability.
• The Inevitability of Exposure: Davey admits he always knew the truth would emerge; he hoped to die before it happened. This underscores the theme that secrets have a shelf life.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is a turning point in The Impossible Fortune. It reveals the fundamental secret driving the plot: the Bitcoin that Holly and Nick believe is worth a fortune is actually a forgery. The revelation shifts the stakes—neither the car bomb nor the theft were about protecting a real fortune, but about a man trying to avoid exposure for a decades-old con. It also deepens Davey’s character, showing him as more of a schemer than a victim, and creates new questions: What will Holly and Nick do when they learn the truth? How will the Thursday Murder Club use this information? The chapter tightens the narrative around deception, trust, and the gap between appearance and reality.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why did Davey decide to fake the Bitcoin instead of giving Holly and Nick the real one?
   Davey had the real Bitcoin key on a piece of paper, but he assumed the cryptocurrency was a passing fad. He thought there was no risk in writing random numbers instead, because he believed the value would never matter. He underestimated Bitcoin’s longevity and growth.

2. What prevented Davey from coming clean earlier, and why did he finally plan to confess?
   Davey kept hoping Bitcoin’s value would drop, so he wouldn’t have to pay millions. As the sum became enormous, he became trapped. Two weeks before the chapter, Holly and Nick insisted on cashing out, forcing Davey to plan a confession.

3. How does the revelation about the fake Bitcoin affect the events of the novel up to this point?
   The car bomb, the theft of the safe, and the multiple parties pursuing the Bitcoin are all based on a mistaken belief that the paper in the safe is real. The chapter reveals that the central conflict was built on a lie, which reframes earlier incidents as reactions to a phantom fortune.

Previous Chapter: Chapter 68
Next Chapter: Chapter 70
Back to Book Hub