Chapter summaries The Girl from Devil's Lake J. A. Jance

Chapter 57 (Chapter 55): Weddings and Farewells

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

The chapter opens on Saturday, December 23, 2023, in Bisbee, Arizona. Butch Dixon walks his stepdaughter, Jennifer Ann Brady, down the aisle. At the moment Reverend Marianne Maculyea asks who gives this woman, Butch becomes emotional and barely manages to reply. Jenny marries Nicholas Richard Sanders (keeping her own surname; Nick keeps his). Joanna is unsurprised, thinking that Jenny is a chip off the old block. The reception features Butch’s Mexican finger foods and a spectacular cake.

The following Sunday, Joanna tells Butch she needs to take a separate car after church. Butch correctly guesses she is going to scatter the ashes of Marliss Shackleford. Joanna drives her Interceptor to Juniper Flats, a rutted, snow-dusted road. She parks near the summit’s towers and walks to the edge of the precipice. Unscrewing the urn, she speaks aloud to Marliss, expressing regret that Marliss had a tough life and that they might have become friends if Marliss had lived longer. She pours out the ashes, and a gust of wind carries them into the canyon below. Marliss’s remains stay in southern Arizona, the place she chose to make her home.

Key Events

  • Butch Dixon walks Jenny down the aisle and becomes tearful during the ceremony.
  • Jenny and Nick exchange vows; both keep their surnames.
  • Reception at Butch’s with Mexican food and cake.
  • Joanna reveals she has a task after church.
  • Butch correctly guesses she intends to scatter Marliss’s ashes.
  • Joanna drives to Juniper Flats and scatters the ashes from the precipice.
  • A gust of wind carries the ashes into the canyon.

Character Development

Joanna Brady
Joanna shows both practicality and sentiment. She chooses a separate car to allow a private ritual. Her words to Marliss reveal a reflective side – she acknowledges Marliss’s difficult life and expresses a hypothetical future friendship. By scattering the ashes herself, Joanna demonstrates responsibility and closure, tying up a loose end from the case.

Butch Dixon
Butch’s emotional breakdown during the wedding highlights his deep love for Jenny and his role as a devoted stepfather. His immediate guess about Joanna’s plan shows their strong partnership and understanding.

Jennifer Ann Brady and Nicholas Richard Sanders
Both choose to keep their own surnames, a detail that Joanna attributes to Jenny being “a chip off the old block.” This suggests independence and equality in their marriage.

Marliss Shackleford (deceased)
Though dead, Marliss is indirectly present through the scattering ritual. Joanna’s brief address humanizes her, framing her as a person whose life was tough and who made Arizona her home.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Closure and Ritual
The wedding and ash scattering are both rituals that mark transitions. The wedding celebrates new beginnings; the scattering provides a final, respectful farewell to Marliss. Joanna performs both as a public and a private act.

Family and Chosen Kinship
Butch’s emotional role as “giving away” Jenny reinforces that family is built on love, not biology. Joanna’s solo act also underscores that she takes responsibility for those who have crossed her path.

Wind and Landscape
The gust of wind that catches the ashes symbolizes Marliss’s release into the land she loved. The austere, snowy Juniper Flats setting mirrors the quiet resolution of Marliss’s story.

Independence
Jenny keeping her name echoes Joanna’s own strong will. It also mirrors the theme of personal identity that runs through the novel.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter provides emotional resolution for both the wedding arc and the Marliss Shackleford subplot. It closes a significant character thread: Joanna’s relationship with Marliss, which had been fraught with tension, ends on a note of grace. The wedding scene also affirms the stability of the Brady-Dixon family after the upheavals of the story. By placing these two events side by side, the chapter contrasts joy with sorrow and shows that life moves forward even as we honor the past.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Butch become emotional during the wedding ceremony?
Butch has been a loving stepfather to Jenny for many years. The moment when the minister asks “Who giveth this woman?” overwhelms him because it represents the culmination of his role in her life and his deep pride in the woman she has become.

2. What does Joanna’s decision to scatter Marliss’s ashes reveal about her character?
It shows that Joanna believes in personal closure and respect for the dead, even for someone she did not particularly like. She takes the time to perform the ritual privately, and her spoken words indicate she has reflected on Marliss’s hardships.

3. Why do Jenny and Nick both keep their own surnames?
Joanna interprets this as Jenny being “a chip off the old block,” suggesting that Jenny inherits her mother’s independent streak. The choice reflects a modern, egalitarian approach to marriage where both partners retain their identities.

Navigation

< Previous Chapter: Chapter 56
Next Chapter: Chapter 58 >
Back to Book Hub