Chapter 7 (Chapter 5) Summary: The Rehearsal Dinner & An Old Promise

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Chapter 5 takes place entirely during the rehearsal dinner for Jeanie and Logan’s wedding, held in a decorated barn. Kira has arranged the tables with simple, intimate decor. Annie is seated between Iris and Bennett, deliberately far from Mac. As the evening unfolds with food, laughter, and dancing, Annie becomes acutely aware that she is the only single person in her friend group—aside from Mac. She accepts a dance with a guest who talks at length about feeding his gecko pellets, which she endures politely before escaping outside. After the crowd thins, Kira briefly questions Annie about her history with Mac, but Annie deflects. Later, when only Mac remains in the barn, Kira “forgets” to turn off all the lights, leaving twinkle lights glowing. Mac approaches Annie, and the two share a charged moment. They reminisce about a past Christmas-lights tour that Mac calls his favorite night. He tells her he still feels the same way, and they begin a slow dance. Annie allows herself a few breaths to remember the good times, then pulls away. She walks out into the cold air, reaffirming a promise she made to herself years ago: never to let Macaulay Sullivan back into her life.

Key Events

Annie helps set up the rehearsal dinner and admires Kira’s decorating skills.
She sits between Iris and Bennett, trying to avoid Mac, who is at a different table.
Archer’s meal is praised; playful banter occurs about carrying his baby for such food.
Mayor Kelly discusses the wedding ceremony with the bridal couple.
Estelle asks Jeanie about wedding-night attire, causing embarrassment for Logan.
Couples dance; Annie feels isolated as the only single person besides Mac.
Annie dances with a guest who describes feeding geckos pellets, cutting the dance short.
She steps outside alone to compose herself under the starry sky.
Kira notices Annie watching Mac and asks what happened between them; Annie says only that they were “young and stupid.”
After everyone else leaves, Kira pretends to forget the lights, leaving only twinkle lights on.
Mac and Annie share a tender moment, remembering a Christmas-lights tour from years ago.
Mac admits that night was his favorite and that he still feels the same way.
They sway together in a slow dance; Annie indulges briefly before pulling away.
Annie walks out, reaffirming her resolve to protect herself from Mac.

Character Development

Annie: Feels increasingly out of place among happy couples, revealing her loneliness and unresolved feelings. Her brief surrender to Mac’s memory shows vulnerability, but her inner promise to avoid him demonstrates self-protection learned from past hurt.
Mac: Expresses genuine fondness and regret. His quiet watchfulness and hesitant approach indicate he still cares deeply, but he respects Annie’s boundaries when she pulls away.
Kira: Shows curiosity about the past and subtly manipulates the situation by dimming the lights, hinting at her role as a gentle instigator for the main couple.
Supporting characters (Iris, Archer, Bennett, Estelle) reinforce the warm, community atmosphere and contrast with Annie’s isolation.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Nostalgia vs. Reality: The twinkle lights and the memory of the Christmas-lights tour symbolize a perfect, unspoiled moment. Annie must choose between clinging to that idealized past and facing the messy present.
Isolation amid Togetherness: The chapter repeatedly emphasizes Annie’s single status against a backdrop of couples, highlighting her emotional loneliness.
Promises and Self-Protection: Annie’s vow to the girl she once was governs her current choices. The motif of keeping promises (to oneself) is central to her internal conflict.
The Dance as Metaphor: The slow dance with Mac represents the possibility of reconciliation, but Annie cuts it short, illustrating her struggle between desire and caution.

Why This Chapter Matters

Chapter 7 (Chapter 5) provides the first extended, intimate interaction between Annie and Mac since the story’s present timeline began. It fleshes out the backstory of their failed relationship through shared recollection, making their conflict feel real and earned. The chapter also deepens Annie’s character by showing her loneliness and her fierce commitment to a painful promise. The emotional stakes are raised for the remainder of the wedding weekend, setting up the tension that will drive the next chapters.

Study Questions and Answers

What triggers Annie’s memories of Mac during the rehearsal dinner?
Answer: The sight of happy couples dancing, the closeness of friends like Hazel and Noah, and the romantic atmosphere of the barn all remind Annie of what she lacks. More directly, the twinkle lights and Mac’s proximity provoke a specific recollection of the Christmas-lights tour they took years ago.
Why does Annie pull away from Mac during the slow dance, despite still feeling drawn to him?
Answer: She is honoring a promise she made to her younger self after Mac left her waiting for a year. She fears that giving in again would betray that promise and expose her to further hurt. Her ego and self-protection win over her lingering attraction.
How does Kira’s action of “forgetting” the lights advance the plot?
Answer: By dimming the main lights and leaving only the twinkle lights, Kira creates an intimate setting that encourages Mac and Annie to talk and dance. This action forces them into a private, emotionally charged moment that Annie has been avoiding. It also shows Kira’s gentle meddling and sets the stage for future interactions.

Navigation

Previous Chapter: Chapter 6 Summary
Next Chapter: Chapter 8 Summary
Back to Book Hub