Chapter summaries The Five-Star Weekend Elin Hilderbrand

The Drop II: Brooke Reveals Her Friendship with Hollis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

Caroline finds Brooke in the kitchen and invites her downstairs for a filmed interview. Brooke explains how she met Hollis at a doctor’s office when both were pregnant. She recalls the golden age of their friendship, especially the years of “rock and roll football” parties at Electra Undergrove’s house. The parties involved football viewing, drinking, and dancing. Brooke felt part of a village. However, Electra eventually dropped Brooke from the group without explanation. Brooke tried to contact Electra repeatedly but got no response. She called Hollis, who admitted she was still invited and continued attending with other women. Brooke felt betrayed that Hollis did not immediately defend her. Only after the Super Bowl did Hollis break with Electra, and they planned a trip to the Virgin Islands instead. Brooke reflects on her insecurity and her crush on Electra, but now feels detached. Caroline shuts off the camera, and Brooke leaves to read by the pool. Caroline realizes she hasn’t interviewed Gigi and will have to do it after the sail.

Key Events

  • Caroline interviews Brooke on camera about her friendship with Hollis.
  • Brooke describes meeting Hollis when both were pregnant.
  • Brooke recalls the “rock and roll football” Sunday parties hosted by Electra.
  • The parties included a large group of mothers and their families.
  • Electra sends Brooke a text uninviting her and Charlie.
  • Brooke calls Electra repeatedly but gets no answer.
  • Brooke calls Hollis, who is still invited and plans to attend.
  • Brooke realizes Hollis did not stand up for her immediately.
  • After the Super Bowl, Hollis finally breaks with Electra and plans a trip with Brooke.
  • Brooke now feels detached and self-possessed.
  • Caroline ends the interview, and Brooke goes poolside.
  • Caroline notes she has no time to interview Gigi before lunch.

Character Development

  • Brooke: Shifts from insecure and cringey behavior to self-possession. She admits her past weakness and now feels refreshed detachment from the Electra drama.
  • Caroline: Gains insight into her mother’s past friendship dynamics. She sees Brooke in a new light.
  • Hollis: (discussed) Portrayed as a good person but initially hesitant to intervene. Eventually chooses loyalty to Brooke.
  • Electra: (discussed) Characterized as manipulative and status-conscious, dropping Brooke for unclear reasons.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Friendship dynamics and social hierarchy: The rock and roll football group has a clear pyramid with Electra and Hollis at top.
  • Exclusion and vulnerability: Being dropped from the group without explanation highlights the insecurity Brooke felt.
  • The golden age of friendship: Brooke’s nostalgia for the early years contrasts with the painful end.
  • Self-possession vs. insecurity: Brooke’s transformation from trying too hard to feeling at ease.
  • Loyalty vs. self-preservation: Hollis’s delayed reaction shows the tension between maintaining group harmony and standing up for a friend.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter deepens the backstory of Brooke and Hollis’s friendship, explaining the roots of their current closeness. It reveals the painful incident that occurred during the “rock and roll football” era and shows how Hollis ultimately chose Brooke over the popular group. The chapter also marks a turning point for Brooke’s character: she gains self-possession and resolves past insecurity. For Caroline, the interview fills in gaps about her mother’s social history and sets up her final conversation with Gigi.

Study Questions and Answers

  1. Question: What does Brooke identify as the “golden age” of her friendship with Hollis? Answer: The years when their children were in fourth and fifth grade (ages nine to eleven), during the rock and roll football parties at Electra’s house.

  2. Question: Why does Electra drop Brooke from the group, and how does Brooke react? Answer: Electra sends a text uninviting Brooke with no explanation. Brooke calls repeatedly and leaves a pleading message; she never gets an answer. She suspects it might be due to her insecurity or something Charlie did.

  3. Question: How does Hollis handle the situation initially, and what does she do later? Answer: Initially, Hollis continues attending Electra’s parties without Brooke, saying she doesn’t want to get in the middle. After the Super Bowl, she tells Electra she won’t join the spring break trip and instead plans a Virgin Islands getaway with Brooke.

Navigation