Chapter 22 (CHAPTER 17): Amateur Night Surprise
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
Brea and Garrett revisit their Dartmouth memories, including the library where they first kissed, and watch a sunset. They then go to Sunapee Roadhouse for dinner. When Brea notices an amateur night sign, she secretly signs Garrett up and borrows a guitar. After the host announces Garrett's name, Brea hands him the guitar, and Garrett performs three songs: "Crazy Little Thing Called Love," "A Horse with No Name," and "The Sound of Silence." The crowd enthusiastically participates. Garrett then dedicates a fourth song, "You Are So Beautiful," to Brea and calls her onstage. Despite her initial embarrassment, Brea sits beside him and is moved to tears as he sings softly and sweetly, making the moment intensely personal amid the public setting.
Key Events
- Brea and Garrett take a nostalgic tour of Dartmouth, reenacting their first kiss at Baker-Berry Library.
- They drive to Sunapee Roadhouse for cheeseburgers and beer.
- Brea spots a sandwich board advertising amateur night and decides to surprise Garrett.
- She borrows a beat-up Gibson acoustic guitar from a backstage crew member.
- The host announces Garrett as the first amateur-night performer.
- Brea hands Garrett the guitar, and he reluctantly takes the stage.
- Garrett performs three crowd-pleasing songs, winning over the audience.
- He calls Brea onstage to dedicate "You Are So Beautiful" to her.
- Brea joins him under the spotlight and is brought to tears by his heartfelt rendition.
Character Development
Brea Cooke reveals her resourceful and mischievous side by orchestrating the amateur night stunt. She shows both daring (negotiating for the guitar) and vulnerability (tearing up during his dedication). Her decision to push Garrett into the spotlight suggests a desire to see him shine and share a memorable experience.
Garrett Wilson demonstrates adaptability and emotional openness. Initially confused and pale, he embraces the situation, performing confidently and connecting with the audience. His choice of songs—from rock to folk to a tender ballad—displays range, and his dedication to Brea reveals his deep affection. The chapter highlights his comfort with public vulnerability when it serves their relationship.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Vulnerability as a love language. Brea forces Garrett into an uncomfortable situation, but he transforms it into a declaration of love. His willingness to be exposed onstage mirrors the trust in their relationship.
Nostalgia and re‑creation. The chapter begins with nostalgic visits to Dartmouth haunts and recreating first kisses. This primes the emotional atmosphere for a new shared memory that echoes their past.
Public vs. private intimacy. Even in a crowded restaurant, Garrett and Brea create a private bubble of connection. The stage and spotlight symbolize the tension between public performance and personal truth.
Music as emotional conduit. Garrett uses song lyrics to express feelings that might be harder to say directly. The audience’s participation turns the moment into a communal celebration of love.
Why This Chapter Matters
Chapter 22 deepens the romantic core of the novel by showing the couple’s playful dynamic and their ability to surprise each other. It moves beyond the political and personal pressures that may surround Brea’s role as First Lady? (if that is her role) and focuses purely on the relationship. The chapter also reinforces Garrett’s character as both a performer and a devoted partner, while Brea’s orchestration demonstrates her assertiveness and creativity. The emotional payoff—Brea crying—signals that their bond is strong and sincere, providing a warm respite from any larger plot tensions.
Study Questions and Answers
1. Why does Brea decide to sign Garrett up for amateur night without telling him? Brea wants to create a spontaneous and memorable evening. She knows Garrett enjoys music (they often sing or play?) and believes he will rise to the occasion. It also reflects her playful, somewhat diabolical personality, as she later calls it “payback” for something? The chapter implies she enjoys testing boundaries in a loving way.
2. How does Garrett react when he realizes he is being called to the stage? He is initially confused, then turns pale and says “No way.” He looks at Brea with disbelief and discomfort. However, once onstage, he adapts quickly, performing three songs with increasing confidence and eventually turning the situation into a tribute to Brea.
3. What does the song “You Are So Beautiful” symbolize in this scene? The song represents Garrett’s raw, unfiltered affection for Brea. Sung softly and without any ironic distance, it cuts through the crowd’s noise and makes their connection feel private and sacred. Brea’s tears indicate that the moment touches her deeply, affirming that their love is genuine and reciprocated.
Navigation
- Previous Chapter (Chapter 21)
- Next Chapter (Chapter 23)
- Book Hub