Chapter 40 Summary, Analysis, and Key Themes
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
Katarina wakes up in Saint Louis University Hospital with Heath holding her hand. The first sensations she registers are the IV in her skin, the heart monitor on her finger, and a diffuse, overwhelming pain that makes her feel like her whole body is an open wound. Heath sits beside her, head bowed as if in prayer, his heel tapping nervously—a habit from their novice competition days. When she laces her fingers through his, he looks at her with an expression she reads as relief, as if she were a sunrise after years of darkness.
She asks what happened. Heath tells her she's in the hospital and that she fell at Nationals. He is still wearing his free dance costume, and the front of his tuxedo shirt is smeared with red stains. Her white skating dress hangs over a chair by the window, stiff with dried blood—her blood. She remembers Heath warning her not to skate, but she took the ice anyway. After that, her memory is a blur: a stomach-lurching drop, glaring lights, satin against her cheek, and being lifted off the ice, floating upward.
She asks about the Olympic team announcement. Heath says he doesn't know and doesn't care. She then recalls a fragmented memory of Bella's voice, weak and desperate, pleading with Heath: “You can't. Please, Heath, don't do this, we have to—” When she asks Heath what he did, he deflects, saying it doesn't matter and that all that matters is her recovery.
Key Events
-
Katarina wakes in the hospital, injured and in pain, with Heath at her side.
-
Heath is still in his free dance costume, stained with blood, and her dress is ruined.
-
Katarina remembers Heath's warning not to skate and her decision to take the ice anyway.
-
She asks about the Olympic team; Heath dismisses the question.
-
She recalls a desperate plea from Bella, cut off mid-sentence.
-
Katarina asks Heath what he did; he avoids answering.
Character Development
Heath emerges as a figure of intense devotion. His physical presence—still in costume, blood on his shirt, tapping heel—shows he hasn't left her side. His response to her question about the Olympic team (“I don't know. I don't care.”) reveals that his priorities have shifted entirely to her well-being. Yet his deflection when she asks about Bella's plea hints at a darker side: he may have done something drastic, something he doesn't want her to know. This chapter deepens his complexity, balancing tenderness with a hint of menace.
Katarina is physically broken but mentally sharp enough to piece together fragments. Her memory is unreliable, but she insists on asking about the competition and about Heath's actions. She is vulnerable, dependent on Heath for care, yet her questions show she isn't passive—she's trying to understand what happened. Her fall represents the physical cost of her ambition, and her fragmented memory underscores how trauma can distort perception.
Bella appears only in memory, but her voice—weak, pleading, desperate—suggests she was trying to stop Heath from doing something. Her absence from the hospital room raises questions about her fate and her relationship with Heath.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Sacrifice and Physical Cost of Ambition: Katarina's injury is a direct result of her choice to skate against Heath's warning. Her ruined dress, stiff with blood, symbolizes the price of her pursuit of Olympic glory. The hospital setting contrasts sharply with the glittering ice rink, emphasizing the toll that elite competition takes on the body.
Devotion: Heath's unwavering presence, his refusal to care about the Olympic team, and his focus on Katarina's recovery illustrate a devotion that borders on obsession. His hand in hers is a lifeline, but his deflection hints that his devotion may have led him to act recklessly.
Fragmented Memory: Katarina's memories are disjointed—lights, satin, being lifted, Bella's plea. This motif highlights the unreliability of trauma-affected recollection and sets up a mystery that the reader must piece together alongside her.
Love vs. Career: The chapter pits Heath's love for Katarina against her career ambitions. He warned her not to skate; she did anyway. Now, in the hospital, he prioritizes her life over any future competition, while she still asks about the Olympic team. This tension underscores the central conflict of their relationship.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter is a pivotal turning point in The Favorites. It delivers the immediate aftermath of the Nationals fall, showing the physical and emotional wreckage. More importantly, it introduces a major mystery: what did Heath do that Bella was pleading against? The reader is left with a cliffhanger that deepens Heath's character and raises stakes for the rest of the novel. The chapter also crystallizes the theme of ambition's cost—Katarina's body is broken, and her dreams may be shattered, but her first question is about the Olympic team. This moment forces readers to confront the sacrifices athletes make and the blurred lines between love, loyalty, and obsession.
Study Questions and Answers
1. What does Heath's response to Katarina's question about the Olympic team reveal about his character?
Heath says he doesn't know and doesn't care about the team announcement. This reveals that his priorities have completely shifted from competition to Katarina's recovery. It shows his devotion, but also a potential disregard for the sport that once defined them. His lack of interest suggests that he may have done something that makes the outcome irrelevant, or that he is so consumed by her well-being that nothing else matters.
2. Why does Katarina have fragmented memories of the incident?
The text shows she was injured and likely lost consciousness. Her memories are described as a blur, with isolated sensations like lights, satin, and being lifted. This fragmentation is a natural response to trauma, as the brain may suppress or distort painful events. It also serves a narrative purpose: it leaves gaps that the reader and Katarina must fill, creating suspense about what actually happened.
3. What might Heath have done that Bella was pleading about?
The evidence only gives Bella's desperate words: “You can't. Please, Heath, don't do this, we have to—” The sentence is cut off, and Heath deflects when asked. Based on the context—Heath's blood-stained shirt, his refusal to discuss it, and his intense focus on Katarina—it's plausible he confronted someone or took drastic action to protect her, possibly harming another person or sabotaging the competition. However, the text does not confirm this, leaving it as an open question for the reader.