Chapter 20 Summary: What Happens at 6:22 p.m.
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
Chapter 20 opens at 6:22 p.m. as Neil McNair arrives at Rowan's parents' home for Shabbat dinner. Rowan notes that Neil is staring at her parents with disbelief, and her mother invites him to lead the kiddush blessing over the wine. Neil accepts and recites the blessing with flawless pronunciation and inflection, which impresses Rowan. She reflects on how Judaism can feel isolating, but seeing Neil participate so naturally makes her feel less alone in that experience.
During dinner, the conversation turns to the Howl contest. Rowan's parents are relaxed now that they're not on deadline, and they listen intently as Rowan and Neil explain their strategy, the clues, and the grand prize. Rowan's dad suggests the contest could make a fun book, though her mom is skeptical, calling it too niche.
Neil then reveals he's been a longtime fan of Rowan's parents' Excavated book series, having started reading it in third grade. He's brought two books for signing—one for himself and one for his eleven-year-old sister, Natalie. Rowan's parents are charmed and happily sign both books. Neil also mentions that he loves romance novels, which surprises Rowan, and he defends the genre, noting that it centers women's experiences in ways other media doesn't.
Rowan's dad dismisses romance novels with a comment about them being for bored housewives, and Neil gently pushes back. Rowan, feeling her lungs tighten, excuses herself and escapes to the kitchen. Her mother follows her, and they have a heart-to-heart. Rowan admits she's afraid her parents won't take her dream of writing romance novels seriously. Her mother shares that her own father-in-law once asked when they'd start writing real books, and she reassures Rowan that they each have their preferences and can agree to disagree.
Finally, Rowan's mother asks if there's something romantic going on between Rowan and Neil. Rowan denies it emphatically, insisting they're just teammates for the game. But her mind wanders to the way Neil said the kiddush, the freckles across his face, and the way his arms look in his T-shirt. Her mother smirks and returns to the dining room.
Key Events
-
Neil leads the kiddush blessing at Rowan's family Shabbat dinner, impressing everyone with his fluency.
-
Rowan shares a painful fifth-grade memory about a teacher who made her feel othered for being Jewish.
-
Neil reveals he's a devoted fan of Rowan's parents' Excavated series and gets two books signed.
-
Neil admits he loves romance novels and defends the genre when Rowan's dad dismisses it.
-
Rowan retreats to the kitchen, where her mother follows and they discuss Rowan's fear of parental disapproval.
-
Rowan's mother asks if there's something romantic between Rowan and Neil; Rowan denies it.
Character Development
Rowan — This chapter shows Rowan at her most vulnerable. She's usually confident and competitive, but here she grapples with deep-seated fears about her creative ambitions. Her confession that she's afraid her parents will dismiss her romance-writing dreams as a hobby reveals a softer, more uncertain side. The fact that she's able to be honest with her mother—even about losing her virginity—shows the trust in their relationship, yet she still can't bring herself to fully confess her career aspirations.
Neil — Neil's character deepens significantly here. He's no longer just Rowan's rival; he's someone who shares her Jewish identity, who's a genuine fan of her parents' work, and who defends romance novels with sincerity. His flawless kiddush recitation and his quiet admission that being around other Jewish people is nice show a more personal, grounded side. His defense of romance novels—noting they center women's experiences—also reveals his respect for the genre and, by extension, for Rowan.
Rowan's mom — She emerges as a supportive but imperfect figure. She validates Rowan's feelings, shares her own experience with criticism from family, and tries to reassure her daughter. But her response that they can agree to disagree isn't quite the full validation Rowan is hoping for. Her final question about Neil shows she's perceptive about the growing tension between them.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Jewish identity and othering — The chapter explores what it means to be Jewish in a predominantly non-Jewish environment. Rowan's fifth-grade story about the teacher who made a spectacle of taking down the Christmas tree illustrates how well-meaning gestures can still cause harm. Neil's comment that being around other Jewish people is nice underscores the comfort of shared identity.
Genre prejudice — Rowan's dad's dismissive comment about romance novels being for bored housewives highlights the cultural bias against the genre. Neil's defense of romance novels as centering women's experiences pushes back against that prejudice, and Rowan's fear that her parents won't take her writing seriously stems directly from this attitude.
The kiddush cup — The silver cup that belonged to Rowan's dad's grandparents symbolizes family heritage and continuity. Passing it around the table connects the generations and reinforces the theme of legacy.
Fear of parental disapproval — Rowan's internal monologue reveals her terror that her parents will dismiss her dreams. Her mother's story about Grandpa asking when they'd write real books shows that even successful authors face this kind of criticism, which both comforts and unsettles Rowan.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter is pivotal for several reasons. It deepens the connection between Rowan and Neil by placing them in a domestic, familial setting where their shared Jewish identity becomes a point of bonding rather than difference. Neil's participation in the Shabbat rituals and his genuine warmth with Rowan's parents complicate Rowan's perception of him as merely a rival.
The chapter also advances Rowan's internal arc. Her fear about her parents' reaction to her romance-writing ambitions is a central emotional conflict, and this conversation with her mother—while not fully resolving it—moves her closer to being able to voice her dreams. The fact that she's about to meet Delilah, a romance author, later that evening adds urgency to this theme.
Finally, the chapter plants seeds for the romantic tension between Rowan and Neil. Rowan's denial to her mother is undercut by her own wandering thoughts about Neil's freckles and arms, signaling that her feelings are shifting even if she's not ready to admit it.
Study Questions and Answers
1. How does Neil's participation in the Shabbat dinner change Rowan's perception of him?
Neil's flawless recitation of the kiddush and his comment about being around other Jewish people being nice show Rowan a side of him she hadn't considered. She reflects that she'd labeled him an enemy, but he might have been feeling isolated in the same way she does. This shared experience of Jewish identity creates a new bond between them and complicates her view of him as just a rival.
2. What does Rowan's fifth-grade story about Mrs. Garrison reveal about microaggressions?
The story shows how a teacher's attempt to accommodate Rowan's Jewish identity backfired. By announcing to the entire class that she was taking down the Christmas tree because of Rowan, Mrs. Garrison singled Rowan out and made her the target of classmates' anger. The teacher never asked Rowan what she wanted, demonstrating how well-intentioned actions can still cause harm when they center the majority's perspective rather than the affected person's needs.
3. Why does Rowan's mother's response about romance novels feel incomplete to Rowan?
Rowan's mother says they can agree to disagree about preferences, which isn't quite the validation Rowan is seeking. Rowan wants her parents to take her dream of writing romance novels seriously, but her mother's response treats it as a matter of taste rather than a legitimate creative ambition. This leaves Rowan feeling that her aspirations are still not fully understood or supported, even though her mother's intentions are kind.
Navigation
Back to Book Hub