Chapter 37 Summary and Analysis
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
Summary
The chapter opens on Tuesday, June 21, 1921 — the summer solstice and the ninth week of term — with Henry cycling away from the rectory toward Oxford. The remaining group settles in the parlor with tea, watching Constance play with a kitten on the floor. Beatrice studies the child with fascination, noting that while Constance has a tanned, fleshy build unlike her mother's, she shares Marianne's long neck and hooded eyes. As she watches, Beatrice slowly digests the news she has just received, replaying scenes from the previous two terms that had not quite made sense at the time — particularly how Marianne would return from weekend visits home exhausted and having done very little reading.
Otto declares herself excellent with children and announces she will be Constance's unofficial aunt, promising they will celebrate their birthdays together. Constance is enchanted by Otto's long yellow beads. Marianne explains that her daughter is somewhat spoiled by her father and mother-in-law, and that she spends her weekends trying to counteract the effects of too many late nights and jam tarts.
Dora expresses wonder that she had no idea, and Beatrice echoes the sentiment. Marianne reveals that Olive lives at the rectory and takes care of things during term time, and that Olive insisted Marianne must go to Oxford, saying Thomas would have wanted it. Beatrice finds it strange to think of Marianne as a widow — that her real name is Mrs. Thomas Ward — and reflects on how exhausting it must have been to keep such a weighty secret.
When Dora asks what will happen if Miss Jourdain finds out, Otto responds darkly that they must make sure she doesn't. Beatrice asks whether there are rules forbidding widows or mothers from enrolling, but Marianne notes that such rules wouldn't matter to Miss Jourdain. The revelation that Miss Jourdain is involved surprises Beatrice more than the news that Marianne is a widow with a daughter. Miss Jourdain, with all her rules and religious fervor, was party to this secret — it seems impossible. Marianne explains that while there are no formal rules against mothers attending, it would be considered a bad show and could even threaten her custody of Constance. Miss Jourdain swore them to secrecy.
Beatrice apologizes for not realizing, recalling how Marianne cried at The Kid and the fuss over the kittens. Otto reassures her that even an enormous brain misses things. Marianne, wiping her eyes, explains she was too ashamed to tell them and had promised Miss Jourdain she wouldn't. She describes her panic from the moment she arrived at Oxford, counting down the days until she could go home at the weekend, but knowing that she and Connie would both have a better life if she could teach. The eight-week terms seemed bearable as long as she could see her daughter some weekends. She kept returning to the question: is it so wrong to want something for herself? Dora takes her hand and assures her it isn't wrong at all.
Otto observes that not everyone goes to Oxford to become Marie Curie — most are ordinary people grasping the opportunity of an extraordinary education, and that goes for the men too. For once, there is nothing further to explain.
After Constance goes to bed, they eat supper with Marianne's father, Reverend Grey. Beatrice is surprised to find him younger and more vital than her own father, and an expert on ancient Greek theater. He talks passionately about his time studying Greats at Magdalen and wants to hear about the new school of PPE.
After helping Marianne's mother-in-law clear up, they take the motorcar to Boars Hill to watch the sun set over Oxford. The hill is home to poets and academics who prefer to live outside the city, with rolling pasture, heathland dotted with ancient oak and beech trees, hovering kestrels, and wandering cows. Marianne identifies the view as the one Arnold had in mind when he wrote about the sweet city with her dreaming spires — specifically from Thyrsis, the poem about Arthur Hugh Clough. Dora confirms the reference. Marianne notes they experienced it together in winter, and that the view has likely changed little in eighty years.
Beatrice observes that one day it will change — that's the number one rule of life. She removes her hat and begins sketching the skyline, numbering the spires to create a key. Otto compares the scene to a Turner painting, and when Beatrice asks whether she means William Turner of Oxford or J. M. W. Turner — both of whom painted the scene and are in the Ashmolean — Otto admits she means the one on the wall in the WC at the Good Luck Tea Rooms.
Dora asks whether orchids grow around Boars Hill, and Marianne says the soil is too sandy. Beatrice mentions that Henry says they found orchids in the meadow at Christ Church, dormant all this time after the land was allowed to go to seed following the vegetable growing. There's one bee orchid that's been cordoned off, and Henry thinks there may be more. Dora marvels that they were under their feet all that time, and Otto adds just like the cowpats.
From four hundred feet above sea level, Oxford lies below them, dwarfed by the sky, looking as if it is sinking into the surrounding hillsides. They identify the Radder's dome, All Souls' turrets, Exeter College chapel's steeple, the University Church of St. Mary the Virgin, All Saints' Church tower, Magdalen Tower, Tom Tower, and the Sheldonian Theater's cupola. The sun, on its longest journey of the year, descends in amber brushstrokes, and the city blushes as it sinks into shadow.
Dora reflects that the thing about Oxford is that you spend all this time fretting that you don't belong, but when you are apart from it, you feel as if you've left something precious behind. Otto jokes about her two engagement rings, and an affectionate scuffle ensues. Beatrice reminds them they promised Miss Kirby they'd be back by ten. Marianne moves closer and puts her arms out; they encircle her, heads pressed together, as if it were the most natural thing in the world. And then they rise.
Key Events
-
Beatrice learns that Marianne is a widow with a daughter, Constance, and that Miss Jourdain has been party to the secret
-
Marianne explains Olive's role in caring for Constance during term time
-
The group has supper with Reverend Grey, who is healthy and knowledgeable about Greek theater
-
They drive to Boars Hill for a summer solstice sunset over Oxford
-
Beatrice sketches the skyline, numbering spires for a key
-
The group discusses orchids found at Christ Church meadow
-
Dora reflects on belonging and alienation from Oxford
-
The group embraces Marianne before returning by ten
Character Development
Beatrice — Her apology to Marianne shows growth in emotional awareness, though Otto's teasing suggests she still misses social cues. Her impulse to sketch the skyline reflects her instinct to preserve and understand through observation and documentation.
Marianne — The revelation of her secret reshapes the reader's understanding of her. Her explanation — that she was counting down the days until weekends, but knew teaching would give both her and Connie a better life — reveals the painful calculus of motherhood and ambition. Her question, is it so wrong to want something for myself, is the emotional core of the chapter.
Otto — Her declaration as unofficial aunt and her pragmatic observation about ordinary people grasping extraordinary education shows her loyalty and her grounded perspective on why they are all at Oxford.
Dora — Her reflection on belonging and alienation captures the ambivalence many of the women feel about Oxford.
Reverend Grey — Subverts Beatrice's expectations; he is vital, healthy, and intellectually engaged, suggesting that Marianne's family situation is more complex than imagined.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Secrecy and deception — The chapter centers on the revelation of Marianne's secret, and the web of complicity that includes Miss Jourdain and Olive. The theme of hidden truths beneath the surface is reinforced by the orchids that lay dormant under the meadow.
Motherhood and academia — Marianne's struggle to reconcile her role as a mother with her desire for education is the chapter's central tension. Her question about whether it is wrong to want something for herself speaks to the broader constraints on women's self-fulfillment.
Belonging and alienation — Dora's reflection on feeling apart from Oxford while also feeling she has left something precious behind when away captures the ambivalent relationship the women have with the institution.
Impermanence and change — Beatrice's observation that one day it will change, that's the number one rule of life, ties the sunset and the summer solstice to the theme of impermanence. The sketching of the skyline is an attempt to preserve what will inevitably change.
The Oxford skyline as symbol — The detailed description of the spires and towers from Boars Hill presents Oxford as a place of beauty and aspiration, but also as something distant and dwarfed by the sky — perhaps reflecting the women's precarious position within it.
Summer solstice — The longest day of the year marks a turning point, both literally and metaphorically, as secrets are revealed and the group's time at Oxford draws toward its end.
Sketching as preservation — Beatrice's impulse to capture the skyline, numbering the spires for a key, mirrors the novel's concern with memory and documentation.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter is a turning point in the novel. The revelation of Marianne's secret transforms the reader's understanding of her character and of the social constraints facing women who sought education in this period. It also deepens the friendship among the group — the embrace at the end, heads pressed together, signals a new level of solidarity. The chapter's setting on the summer solstice, with the sunset over Oxford, provides a moment of reflection on impermanence and change, and the detailed description of the skyline from Boars Hill offers a symbolic view of Oxford as both aspirational and distant. The chapter also develops the theme of hidden truths beneath the surface, reinforced by the dormant orchids and the secret that has been kept for so long.
Study Questions and Answers
1. Why does Beatrice apologize to Marianne, and what does this reveal about her character?
Beatrice apologizes for not realizing Marianne's situation, recalling specific moments — the fuss over the kittens and Marianne's tears at The Kid — that she now understands differently. The apology reveals Beatrice's growing emotional awareness and her capacity for empathy, though Otto's teasing suggests she still misses social cues. It also shows that Beatrice is willing to acknowledge her own failures of perception.
2. How does the chapter use the setting of Boars Hill and the summer solstice to reinforce its themes?
The Boars Hill setting provides a vantage point from which Oxford appears dwarfed by the sky, reinforcing the theme of belonging and alienation — the women are both part of and apart from the city. The summer solstice, the longest day of the year, marks a turning point, and Beatrice's observation that one day it will change ties the sunset to the theme of impermanence. The dormant orchids at Christ Church meadow reinforce the theme of hidden truths beneath the surface.
3. What does Marianne's question — is it so wrong to want something for myself — reveal about the constraints facing women in this period?
Marianne's question reveals the deep conflict between motherhood and self-fulfillment that women faced. She has had to keep her identity as a mother secret, fearing that it would be considered a bad show and that she might even lose custody of Constance. Her question suggests that the very act of wanting something for herself — an education, a career — was seen as selfish and potentially dangerous, and that women had to make painful calculations about their own ambitions versus their duties to their families.
Navigation
-
Next Chapter