Chapter 8 (Diana): Summary, Themes, and Analysis
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.
⚠️ This page contains detailed plot points and character developments from That Summer, Chapter 8: Diana. If you haven't finished this chapter yet, you may want to read it first before continuing.
Summary
By early autumn, Diana has settled into a steady rhythm on Cape Cod. Each morning, while the weather allows, she swims in the ocean, walking south along the beach for half an hour before swimming back to the cottage. She fills her days with reading, errands, laundry, and trips to restock her pantry. The neighboring cottages sit empty, and she can go days without seeing another car on her road, just as Dr. Levy predicted the off-season would be.
At three thirty in the afternoon, Diana dresses in one of her three white shirts and black pants, pockets her bow tie, and drives fifteen minutes into Provincetown. At four thirty, Reese gathers the staff to review the evening's specials. Chef Carl, a towering, silent man, prepares tasting portions of each special so the wait staff can describe them accurately to diners, along with a simple staff meal. Diana's shift runs from six until one in the morning, or until the last check is dropped. Reese gives her four shifts: dinner Tuesdays through Thursdays and a Sunday split shift with brunch and dinner. Fridays and Saturdays, the most lucrative nights, go to more senior staff, but Diana doesn't mind. The slower pace suits her, and the off-season clientele—mostly locals celebrating birthdays, anniversaries, or a child coming home from college—are friendly and patient. Her tips cover her expenses and let her start a savings account.
Diana gets to know what Reese calls the Abbey's happy family. She shadows Carly, a single mother who attends morning AA meetings and lives with her daughter Melody in an apartment off Shank Painter Road. Carly is brisk and unsmiling except when talking about Melody, a talented young pianist who competes in pageants. Carly's plan is to move to Vermont when Melody is old enough to compete for Miss America, reasoning that the state's small population gives her daughter a better chance than Texas would. Diana also meets Jonathan, Reese's partner, an accomplished pianist who manages a local theater and hosts a Thursday-night singalong at the Crown & Anchor.
Ryan, the host, is standoffish at first. He calls everyone Bitch, regardless of gender, and escalates to Miss Thing when irritated and Missy Miss when genuinely upset. Diana suspects he's whispering about her with Frankie the bartender and Lizzie the waitress. One night, a middle-aged couple arrives—a man in a suit, a woman with hairspray-stiffened hair and a gold cross at her throat. Ryan's face goes pale as he seats them. After her shift, Diana finds Ryan crying behind the Dumpster. It's his birthday, and the couple were his parents. Reese later explains that Ryan's mother discovered fifteen-year-old Ryan wearing one of her dresses and gave him an ultimatum: renounce his identity, attend a conversion camp, or leave home. He left, couch-surfed through high school, and moved to Provincetown. His parents still don't speak to him, but every year on his birthday they come to dinner, leave five hundred dollars on the table, and walk out without a word.
The next morning, Diana arrives an hour early, buys Ryan a birthday card and a pair of cashmere socks from a boutique. After that, Ryan becomes her champion—helping her clean up when she drops a tray of glasses, slipping her day-old pastries from the Portuguese Bakery, and seating the best tippers in her section.
Diana acquires regulars: Heavy Flo, a drag queen whose real name is Phil Amoroso, and Dora Fitzsimmons, a taciturn sailing-camp owner who comes every Tuesday at five o'clock for a well-done burger with curly fries—a menu item the chef keeps in the freezer from the restaurant's days as D'Amico's. Dora never says much beyond please and thank you, but always leaves a ten-dollar bill under her water glass.
When the staff gathers at the bar after closing to split tips and plan nights out, Diana says good night and returns to her cottage to read and sleep.
On a sunny Monday in October, Diana drives to the dog shelter in Dennis. She walks past the jumping, licking, whining dogs until she reaches the last pen, where a scrawny, shivering dog with a patchy white coat huddles in the corner, too scared to approach. Diana crouches with a treat, waits patiently, and finally sets it on the floor. The trembling dog takes the treat but carries it back to her bed and hides it under a blanket instead of eating it. Twenty minutes later, Diana has filled out the paperwork, paid the fees, and is driving back to Truro with Willa on a blanket beside her.
Willa was found on Skaket Beach at the end of summer. Diana wonders whether a family abandoned her after a last vacation, whether she ran from fireworks, or whether she fled a home where she was kicked and yelled at. In the cottage, Willa sniffs every corner, eats cautiously, and tries to hide kibble under the couch. That first night, Diana invites her up to the loft bed, and Willa curls against her hip, muzzle on Diana's forearm.
Over the following weeks, Diana buys Willa a dog bed and a used three-speed bike with a wicker basket. They walk every morning and ride to the post office every few days. At two in the morning, Diana comes home to find the stove light burning and Willa wagging her tail on the couch. Diana's skin tans, her hair streaks gold, and the swimming, biking, and sound sleep erase the worry from her eyes. Day by day, she feels stronger, more herself, more at home.
By October, the trees are bare, the water too cold for swimming, and the town has emptied out. Diana starts recognizing the faces of fellow washashores and year-rounders: the grocery clerk, the librarians, the guy behind the counter at Joe's.
After Reese's fiftieth birthday party at the Abbey—a raucous celebration where the chef makes paella, Reese sings on a tabletop, and Diana dances to Love Shack until after two in the morning—she sleeps late. A loud knock wakes her. A man shouts Caretaker! Diana, startled, wraps a purple knit blanket around her waist and answers the door.
Michael Carmody is a tall, heavyset, bearded man with a Boston accent, a Red Sox cap, and a barn jacket. He explains that Dr. Levy and her husband hired him to winterize their properties: storm windows, weather stripping, mouse traps, snow plowing, and general upkeep. Diana is cautious, but he suggests she call Dr. Levy to verify him. She does, and agrees to let him work while she's at her shifts.
Willa, who has nosed the screen door open, head-butts Michael's knee. He scratches her ears and asks if he can give her a treat, pulling dehydrated hot dog slices from his pocket—a trick his father taught him. Willa, who has never shown such agility, catches treats mid-air and rolls over for belly rubs. Michael mentions growing up with a golden retriever named Monty who hid under the porch during fireworks. Diana doesn't want to be amused, but she can't help picturing a big, dopey dog matching this big, amiable man.
Michael leaves a business card, and when Diana returns from work that night, she finds another card tucked in the door, a waist-high pile of firewood stacked by the door, and a Baggie of dehydrated hot dog treats on top. She tells Willa her affections can't be bought, then sighs and gives her one of Michael's treats anyway.
Key Events
-
Diana establishes a daily routine of swimming, chores, and evening waitressing shifts at the Abbey.
-
She learns the restaurant's rhythms under Reese's guidance and shadows Carly, a single mother with pageant ambitions for her daughter Melody.
-
Ryan's estranged parents visit on his birthday, leaving money without speaking to him; Diana learns his backstory from Reese.
-
Diana gives Ryan a birthday card and cashmere socks, transforming their relationship from hostile to supportive.
-
She gains regular customers, including Heavy Flo and Dora Fitzsimmons.
-
In October, Diana adopts Willa, a fearful shelter dog, and the two bond deeply.
-
Diana's physical and emotional health improves through swimming, biking, and steady work.
-
Michael Carmody, the caretaker, arrives to winterize the cottage; Diana verifies him with Dr. Levy before allowing him to work.
-
Michael leaves firewood and homemade dog treats, and Diana finds herself amused despite her resistance.
Character Development
Diana moves from wary outsider to someone with a routine, a job, a savings account, and a dog. The chapter shows her healing through physical activity, steady work, and small connections. Her caution around Michael—refusing to open the door, verifying his identity—shows she still guards her privacy, but her amusement at his stories and her acceptance of his treats suggest she's opening up, however slowly.
Ryan transforms from a hostile coworker into Diana's champion after she shows him kindness on his birthday. His backstory—kicked out at fifteen for wearing his mother's dress, now estranged from his family—adds depth to his abrasive exterior and reinforces the chapter's theme of found family.
Willa mirrors Diana's own journey: fearful, abandoned, and slow to trust, but capable of deep loyalty once given safety and patience.
Michael Carmody enters as a gentle, competent presence. His ease with Willa, his homemade treats, and his matter-of-fact caretaking suggest a man who offers care without demanding anything in return—a contrast to the conditional love Ryan's parents showed.
Themes, Symbols, or Motifs
Found family: The Abbey staff, Reese's birthday party, and the community of washashores and year-rounders all show Diana building a chosen family in place of her estranged biological one.
Abandonment and rescue: Willa's story—found on a beach, possibly abandoned—parallels Diana's own situation. Diana rescues Willa, and Willa's trust helps Diana heal.
Trust and vulnerability: Diana's cautious interactions with Michael, her decision to verify him with Dr. Levy, and her eventual acceptance of his gifts all trace her growing willingness to trust.
Caretaking and maintenance: Michael's job—winterizing houses, keeping pipes from freezing, making sure nothing gets stolen—mirrors the emotional work Diana is doing on herself: preparing for winter, maintaining her new life, protecting what she's built.
Washashore identity: The term, used affectionately by Reese and applied to Diana, captures her status as someone who came to the Cape and stayed, building a new identity in a place that wasn't her origin.
Seasonal change: The shift from summer to winter—bare trees, cold water, empty town—parallels Diana's transition from a summer person to a year-rounder, from a visitor to someone at home.
Why This Chapter Matters
This chapter marks Diana's transformation from a woman in hiding to someone building a life. The routine she establishes—swimming, working, saving money—gives her structure and purpose. Her adoption of Willa is the emotional heart of the chapter: in rescuing a fearful dog, Diana recognizes and begins to heal her own fear. The Ryan subplot deepens the novel's exploration of family estrangement and found family, while Michael Carmody's arrival introduces a new relationship that promises to test Diana's ability to trust. The chapter also establishes the off-season Cape Cod setting—quiet, intimate, and full of year-rounders—that will shape the rest of the novel.
Study Questions and Answers
1. How does Diana's routine in this chapter reflect her emotional state, and what does her adoption of Willa reveal about her?
Diana's routine—morning swims, chores, evening shifts, savings deposits—gives her structure and a sense of control after her upheaval. The physical activity strengthens her body while the steady work rebuilds her confidence. Her adoption of Willa reveals her capacity for empathy: she chooses the most fearful dog in the shelter, the one who reminds her of herself, and patiently earns its trust. In caring for Willa, Diana practices the patience and gentleness she needs to extend to herself.
2. What does Ryan's story contribute to the chapter's themes, and how does Diana's response to it change their relationship?
Ryan's story—kicked out at fifteen for wearing his mother's dress, now estranged from his family—reinforces the theme of family estrangement and the necessity of found family. His parents' annual birthday visits, leaving money but never speaking, show a painful, unresolved wound. Diana's response—a card and cashmere socks, a small kindness on a painful day—transforms Ryan from hostile to supportive. Her empathy for his situation suggests she recognizes a fellow exile, someone who also lost family and built a new life.
3. How does Michael Carmody's arrival test Diana's growth, and what does her response reveal about her progress?
Michael's arrival startles Diana out of her solitary routine and forces her to interact with a stranger. Her caution—refusing to open the door, verifying his identity with Dr. Levy—shows she still maintains boundaries. But her willingness to let him work, her amusement at his stories about Monty, and her acceptance of his firewood and treats show real progress. She doesn't want to be amused, but she can't help it—a sign that her defenses are softening and she's ready to let new people in.
Navigation
-
← Previous Chapter