Chapter 23 Summary, Analysis, and Key Themes

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

You have been warned.

Now, let's dive in.

(If you need a refresher on the previous chapter, see the Chapter 22 summary.)

This chapter is a turning point in Andrew's investigation and his personal relationships, so let's unpack it thoroughly.

We'll start with a chronological summary, then break down key events, character development, themes, and why this chapter matters.

Finally, we'll answer three study questions to help you think critically about the text.

Let's begin.

Summary

The chapter opens on the porch of Sam's house, where Andrew and Sam sit together after their earlier argument.

Andrew, seeking to reciprocate the trust Sam has shown him, offers to show Sam the scar on his back—a long, puckered weal from his childhood cave accident.

Sam examines it and then shares his own history of abuse: at fifteen, his father threw him through a glass storm door, and his grandmother took him in, never to see his parents again.

Andrew, in turn, recounts the full story of the cave incident with Eddie.

He describes how he passed out, woke to find Eddie unresponsive, and had to crawl through a dark, water-filled cave system.

He felt a presence in the cave, something that seemed to want them there, especially Eddie.

When he finally found Eddie, Eddie was not himself—he performed a disturbing ritual, forcing Andrew to drink his blood and whispering incomprehensible words that Andrew felt changing him to his bones.

Andrew explains that the Fulton curse is real, and that after that night he felt dead, like a ghost, for weeks.

Sam listens without judgment, then shares more about his own role as Riley's guardian.

He explains that Riley came to live with their grandmother after being bullied at school and rejected by his religious parents.

Sam feels responsible for Riley, but Andrew gently points out that Riley is grown and not Sam's son.

Sam reluctantly agrees to talk to Riley about his independence, but asks Andrew to keep Riley on the edges of the investigation.

The conversation leaves Andrew drained, and he sleeps on Sam's couch.

The next morning, Andrew returns to his house on Capitol Street.

He does chores—showering, washing dishes, sweeping—to distract himself while he mulls over the curse and Eddie's search for an explanation.

Riley joins him, and after some banter, Riley offers to answer any invasive questions Andrew has.

Andrew asks about Riley's glasses, which Riley finds amusing.

Riley then advises Andrew to attend his classes, warning that he might lose access to resources if he doesn't.

Andrew takes the advice to heart.

Later, Andrew emails Troth and West.

He responds to Troth's earlier warning, mentioning a breakthrough with the McCormicks.

West's emails reveal his frustration with Troth and his concern about Andrew's absence from class.

Andrew, still suspicious of West, agrees to meet with him.

Riley texts Andrew the title of the monograph Eddie was searching for: Appalachian Folk Knowledge and History by E. Gerson, circa 1943.

Andrew spends hours combing the library stacks but finds nothing.

He then meets Troth in her office.

She asks about the McCormick interview, and Andrew admits he did not record it.

Troth is visibly annoyed, stressing the importance of audio recordings for archival work.

She then invites Andrew to a gathering at her home on Friday, where her partner might help with his research into family lore.

Andrew accepts, despite the short notice and his discomfort.

The chapter ends with Andrew leaving Troth's office, feeling steamrolled and uneasy.

Key Events

• Andrew shows Sam his scar and recounts the full cave accident, including Eddie's blood-drinking ritual and the curse's transformation.

• Sam reveals his own abusive past and his role as Riley's guardian, leading to a discussion about Riley's independence.

• Sam agrees to talk to Riley, but asks Andrew to keep Riley out of the investigation.

• Andrew returns home, does chores, and has a conversation with Riley about classes and personal questions.

• Andrew emails Troth and West, and receives the monograph title from Riley.

• Andrew searches the library for the monograph but finds nothing.

• Andrew meets Troth, admits he didn't record the McCormick interview, and accepts an invitation to a Friday gathering.

Character Development

Andrew undergoes significant vulnerability in this chapter.

He voluntarily shows his scar and shares the traumatic details of the cave incident, something he has never fully articulated before.

His admission that he felt like a ghost for a week after the accident reveals the depth of his psychological scarring.

He also shows growth in his interactions with Riley, gently pushing Sam to recognize Riley's adulthood.

However, he remains guarded, especially with Troth, and his suspicion of West continues to grow.

Sam is revealed as a deeply protective figure.

His own history of abuse and his commitment to raising Riley show a man shaped by trauma but determined to break cycles.

His willingness to listen to Andrew without judgment and his eventual agreement to talk to Riley demonstrate his capacity for change, even if he is reluctant.

Riley emerges as a pragmatic and supportive presence.

He offers Andrew a chance to ask questions, but deflects with humor, and his advice about attending classes shows his concern for Andrew's academic standing.

He also provides the crucial monograph title, indicating his involvement in the investigation.

Troth is portrayed as manipulative and career-focused.

Her irritation at Andrew's lack of recording and her forceful invitation to the gathering suggest she is using Andrew for her own academic gain.

Her body language—tapping her nail, pressing her hands to her mouth—hints at hidden motives.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

• The Fulton Curse: The curse is central to this chapter, as Andrew explicitly confirms its reality.

The curse ties Andrew to the land and to Eddie, and its transformative power is described in visceral terms.

• Scar as Symbol: Andrew's scar represents his traumatic past and the lasting physical and psychological marks of the curse.

It also serves as a point of connection between Andrew and Sam, who share their own scars.

• Blood Consumption Ritual: Eddie's forcing Andrew to drink his blood is a disturbing act that binds them together.

It symbolizes the curse's invasive nature and the way trauma is internalized.

• Generational Trauma: Both Andrew and Sam have suffered abuse and family dysfunction.

Sam's story of his father and his grandmother's intervention highlights the cycle of violence and the attempt to break it.

• Domestic Abuse History: Sam's revelation about his father and Riley's own background with religious parents and bullying underscore the theme of family as both a source of harm and protection.

• Transformation by Curse: Andrew describes feeling changed to his bones, suggesting the curse alters not just his body but his identity.

• Feeling of Being Dead: Andrew's confession that he thought he was a ghost for a week reflects his emotional numbness and dissociation from trauma.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is pivotal for several reasons.

First, it provides the most detailed account of the cave accident and the curse's mechanics, giving readers crucial context for understanding Andrew's motivations and the supernatural elements of the story.

Second, it deepens the relationship between Andrew and Sam, establishing a foundation of mutual trust and vulnerability that will likely influence future events.

Third, it advances the investigation: Andrew learns the title of the monograph Eddie was seeking, and his meeting with Troth sets up a potential breakthrough at the Friday gathering.

Finally, the chapter reinforces Andrew's isolation and suspicion, particularly regarding West, while also showing his growing connection to Riley and Sam.

The invitation to Troth's gathering promises to introduce new characters and information, making this chapter a bridge to the next phase of the narrative.

Study Questions and Answers

1. How does Andrew's recounting of the cave accident affect his relationship with Sam?

Andrew's decision to share the full story, including the blood-drinking ritual and his feeling of being dead, creates a bond of mutual vulnerability.

Sam reciprocates by revealing his own abusive past, and the two men find common ground in their trauma.

This exchange allows Sam to see Andrew as more than just Eddie's friend, and it leads to Sam's agreement to talk to Riley.

The trust established here is crucial for their ongoing collaboration.

2. What does the monograph title reveal about Eddie's investigation, and why is Andrew's failure to find it significant?

The monograph, Appalachian Folk Knowledge and History by E. Gerson, suggests Eddie was researching the Fulton curse from a folkloric or historical perspective.

Andrew's inability to locate it in the library indicates that the text is rare or possibly hidden, which could mean Eddie found it elsewhere or that someone removed it.

This failure underscores the difficulty of Andrew's search and hints that the answer may lie outside conventional sources.

3. How does Troth's behavior in this chapter reveal her motivations?

Troth's irritation at Andrew's lack of recording and her insistence on proper archival procedure show her primary concern is academic publication, not Andrew's personal quest.

Her forceful invitation to the gathering, extended only to Andrew, suggests she wants to control the narrative and use his research for her own benefit.

Her body language—tapping her nail, pressing her hands to her mouth—indicates she is hiding something, possibly related to Eddie's death or the curse.

This chapter positions Troth as a potential antagonist or at least a self-interested ally.

Navigation

• Previous: Chapter 22 Summary

• Next: Chapter 24 Summary

• Book Hub: Summer Sons