Chapter 19 Summary

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

⚠️ This chapter contains major plot developments, including a death and revelations about family dynamics. Proceed with caution if you haven't finished the book.

Summary

The chapter opens with Amy visiting Josh's grave, a month or more after Ollie gave birth. She obtains a hand-drawn map from the groundskeeper and walks through the drizzle, feeling compelled to be there. When she finds the headstone, her grief turns to anger, and she briefly imagines kicking it over. She recalls a classmate who died of leukemia, and her guilt resurfaces: she believes that taking Josh to rehab hastened his death. She leaves a wishing stone—a childhood object she and Ollie believed had magical powers—on the grave, remembering how her mother once wished for all her dreams to come true.

Josh's mother picks her up from the cemetery and insists on feeding her a large lunch. His sister and fiancé are present but indifferent. Josh's mother tells Amy she wished Josh had married her. Amy asks to see Josh's room, which feels smaller than she remembered, with the tea stain still on the ceiling. As she leaves, Josh's father returns and drives her to the train station. He gives her a manila envelope containing Josh's Boy Scout sash with six badges, lamenting that Josh never finished anything. He also hands her a shopping bag of food, which later reveals Josh's leather jacket and a book of Walt Whitman poems. Amy reads the poem “As I Lay with My Head in Your Lap Camerado” and realizes that she and Josh were not lovers or best friends but camerados—deep companions on life's journey.

The phone rings: Anita commands Amy to get on the next plane because her father has had another stroke. Amy flies to Florida, where she finds Anita outside the hospital room. Her father is unresponsive, kept alive by tubes. Amy talks to him, recalling childhood memories, and whispers, “Hi Daddy. It's me. Your Bunny.” She and Anita have dinner at a Red Lobster, where Anita insists that her father is a good man. That night, her father dies alone. Ollie arrives the next morning, and they buy a black dress for the funeral, with Ollie deliberately choosing a sleeveless style to defy their mother's memory. They bury him on a humid day. Afterward, Anita reveals that the estate will be split two-thirds to Ollie and one-third to Amy, because Amy has no children. Amy is stunned and hurt, suspecting Anita's influence. She reflects on her strained relationship with her father, wishing she had been kinder after he left her mother.

The narrative then shifts to a flashback of Ollie's severe postpartum depression after Raine's birth. Hunt hires a caretaker named Lillian, who gradually helps Ollie recover by bringing her smoothies, teas, and gentle exercises. Ollie initially refuses to see or nurse the baby, but eventually bonds with Raine. Hunt persuades Ollie to see a psychiatrist, who prescribes lithium—the mood stabilizer Dr. Lucie had recommended years earlier. Ollie agrees to try it, and the explanation that her depression was hormonal brings her relief. She promises to stay on the medication.

The chapter returns to the present: Raine's second birthday party in Los Angeles, a lavish Hollywood affair with ponies, a clown, and a jumping castle. Amy attends, and she and Ollie have grown close, speaking nearly every day. Amy is dating Ian, an architect she met at the pool, though she feels the relationship is temporary. While filling goody bags, Ollie tells Amy she loves her, and Amy struggles to respond in kind. Later, Amy watches Ollie take her medication and reflects on the sister she once saw as a “demon seed.” The chapter ends with Raine asking Amy to read her a bedtime story, and Amy feels a deep, bittersweet love for her sister and niece.

Key Events

Amy visits Josh's grave and leaves a wishing stone, wrestling with guilt over his death.
Josh's parents give Amy his Boy Scout sash, leather jacket, and a book of Whitman poems.
Amy reads “As I Lay with My Head in Your Lap Camerado” and recognizes her bond with Josh as camerados.
Anita calls to report that Amy's father has had a second stroke; Amy flies to Florida.
Amy's father dies alone in the hospital; Ollie arrives, and they bury him.
Anita reveals the estate split: two-thirds to Ollie, one-third to Amy, citing Amy's lack of children.
Flashback: Ollie's postpartum depression, Lillian's care, and Ollie's decision to start lithium.
Raine's second birthday party in LA; Amy and Ollie are close, and Amy reads to Raine.

Character Development

Amy is consumed by survivor's guilt over Josh, believing she signed his death warrant by taking him to rehab. Her visit to the grave shows her inability to forgive herself, but the objects she receives—the sash, jacket, and poems—help her reframe their relationship as one of deep companionship rather than romance. Her father's death forces her to confront her own resentment and regret; she wishes she had been kinder to him. The estate split stings, but she begins to accept her sister's transformation. By the end, Amy is more open to family, even as she struggles to say “I love you” to Ollie.

Ollie undergoes a dramatic arc. Her postpartum depression nearly destroys her, but with Lillian's help and lithium, she stabilizes. She becomes a devoted mother, planning an elaborate birthday party and bonding with Raine. She also softens toward Amy, admitting she gave their mother a hard time and expressing love. Her willingness to take medication marks a major shift from her earlier resistance to treatment.

Hunt emerges as a devoted partner, hiring Lillian and supporting Ollie through her darkest period. He is smitten with Raine and celebrates the family they've become.

Anita remains a complex figure, caring for Amy's father but also making the estate decision that favors Ollie. Amy suspects Anita's influence, but Anita's explanation—that Amy has no children—feels cold and pragmatic.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Grief and survivor's guilt: Amy's visit to Josh's grave and her belief that she caused his death highlight her unresolved guilt.
Wishing stones as childhood magic: The stone Amy leaves on the grave symbolizes lost innocence and the desire to make things right.
Unfinished potential: Josh's Boy Scout sash with only six badges, and his father's comment that he “never finished anything,” underscores the tragedy of a life cut short.
Objects as memory vessels: The leather jacket, the book of poems, and the sash carry Josh's presence and help Amy process her grief.
Camerados: The Whitman poem gives Amy a language for her bond with Josh—neither romantic nor platonic, but a deep, soul-level companionship.
Parental loss and death: Amy's father's death forces her to reckon with her feelings of abandonment and regret.
Inheritance inequality: The estate split reflects family favoritism and the pain of being undervalued.
Postpartum depression and mental illness: Ollie's struggle and recovery highlight the importance of treatment and support.
Sibling reconciliation: Amy and Ollie's growing closeness fulfills their mother's prediction and offers hope for healing.
Redemption through family: Ollie's love for Raine saves her, and the birthday party celebrates the family they've built.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is a turning point for Amy and Ollie's relationship. It brings closure to Josh's story, showing Amy's grief and her eventual understanding of their bond. It also marks the death of Amy's father, forcing her to confront her past and her place in the family. The flashback to Ollie's postpartum depression humanizes her and explains her transformation, making her recovery and the sisters' reconciliation feel earned. The estate split adds a layer of resentment, but the chapter ends on a note of tentative hope as Amy reads to Raine, suggesting that family bonds can be rebuilt.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Amy feel responsible for Josh's death, and how does she cope with that guilt?

Amy believes that taking Josh to rehab hastened his death, and she says she signed his death warrant. She copes by visiting his grave, leaving a wishing stone, and later by accepting the objects his parents give her. Reading the Whitman poem helps her reframe their relationship as camerados, which allows her to see their bond as meaningful without romantic expectations.

2. How does Ollie's postpartum depression change her character, and what role does Lillian play in her recovery?

Ollie's depression makes her withdraw from the baby and her family, but Lillian's patient care—smoothies, teas, gentle exercise—gradually brings her back. Lillian also helps Ollie accept psychiatric treatment, leading to lithium. Ollie's recovery transforms her into a devoted mother and a more empathetic sister, as seen in her apology to Amy and her desire to celebrate Raine's birthday.

3. What does the estate split reveal about Amy's relationship with her father and Anita?

The split—two-thirds to Ollie, one-third to Amy—feels unfair to Amy, especially since Ollie and Hunt have money. Anita's explanation that Amy has no children stings, and Amy suspects Anita's influence. It reveals Amy's sense of being undervalued and her unresolved anger toward her father for leaving her mother. The moment also forces Amy to confront her own regrets about not being kinder to him.

Navigation

← Previous Chapter | Book Hub | Next Chapter →