Chapter summaries Resurrection Walk Michael Connelly

Resurrection Walk Chapter 36: The Sealed DNA Subpoena

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

In Chapter 36, Mickey Haller visits Judge Coelho's courtroom after hours, knowing the court is dark, to request a sealed subpoena duces tecum. He bypasses the clerk, Gian Brown, and pushes the judge's call button to gain access to chambers. Haller explains that an untested piece of a gunshot-residue pad from Lucinda Sanz's original case still exists at Applied Forensics lab. He asks the judge to issue a DNA testing order: collect a DNA swab from Sanz and compare it to the pad's touch DNA. Haller argues that if Sanz's DNA is absent, it will support the claim that the GSR evidence was planted. Judge Coelho warns that a positive result would harm the defense, but Haller insists Sanz is innocent and willing. He also reveals that his home and his investigator's home were broken into, his computer destroyed with maple syrup, as acts of intimidation, justifying the need for a sealed order. Coelho agrees but insists on using U.S. Marshals for chain of custody to avoid later challenges. She prepares the documents. Haller then attempts to ask the judge to reconsider her ruling on Dr. Arslanian's crime re-creation, but Coelho sharply tells him not to push his luck.

Key Events

  • Mickey Haller arrives at the dark courtroom and speaks with clerk Gian Brown.
  • Brown refuses to disturb the judge, so Haller pushes the judge's call button himself.
  • Judge Coelho agrees to see him after the buzzer.
  • Haller presents his request for a sealed subpoena and DNA order regarding the GSR pad.
  • Haller explains his theory that the GSR evidence was planted and that DNA testing will exonerate Sanz.
  • Coelho warns of the risk but Haller confirms both he and Sanz are "all in."
  • Haller reports break-ins at his home and his investigator's home as motive for sealing.
  • Coelho agrees but mandates U.S. Marshals handle DNA collection to maintain chain of custody.
  • Haller exits and attempts to ask about reconsidering the crime re-creation ruling; Coelho refuses.

Character Development

  • Mickey Haller: Demonstrates his aggressive, unorthodox legal tactics by forcing access to the judge. He shows strategic thinking by having built rapport with the clerk over months. Willing to take risks for his client, including possibly damaging evidence. Resolute in his belief in Sanz's innocence.
  • Judge Coelho: Cautious and fair, yet firm. She insists on proper procedures (chain of custody) and won't be swayed by flattery or overreach. Shows dry humor (comment on obsequiousness).
  • Gian Brown: Professional and wary of favoritism, but eventually facilitates Haller's meeting.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

  • Integrity of Evidence: The chapter revolves around a single GSR pad and whether it contains Sanz's DNA. Physical evidence is fragile and its handling can determine guilt or innocence.
  • Intimidation and Obstruction: The break-ins (maple syrup on keyboard) symbolize efforts to hinder the defense without leaving DNA evidence.
  • Risk vs. Reward: Haller and Sanz stake everything on a test that could either prove innocence or confirm guilt.
  • Legal Procedure vs. Expediency: The judge insists on official chain of custody to preserve evidentiary integrity, contrasting with Haller's desire for speed and secrecy.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter is a turning point: Haller secures a court order for potentially exonerating DNA evidence, setting up the climax of the investigation. It also reveals the extent of external pressure on the defense (break-ins) and reinforces Haller's commitment to his client. The sealed nature of the order adds suspense and foreshadows a confrontation when the prosecution learns of the test. The chapter also demonstrates Haller's skill in navigating the legal system and his willingness to take calculated risks.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Mickey Haller want the subpoena and order sealed? Haller fears that if the plan to test the GSR pad becomes known, someone might obstruct justice by stealing or tampering with the evidence. He cites break-ins at his home and his investigator's home where nothing was taken but intimidation was clear (maple syrup on keyboard). A sealed order keeps the test secret until results are obtained.

2. What does Judge Coelho require to maintain chain of custody? She insists that the U.S. Marshals Service handle the collection of Lucinda Sanz's DNA swab and its delivery to the lab. This ensures that the evidence's integrity cannot be challenged later in court, should the test results become part of a legal proceeding.

3. How does Haller's relationship with clerk Gian Brown help him in this chapter? Over six months, Haller has consistently brought motions in person and bought Brown caramel macchiatos, making himself familiar and somewhat liked. Though Brown protests favoritism, he ultimately informs the judge when Haller pushes the call button. This rapport gives Haller a chance to argue his case directly to the judge rather than being turned away.

Navigation