Chapter summaries Our Vicious Oaths N.E. Davenport

Chapter 11 Summary and Analysis

⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This guide contains detailed spoilers for the entire novel. Proceed only if you've finished reading or are comfortable knowing the plot.

Summary

The chapter opens in the Petitions Hall, where Malachi sits on the throne and quietly observes the lord primes during his cousin Cassius's formal challenge for the crown. Malachi takes note of which nobles seem too eager to hear Cassius out, and which ones rarely attend court but have shown up today. Among the latter is Lady Remi Niyarre, the Stone Warden, a notorious recluse. Her presence unsettles Malachi because her daughter, Arrenia, has recently shared his bed on several nights. He wonders whether Arrenia was angling for a queen's crown or weaving a different trap, and he resents not knowing the full scope of the political schemes around him. He recalls that his father's ignorance of such plots led to the former king and queen's deaths, and he is determined not to repeat that mistake.

Malachi tallies seven lord primes he suspects of disloyalty: the heads of the cardinal bloodlines Uma, Tareek, and Windemyr, who rarely came to court and had not welcomed Nychelle's regency or Malachi's ascendancy, plus three of the seven primes who are always embroiled in court politics and who seemed too keen on Cassius's claims. The remaining four of that latter group are still uncertain in their loyalties. The only primes Malachi is certain are loyal are the members of his Cadre, who were elevated to their bloodline heads after the massacre of his father's inner court during the Cleric's Rebellion.

Cassius's speech is interrupted when Malachi's Cadre arrives. Shionne, the lord prime of Bloodline Emarid, immediately confronts Cassius, noting that five lord primes who have the right to witness the challenge are missing. She warns Cassius that his rhetoric is dangerously close to the fanatical speech of the Cleric's Rebellion, which would constitute sedition and forfeit his head. Dedrick jokingly wishes she had let him keep talking. Cassius pivots to a safer attack, accusing Malachi of attempting to assassinate the Hyperion king, Rishaud, and failing. Cassius argues that the Apollyon Court cannot win a war against six courts and that the court needs a ruler who seeks peace rather than war. He proposes ceding part of the Yunna Mountains to Rishaud to entice him into an oath to abandon future invasions, claiming this will spare the court devastation.

Malachi rejects the idea, pointing out that Rishaud has held an agenda of conquest for centuries and that the Apollyonfolk were not easily crushed when he tried to subjugate them. Kiyun offers to give Cassius a history lesson. Cassius insists he does not need one and repeats his proposal, framing it as a way to rid the people of perpetual skirmishes. He then formally challenges Malachi for the throne, charging that Malachi's temperament renders him unfit to rule and that his actions endanger the future of the people and the independence of the court.

Malachi accepts the challenge under the upcoming Half Moon, as is their custom. He then turns to the lord primes and delivers a chilling decree: after the challenge, when he remains king, he will root out all who are unfaithful to the crown, adhering to the old laws that allow execution for seditious intent. He warns that no bloodline is too powerful to be spared, and that those who are disloyal or who uphold the ideas of the Cleric's Rebellion will be put to death. He lingers on Lady Niyarre before departing the hall, leaving Cassius and the primes to consider his words.

Key Events

  • Malachi surveys the lord primes during Cassius's challenge and identifies seven he suspects of disloyalty, including Lady Remi Niyarre.
  • Malachi reflects on his recent nights with Arrenia, Lady Niyarre's daughter, and questions her motives.
  • The Cadre arrives, and Shionne warns Cassius that his rhetoric borders on sedition.
  • Cassius accuses Malachi of failing to assassinate Rishaud and proposes ceding part of the Yunna Mountains to secure peace.
  • Malachi rejects the proposal, citing Rishaud's centuries-long aggression.
  • Cassius formally challenges Malachi for the throne on the grounds of unfit temperament and endangering the court.
  • Malachi accepts the challenge under the upcoming Half Moon and issues a public threat to execute any disloyal lord primes after the challenge.

Character Development

Malachi is shown as a ruler who is acutely aware of the political dangers around him. His internal tally of disloyal primes reveals a paranoid but pragmatic mind, shaped by the deaths of his parents. He is determined not to repeat their mistakes, and his willingness to use spies and his tolerance for them only when he can control them shows a calculating nature. His reaction to Cassius's proposal—flat rejection and a history lesson—demonstrates his refusal to appease an enemy he sees as unchangeable. His final decree, delivered with a frosty glare, underscores his ruthlessness and his commitment to the old laws, even as he threatens to execute powerful nobles.

Cassius is portrayed as a challenger who tries to frame himself as a peacemaker, but his rhetoric is undercut by Shionne's warning about sedition. He pivots from a near-fatal reference to the Cleric's Rebellion to a safer attack on Malachi's failed assassination attempt. His proposal to cede territory reveals a willingness to sacrifice resources for peace, but Malachi dismisses it as naive. Cassius's dramatic sigh and exaggerated speech suggest a performative nature, and his timing of the challenge—when the Cadre was away—shows he is not without cunning.

Shionne serves as the fist of the crown, relishing her role as the one who can brandish a weapon in the Petitions Hall without violating custom. Her warning to Cassius is both a legal threat and a personal pleasure, and her casual formation of a void scythe reinforces her authority. She is loyal to Malachi without question, as are the other Cadre members, who stand ready to defend him.

Lady Remi Niyarre is a silent but significant presence. Her stoicism under Shionne's glare is interpreted by Malachi as overconfidence that Cassius will win, which stacks evidence against her. Her daughter's recent intimacy with Malachi adds a layer of personal betrayal to the political suspicion.

Themes, Symbols, or Motifs

Loyalty and treason dominate the chapter. Malachi's entire assessment of the lord primes is framed around who is loyal and who is not, and his final decree makes treason punishable by death. The Cadre's unquestioning loyalty is contrasted with the uncertain loyalties of the other primes.

War versus appeasement is the central ideological conflict. Cassius argues for ceding territory to avoid war, while Malachi insists that Rishaud's aggression is immutable and that only slaying him can stop it. This debate reflects a broader question about how to deal with an implacable enemy.

Spies and information are a recurring motif. Malachi tolerates spies only when he knows their identity and can control the flow of information. He suspects Arrenia may have been a spy, and he makes a mental note to discover who in the palace is feeding Cassius information.

Tradition and custom are invoked repeatedly. The challenge for the throne follows ancient rules, and Malachi's threat to execute disloyal primes is framed as adherence to old laws. Shionne's ability to brandish a weapon is tied to her official role, a custom that allows her to bypass the usual ban on violence in the hall.

Vengeance and ambition drive Malachi's actions. His refusal to let Cassius speak of his father shows a protective, vengeful streak, and his desire to root out disloyalty is partly motivated by a need to avoid the mistakes that led to his parents' deaths.

Why This Chapter Matters

This chapter sets the stage for the upcoming challenge under the Half Moon, which will determine the fate of the Apollyon throne. It establishes the political landscape: Malachi's suspicions, the identities of potential traitors, and the ideological divide between war and appeasement. The chapter also deepens Malachi's characterization, showing him as a ruler who is both paranoid and decisive, willing to make public threats to maintain control. The introduction of Lady Niyarre as a suspect, and the unresolved question of Arrenia's motives, adds a personal dimension to the political intrigue. The chapter's ending, with Malachi's decree hanging over the hall, raises the stakes for the challenge and foreshadows a violent purge if he survives.

Study Questions and Answers

1. Why does Malachi suspect Lady Remi Niyarre of disloyalty, and what role does her daughter Arrenia play in his suspicions?

Malachi suspects Lady Niyarre because she is a notorious recluse who rarely attends court, yet she showed up for Cassius's challenge. Her stoic reaction to Shionne's warning glare suggests to Malachi that she is overconfident in Cassius's victory. Additionally, her daughter Arrenia has been in Malachi's bed on several nights, and Malachi wonders whether Arrenia was angling for a queen's crown or weaving a different trap. He suspects Arrenia may have been the one who carried information about his Cadre's absence to Cassius, though he has not yet had a chance to question her.

2. What is Cassius's main argument for why Malachi is unfit to rule, and how does Malachi counter it?

Cassius argues that Malachi's failed assassination attempt on the Hyperion king, Rishaud, has invited war and that the Apollyon Court cannot win a war against six courts. He proposes ceding part of the Yunna Mountains to Rishaud to secure an oath of peace. Malachi counters by pointing out that Rishaud has held an agenda of conquest for centuries and that the Apollyonfolk were not easily crushed when he tried to subjugate them. Malachi dismisses the idea that any concession would change Rishaud's mind, implying that only slaying him would work.

3. What warning does Shionne give Cassius, and why is it significant?

Shionne warns Cassius that his rhetoric is dangerously close to the fanatical speech of the Cleric's Rebellion, and that if he crosses that line, it becomes sedition and he forfeits his head. This warning is significant because it establishes a legal boundary: Cassius can challenge Malachi under the traditional rules, but he cannot invoke the ideology of the rebellion that killed Malachi's father. It also shows Shionne's role as the enforcer of the crown and her willingness to use the threat of execution to keep Cassius in check.

Navigation

Published by What Happened?

How this guide was made Report an error